50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Sherborn

“My friends and I rode there on our bikes and we didn’t know they were closing. A man that was working there named Josmer didn’t hesitate to make two pizzas for us all. It was easily one of the best pizzas Ive eaten and I have eaten a lot of pizza. The crust was perfect and the cheese was amazing words can’t describe how awesome it was. We will definitely be going back. He was very kind. Thanks Josmer!!“

“Even though we no longer live in Natick, we still get our pizza, subs, chicken tenders and fries from here every time we are in the area. We love it and so do our kids. Highly recommend!!!“

“Very happy with the food! Been there a few times. It was hot and tasty! Owner greeted me and was very personal. I will be back and recommend trying.“

“Stopped by on our way from Norfolk Ice Arena, and the pizza was the best I've had in long while.

Hot, cheesy, with the smell to die for.
The server (not sure if he was the owner) was nice and helpful.

Will be back.“

“Our go-to sub shop was closed and we needed a quick easy meal after vacation so we tried Famous. The steak sub was one of the best I’ve ever had. There was absolutely no fat or gristle which is rare. My husband had the Italian with everything including hot peppers. It was good his only suggestion was that the balance of veggies to meats was a little off. Communication with the online ordering was excellent and delivery was quicker than quoted. We would definitely order from there again.“

“AMAZING FOOD! And great staff!“

“My experience today was amazing - Nicole was so helpful with ordering and our friends received a delicious hot meal with more than enough for a second meal. Thank you all for taking such good care of our request!“

“Simply a great place for great food!“

“Scott gave us fantastic service! He appeared to be the only server this afternoon but you would never know it—he was so quick and attentive. He put us at a quiet table as requested, then got our order right in, refills on drinks, rolls, and then automatically got us a second pizza to take home as he said the first one didn’t come out the way he wanted it to.. we were so lucky to have him today—thank you Scott for giving us such a wonderful dining experience!!“

“This place has become my go to spot. Full name is Milford Pizza Palace. Absolutely wonderful food and even brighter staff. I swear to you it feels like family greeting me when I walk in. Tons and tons of options, almost everything on the menu has a vegan counterpart. Owner makes own vegan ranch dressing that I can (and have) drink right from the container. They also use specialty vegan cheese only available to restaurants and it is so delicious. I can not recommend this place enough absolute 10/10 gem. Updated from previous review on 2026-05-08“

“Stopped in due to convenient location by our hotel. It's decent pizza, but nothing special. Subs were above average and service was quick and easy. Place is clean and order took less than 15 minutes to prepare so it's pretty fast if you're in the area, but nothing worthy of going out of your way for.“

“The pizza was great! The kids asked to come back the next time we’re in the area. They were impressed with the size of each slice! - Franchesca - Rochester, NY“

“So I want to start by saying Kim was by far the most patient sweetest person. Her customer service skills were amazing I couldn’t have been more satisfied. I’m not from the area so she was patient and explained some of the best options. She was an amazing help. Not only would I come back for the service but the pizza was also wonderful.“

“They are Amazing!!! Food is always great!!! Customer service is always great!!! The owner went out of his way today for us. Thanks so much.“

“Once a week my dad got NHP for us during visitation after the divorce. Also once a year when the wizard of oz was on. BEST pizza and subs! 1970s!“

“We had an issue with Grub Hub, and ended up having the restaurant cancel the order (ordered large but they only had the small dough at the time, which I didn’t think would feed the family, they were very obliging in canceling) we ordered from Papa Gino’s which was more money, and honestly not great, my son (ASD and ARFID) didn’t like it and refused to eat because it was cold. Rocco’s then delivered a large caramelized onion, and gave it to us for free (we owe you a double tip next time, my husband forgot in the confusion). My son immediately dove in eating the onions off the piece and the rest of the piece of pizza. You have made a customer out of us. Not only because of the excellent customer service but the food was very good and reasonably priced. Can’t wait to try some of the other dishes as well, due to the reviews.“

“Had it today for the first time. Plain cheese, perfection! Will be back.“

“I grew up in Detroit off of Buddy’s Pizza. This pizza IS BUDDYs pizza. Legit! Well done!“

“Always went PaPa Ginos it was very good until I went to Sudbury PaPa Ginos. I am there most Saturdays, but the pizza the best, never changes. The young lady that makes them is Niran always the same, she deserves a very big applause because to make it the same takes commitment.“

“Great owners and food. They aim to please“

“Tom’s Pizza has been a local favorite for decades. Consistency truly stands out. Everything is made to order with fresh ingredients and great flavor every time. Their Greek‑style pan pizza is exceptional—easily one of the best I’ve ever had—and the smash burger is top‑tier. I also highly recommend the new Detroit‑style and Sicilian‑style pizzas, which are excellent additions to the Tom’s Pizza Newton menu.“

