50 Best Italian Restaurants near Millersville

“IYKYN…there’s nothing like the unique taste of a Ledo’s pizza! The sauce is amazing and the toppings are tasty and fresh. The crust is thin and crispy, and of course, square. I ordered takeout and it was ready for pickup when I arrived. Fantastic in every way.“

“The food is absolutely amazing….pricey but worth it! Better than Little Italy quality.“

“it was the highlight of my day to come to Carrabba's with my wife. We were nearby and always come to Carrabba's for our favorite dish. Fettuccine Carrabba! It's the best and the people that work here in Pasadena are the sweetest most accommodating out of all of them. I love the atmosphere, the cleanliness, the service and the food. The manager "Ben" is fantastic too!“

“The food, atmosphere and service were all excellent. I would really like to get the chef's recipe for the cream of crab. It was the best.“

“Went for the first time yesterday and I don’t know why I waited so long?!?! It’s only because I didn’t know about them! My new fav spot!!! Happy hour is the best! Portions are huge and you feel the love in every bite. The staff was so friendly and welcoming. We had Annie at the bar and she was amazing! Can’t wait to go back!“

“Amazing food! Hand made pasta! What?! Hidden gem in Edgewater. Will be a regular.“

“Never disappointed. Food always very good.“

“Great customer service, quick service good food“

“The best sandwich The Italian!! Whenever we are in the area, we stop and get them.“

“No one will say from the ambiance that this place is not fine dining. The cuisine they have, the ambiance, the staff, the music—I could go on and on about it.“

“we love this place!! 5 stars all day every day!“

“It’s the best pizza and pasta In town !!!“

“Many thanks to Pasticcio Fresh Italian Kitchen for working with St. Mary’s Lacrosse for their Christmas game. Pasticcio made it easy to feed over 130 people today.“

“Local fresh Italian dishes w Monday pizza Specials $5 off. Nightly board specials w homemade sauces, pastas w seafood, chicken, meat. Nice clean atmosphere w self serve free drink refills+ fresh brewed tea. Sister restaurant to original Bella Italia in Annapolis.“

“Soooo I came here on my lunch break.. i just wanted something better than a burger but not so pricey .. ohh man I took a chance and try the chicken veggie soup…that soup was so flavorful and good .. I just had to share .. it’s summer time and i decided hot soup 😩.. but sooo good I will be back for more“

“We tried Italia’s based off recommendations and we are so satisfied. The pizza was fantastic!! The gluten-free was great for my husband. I’m new to the area and prefer local vs chain restaurants for pizza. Totally recommend this for pizza. I can’t wait to dine in for other dishes!“

“Was in the area and was told this is the pizza place of all places. All my friends know I take my pizza pretty seriously. Met with the owner (helluva great guy) and it is a pizza worth a 12hr drive.“

“We had delivery at our motel. Wish we were staying longer because we would definitely order again. The Buffalo jumbo Wings and Chicken Quesadilla were delicious. Delivery prompt.“

“First time here and i was impressed. I got the itallian sub to test the waters. Let me tell you, it's the best i've had in the DMV and to me the ulitmate test of freshness you can expect from a restaurant. The bread, homeade and delicious. The ingredients, fresh. Thanks for a great sammy-- i will certainly be back to try other menu items.“

“Italian Chicken Cheesesteak is the best!“

“We had an amazing experience! Food was great and we loved it! Our server Udiel C was very friendly, attentive and we experienced a very wonderful dinner served by him. Especially with our kids, he was very friendly and made our kids feel welcome!“

“Quality matters !!! Ordered for the first time tonight. Amazing and fresh !!! Highly recommend !!!“

“Anthony’s NY Pizza & Pasta House was truly a 10/10 dining experience. From the warm welcome at the door to the attentive service throughout the meal, everything was exceptional. We started with a Caesar salad and complimentary freshly baked bread with butter, which set the tone perfectly. We ordered the white pizza and the filet mignon, and both were outstanding. The pizza was cooked to perfection—the crust alone was incredible—and the flavor was on point. The wine selection was also excellent and paired well with the meal.

