25 Best Pizza Restaurants near Williamsburg

“Whether your pizza is made by the owner, the manager, or anyone who works at A-1 Hilltown you can count on a superior pie! My son and I got the buy one get one large pizza deal today and as usual we were not disappointed! The dough was super fresh, they went light on the sauce as requested, and both pies were covered in delicious gooey cheese!!!“

“Their Pizza and treats are to die for. Now I’m not vegan but I am severely lactose intolerant and have not had conventional pizza In a long time. Thanks guys for turning your passion into something that brings me so much joy.“

“I had to drop my car off at LIA Honda and their shuttle driver drop me off downtown. I walked over to Pinocchio‘s got a pepperoni slice with a bottle of water for 550 pizza was fantastic and I am half Italian and it’s delicious for the price. You can’t beat it today. I sat and took my time and I watched all the customers coming in and out buying boxes of pizza and ordering slices and you can see why I will return. I like NOHO downtown nice atmosphere Pinocchio is worth a stop for a quick slice of pizza. Highly recommend it.“

“Fonzie and the crew have been feeding me for nearly 30 years. Never a bad meal, everything on the menu is worth trying. Simple food, fair prices, sit down or take out. My regular orders include pizza, spaghetti dinner, calzones, sandwiches, and salads.“

“Such great pizza. Please don't ever change your ingredients!“

“The food is delicious every time!“

“I highly recommend Joe's Cafe in Northampton for several reasons. First and foremost, they serve the best pizza in town—it's simply unbeatable! The atmosphere at Joe's is welcoming and cozy, making it the perfect spot to enjoy a meal. What truly stands out, though, is the staff; they are incredibly friendly and attentive, always making you feel right at home. If you're looking for an enjoyable dining experience, Joe's Cafe is the place to be!“

“Our go to pizza place for years. Both delivery and eat in is always great.“

“The BEST pizza I have ever had!!! And I’m 77 years old…so I’ve have lots of pizza!!! Thank you. A great experience.“

“Wow, what a fantastic spot for a quick slice! From the moment I stepped in, I was greeted warmly by the owner, who promptly confirmed they offered cheese and pepperoni slices. Though I initially tried to pay with a card, they kindly informed me they only accept cash, directing me to the nearby ATM. Within minutes, my order of four slices, totaling around eight dollars, was served – one neatly packed to go, and the other plated for immediate enjoyment. To top it off, the owner generously included a complimentary can of soda. As I savored my slice, I couldn't help but appreciate the friendly atmosphere, even catching snippets of lively conversation from fellow patrons. A solid 10/10 experience all around!“

“i absolutely love coming here. but right now i have a bone to pick…. i ordered fried raviolis, and when I proceeded to open the box, tell me why I only have 9 raviolis. for $11 you would think there’d be a litttttle more. kinda disappointed. ALSO i ordered a large cheese/half pepperoni and i was charged for a party pizza. come on. very upset. and this is the lightest i’ve ever picked up a order of fried raviolis from you guys“

“Great food and exceptional drinks and the best customer service you could get on a busy Friday night. From the wait staff to the owner, who happened to be the one to greeted our party and made it possible for us to have a table during a last minute misunderstanding 😊. we very much plan to return, and will make proper reservation. 😁“

“IMHO they make the absolutely best sauce.“

“I got the chicken tender & french fry app. They tossed it in buffalo sauce for me. A good amount of food for the price and it was really good! They even plated it up nice. Don't go to Friendly's for chicken tenders, come across the street to Starr's, you'll save money and it's better.“

“Me and husband came for their famous clam bellies. Not only was the portions massive, the cl.bellies were nice and big. They were not chewy or rubbery. The golden brown fry in them was perfect. Not too hard not to soft and it was seasoned perfectly. We started our mean with a freshly made pot of coffee and some warm bread with butter. Shortly afterwards our meal came and it was out of this world. I highly recommend this restaurant and a word of advice, ear your clams there. They will be so much better and maintain their chrispy texture.“

“Just finished dinner at Primo's restaurant and had to comment on the food. From NJ and staying in South Deerfield for vacation. My husband, granddaughter and I stopped in for dinner and we're blown away. Started with calamari that was tender, delicious and enough for 3. Husband had lobster ravioli Ala Mar, large portion, flavorful with buttery cream sauce loaded with shrimp and scallops. Delicious. Granddaughter had Chicken Parmesan that was done to perfection. Large chicken cutlet with plenty of cheese over a bed of pasta with fantastic marina sauce. Mine was Primo Specialty Alfredo, a delicious bowl of Fettuccine with a spicy Alfredo sauce tossed with sausage, chicken, salami, peppers and broccoli. Delicious. If you are in the area, DO NOT pass this place. Service may be slow, but we'll worth the wait.“

