20 Best Pizza Restaurants near Emmitsburg

“We stopped in Emmitsburg for gas and chow, on our way back to NY, and decided to forgo McDonalds for once and get a pie from Carleo’s when we spotted the store front. So glad we did…possibly the best pizza we ever had! We hit the road and ate the whole 16” pie in 10 minutes and were seriously debating on turning around for another.“

“The Italian food at Tuscany's is the best I have had this side of Arthur Street in the Bronx“

“Another great experience at The Ott House on 5/25/25!......food was awesome!.....Oyster sammich with 4 HUGE oysters.....New England clam Chowder.....cheeseburger plate. Our server, Lexi, was on top of everything. Obviously was not her first rodeo.😋 Keep up the good work!“

“We stopped there on the way home because my granddaughter was hungry. They fixed her a salad while we waited for the pizza. All was fresh and wonderful. She loved the salad. The staff there was very pleasant.“

“We met some family for lunch here and were not disappointed. We got a pepperoni pizza and a grilled chicken salad. The pizza was really good. The service was really great too. I was glad they had high chairs, it was a little sticky, but that’s almost anywhere. I wipe it down every time I go anywhere anyway so it’s no biggie. Other than that, it was clean.“

“Family owned and operated, good quality food, great wings, great portions ,great price, good pizza My opinion the best cheese steak sub in Gettysburg.“

“Usually get Italian Cheese Subs. Haven't had one in years since moved out of town. Roll was dry and overheated. Fell apart when trying to eat it. Not enough sauce. Not same quality as previously. Lacked personal experience to product. Used to brag about this being the best Italian Cheese steak anywhere. Not so much anymore. Not sure I would travel to get another one. Sorry“

“My husband and I have been here frequently, we continue to come back. The food is amazing and the staff is so very helpful and friendly. There is nothing bad about this place, I have come to think of them as family with how they treat us. Thanks for always being great. 0“

“if you like Italian food this is the place! Will return as often as possible.“

“The staff at Liberty Mountain Ski Resort recommended King's NY Pizza. My husband and I figured we would try this out. I got a grilled cheese sandwich, which was wonderfully toasted and not heavily buttered! Just delicious!! My husband wanted a sub sandwich which he thoroughly enjoyed as well. Price is reasonable, quality was top notch! I would definitely eat here again and recommend this eatery located in the Market!“

“I work in Gettysburg and our office gets carryout once a week. I ordered the cheesesteak special wrap with a side of fried mushrooms. The food took a little longer than they quoted on the phone, but it was worth the wait. Everything was hot and fresh, we will definitely be ordering again.“

“Food was amazing and the waitress were the best.“

“Food is always delicious and you are treated like family❤️“

“The pizza crust and sauce are out of this world!“

“I just picked up a pizza at Blessing. I ordered through DoorDash for pick up. App said 18-25 minutes. Within 5 minutes of placing the order, I got the notification that it was ready 🤔. Picked up my pizza and it was cold and undercooked. I love Blessing pizza. Hoping it was just an off night 🤷🏼‍♀️“

“My bartender was Bailee she was very friendly and courteous. She kept my drinks flowing and continued to check in with me.“

“This was my second time dining there and food is fresh and tastes excellent“

“my first time ordering from them and even though the food was good I wasn't too impressed. I accidentally typed in the wrong phone number so I had no idea that I did that and nobody text me that my food was on his way and it was taking a while so I checked and my food was sitting outside on my porch cold because nobody bother to knock on my door to tell me that it was here. And when I opened up my food my garlic dipping sauce that I ordered was not included in my package. Again good food just no dipping sauce nobody told me that my food was sitting outside“

“Merry a worker there chase me down to return my credit card very "heartening" so thanks“

“We had dinner with friends. Everything was excellent and a great value. Staff was very friendly and helpful. Food, Pizza and Subs, were all wonderful. Highly recommended.“