“I was recommended Marinho's by some people in the gym when I was asking around for a good local calzone... I was absolutely pleased with my purchase the other week (A buffalo chicken calzone w/ bacon) as it was SUPER delicious! A superb first purchase. The dough was phenomenal and the ingredients within the calzone were tasty. Taste and quality wise, this is probably one of, if not, my favorite local calzones around now... Quantity-wise for it's price point, in respect to other places I've gotten take out from, it could be a little larger/heavier! It is a long style of calzone, not wide or round... But taste-wise, Marinho's absolutely takes the crown for me! The dough is what really made this calzone great, as well as all the ingredients within. I recommend giving it a shot, and I may just have to try out their pizza next.“

“Really great food, really nice employees and super fast. Highly recommended, I go here about once a week on my lunch break :)“

“The aptly-named 'Weston' pizza is hands-down the best pizza in the Weston/Wellesley area. A thin crust white pizza with organic baby spinach, sliced cherry tomatoes, caramelized onions, prosciutto and a drizzle of honey...you won't be diappointed!“

“they have been a staple in my family for over 40 years ...“

“Nice place. Good food. Keep it up!“

“The best gluten free pizza ever! The crust was light and fluffy not thin and cardboard tasting. We will be back.😊🍕🇺🇲👍“

“Best food in Town.. i am a loyal customer !! i love the roast beef and the pizza ❤️❤️ customer service excellent🎉“

“🤤 I need a Bianco's closer to Worcester!! Its been over 10 years since I first found them and man I havent found anything close to their buffalo chicken pizza!! This is the place I compare all other pizzas to!

Was craving this my whole pregnancy, finally convinced my bf to take the 2hr drive just for this pizza, now he's down to make the drive weekly 😂“

“Been going to place for a very long, since Polaroid days my absolute Are their Calzones. more specifically is the Italian Calzone, I can eat it all day.“

“I have been coming to the Hearth for many years...the staff is friendly, the atmosphere relaxing and comforting, and the food and beverages are from local sources, well prepared, tasty and satisfying. The owners and management have also shown a dedication to supporting the arts by encouraging local musicians to play at the restaurant. I highly recommend this restaurant.“

“The pizza is amazing!! Besides that I took my 79 yr old father and you can stay and eat. It’s handicap accessible. Bubba’s pizza is out of this world and his staff is so friendly and courteous. I recommend this place to kids and adults of all ages!! ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️“

“the best! lunch dinner, great service, highly recommended“

“Best steak & cheese And Pizza 😍“

“Bluey event was wonderful for the kids and adults. Thanks for great food and fun!“

“We absolutely love this place!! Best pizza in town and awesome sandwiches! People here are great!“

“I celebrated my 60th birthday at this fabulous restaurant this past Saturday. To start when I arrived they had printed out personalized Happy Birthday menus for my self and party of 15. We did a prefixed menu and it was outstanding. The staff and the chef/owner are kind are caring. The food was 5 stars. Everyone in my party raved about the food and customer service all weekend.“

“Went in for a XL pizza at like 8 PM on a Friday night. They were absolutely slammed but even then I only had to wait 10-20 for my order that I had ordered in advance. That’s what happens on Friday nights! XL roni was fantastic. Solid food here.“

“Five Stars all around! HOWEVER, the website is very difficult to read and manuever. Black text on a dark background made it very challenging to place an online order.“

“Disgusting owner says she'll never hire a person with special needs again.“

“Stopped here on an impromptu lunch trip, everything was delicious! Staff was super friendly and gave suggestions on what’s good on the menu. I got a steak & cheese with onions and it was very good!

Restaurant is clean, and prices are decent. Will definitely come back next time I’m in the area!“

“Love LOVE THE FOOD Service was amazing also ❣️⭐🌟🌟🌟🌟🌟 I would suggest it for anyone have a lot of good food to choose from ❣️“

“Supreme is under new ownership and the new team is a delight! Just got a call from one of their staff members ensuring he got my order exactly right and the food was delicious, would recommend!“

“Maria’s has the best food in the area! Friendly service. Highly recommend“

“We ordered the grilled chicken caesar salad and turkey sub with LTO & mayo. It was a simple order, but the ingredients were fresh and delicious! I thought the caesar dressing was really good and the chicken tasted great. I recommend, just make sure to bring cash when you go because that’s all they take.“

“We had an enjoyable dinner at this small, nice restaurant.“

“Their food is amazing. But I got takeout recently and they put their amazing mashed potatoes in a tinfoil package instead of a cup so I had to scrape it out and ended up getting bits in my food. Really weird choice tbh so I took a star off bc the mashed are so good and I wanted all of it.“

“love the food, good crispy fries“

“I’ve never been disappointed ..“

“We’ve been customers of Theo’s House of Pizza for many years, and when the ownership changed a while ago, we were honestly a little skeptical about whether things would stay the same. To our surprise, the quality of the food actually improved. Every meal we’ve ordered since then has been fresh, flavorful, and consistently excellent.

The pizza is always cooked perfectly, the ingredients taste fresh, and the portions are generous. It’s clear that the new ownership takes pride in maintaining high standards and delivering great food. Our entire family loves eating here, and it’s become one of our favorite local spots. It’s not often that a change in ownership leads to an even better experience, but that’s exactly what happened at Theo’s. Highly recommended!!“