“Best bread I’ve ever experienced! I drive an hour every few weeks to stock up my freezer and probably eat it every day. My favorite so far is the Country bread, but all are great Love the cookbook too, very interesting and enjoyable read for anyone who bakes bread.“

“Hillside pizza literally saved our wedding this past weekend. When our family was hit with covid the week before our wedding we had to pivot and make a plan b. If we didn’t cancel our planned catering by a certain time we would risk losing a large amount of money if we ends up with covid. We decided to call hillside which was close to our venue and see if they could help. Daniel was awesome and super accommodating. We were able to order 39 various pizzas all of which were awesome and salad for 105 people. They also accommodated a few of our guests with gluten and dairy intolerance by creating special meals for them. They were able to give us until 8 pm the night before to cancel as we continued to covid test to be sure we were clear. When the pizza arrived it was sent with hot bags tongs for the salad which was so fresh and delicious. All of the dressings and pizzas came with awesome labels. The guests were very satisfied and the food was delicious! Thank you so very much Daniel and hillside pizza!!“

“Highly recommend the salad pizza, especially to others who prefer a higher toppings to crust ratio. It tastes amazing, and I thought it would be soggy the next day since it’s so overloaded with veggies, but the crust held up surprisingly ok!“

“Amazing food & atmosphere. 100000/10🥰“

“Order online to make sure that you get exactly what you want and the best price (coupons). Pizza is always hot and tasty, especially compared to other dominos I’ve been to. I will say they seem maybe understaffed and the mood inside can be a little stressed.“

“The Conway Inn is a quaint place to stop for food and drinks or to hang out with friends. They have 2 pool tables in the back. There is another room with dining tables. It's a limited menu but the food is good. If you like blue grass music the 2nd Friday of every month they have an open jam with some fine local talent.“

“We bought a Car from CURRY Honda Chicopee and it caught on fire after 2000 miles within few weeks we were having a LONG bad day as they refused to take the car back Neither gave us any money back when I come to this place I was hungry exhausted and hopeless I meet a worker here told me leave it on God GOD IS GREAT AND WAIT… thanks for your good word dear worker“

“The Easthampton Diner is the best Restaurant in the world. Not only is Easthampton the best town in the world, but this sweet heart diner is placed perfectly next to the Mountain View. My family and I frequent the diner for our morning brunch. We walk to the park after and obviously stop to see the pond. THE EASTHAMPTON DINER HAS SO MUCH TO OFFER. The menu fits every occasion and person. If you are gluten free they have chili, grilled chicken, salad, baked potatoes, steak, etc. Their cooks are handsome, dedicated, god fearing men. They take such good care of me and always accommodate my requests. The servers are the real heart of the diner. Their personalities are what makes going to the diner so special. It is not uncommon to see one of the servers with a regular. You can really tell because they create friendships with them. Crystal is my favorite. She is a hardworking mother. We have such good conversations. She is like a sister to. me at this point. Grace is a kindhearted, generous, sweet girl. The diner's owner Ahmet is honest. He works hard at the dine. When he sees me he comes over to talk. His family is from Turkey and they are wonderful people. He always makes sure things are just right for his customers. The aesthetic of the diner is perfect. Home town diner. Nothing more, nothing less. The lamp shades are gorgeous Tiffany glass flower chandeliers. The booths offer that homey diner feel. The menu also offers the classics. Any eggs, pancakes, waffles, bacon, sausage, etc. you could want for breakfast items. And I am not kidding you when I say that isn't even like half. For lunch and dinner it's anything you could want. Burgers and fries with a shake? Spaghetti and meatballs with a salad and wine? Ok, do you want garlic break with that? That's why I say this place is the heart of it's town. The Easthampton Diner has great staff, a welcoming and friendly boss, and a satisfying and stimulating menu.“

“Everyone needs to experience Highbrow. You will not be disappointed. All meals are cooked to perfection and only the best ingredients. Menu has so many choices and fun kids meals as well. Very respectful staff and so kind.“