I would highly recommend Anthony’s to anyone looking for high-quality food and great service. I’ll definitely be returning!“

“I love la Posta ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️Tasty food and good Service.“

“Wonderful, wonderful experience! Not only did we have a good experience on Thursday night with our basketball team, but when we called again on Friday they remembered us. Commented on how well behaved our school was. We ended up ordering 15 pizzas for Friday night, they gave us 20 bucks off and carried all 15 pizzas to the car for us. We will definitely be back! Bayview Seahawks thank you.“

“Hands-down best pizza in town!!!“

“Best menu around the Pasadena area“

“Wonderful experience recommend tom.“

“We had excellent food with good service. Our waiter was very friendly and we had no problem with our orders. Nay the manager in training was so thoughtful and friendly. I was trying to help my dad from his chair and he eneded up falling to the ground. She came over quickly saw that everything was ok and tried to help my dad from the floor . I am so grateful she was there. No other manager ever tried to help my dad before. She was the only manger in training to thank us for training. She should become a manager. She deserves it. This happened around 4pm on Sunday 9/27/26.“

“Took the little one for some pie. Mondays special is a $10, 16” cheese pizza. Awesome NY style pizza, cooked perfectly. Really enjoyed the light, crispy crust. The restaurant was clean and the staff very friendly. Had a wonderful meal and some one on one time with the kid.“

“As a transplanted New Yorker, finding great pizza can be a challenge. But, Little Carmine’s has their pizza DOWN PAT! Highly recommend ☺️☺️“

“Great food, quiet hideaway 😊“

“After we heard Carmelo’s was open again, we ran over for a hot slice out of the oven and it did not disappoint! Just as I remembered, not too thin, but perfectly crisp crust on the bottom, great tangy sauce, and perfect amount of cheese. The penne arabiatta was a hit as well as the garlic knots. We will definitely be back!“

“Great place, great food and super entertainment all through the week!“

“It really does feel like an Italian Market. Food and drink to eat or take out as well as goods to prepare meals. Great wine selection and wine tastings. Never had a bad meal. You order at the counter and they give you a number. Only time I felt like it was a little skimpy was rice balls. Great taste and sauce but a tad light. In about 7 yrs I did pay for something that was either picked up by mistake by someone else or forgotten and received a little attitude. I still go back because it is consistent.“

“I always call to request garlic butter and the owner is sooooo kind and patient. He is such a sweetheart and the food is damn good! Great way to break my fast and it’s worth the starving lol . Please support this business, I promise you won’t regret it. The pizza is simply to best in the area. My goodness!“

“Great fresh salads and delicious calzones“

“Had a surprise 50th Birthday for my best friend last weekend. The food, staff and atmosphere was amazing. All the guests loved the food. Our server Shailesh, he set up the food, cleaned up and was there for any questions and concerns I had during the party. They did an excellent job and I would highly recommend having any type of gathering or celebration at this restaurant. The price per person was responsible for the food and service provided.“

“Great food Great atmosphere“

“Really nice restaurant with classic & chill vibe. This place feels like a classic & non-industrialized, everything felt homemade. Italian ice was also an amazing price with generous portions, will return to give another attempt. Chicken Parmesan 7/10 Chicken Guido 8/10“

“I don’t leave reviews often but have been to this location about 5 times and the service from the staff was excellent and pizza is great, particularly the Detroit pizza which I usually don’t like because it’s too much bread but their versions is amazing with a good char on the crust. The 2 slice lunch special with a soda for $9 is a decent deal now a days“

“Great food good service and atmosphere“

“First time ordering today got the chicken quesadilla very very good“

“The service was great! My food came out in a timly manor and my cup was always full! The food was wonderful! I had a bbq chicken pizza and side salad. The house dressing was so good, i had to buy one for the house! The kiddos loved it too. Little Tim lived his chicken tenders and fries! 10/10 recommend!!“

“I grew up in South Jersey, where family-owned pizza spots are everywhere, so I’ve always been picky about pizza. Pizza City honestly brought back a lot of great memories for me. The pizza was amazing definitely 10/10 Jersey vibes.

The place also has that warm, local family-owned atmosphere that makes you feel welcome right away.“

“This is typically our go-to Ledo Pizza location. Leaving this 5-star review to reflect the great service we got the other night! We placed an order for pickup only about 10 minutes before they closed. I know this was probably an inconvenience for the kitchen and managers, but they had our order ready quickly and were very welcoming and provided great service - even at the end of the night. Thank you!“

“I ordered delivery from here last night and it was the BOMB. The driver was super quick and very sweet, gave her an extra 5 for making sure my food was hot since other places are always warm. I WILL be ordering again. I never had better goat curry! 🙌🏾🙌🏾“

“Long time customer that has been very happy with the friendliness of the staff! Very good thin crust pizza and the toppings are delicious, fresh and plentiful! We have been using their Too Many Monday Meals specials for many months!!!“

“I love there service and the food my favorite pizza and wings“

“I wouldn’t normally order a pasta dish from a pizza and sub shop, but I’m glad I gave it a try. The shrimp alfredo was a massive portion, delicious and came with a yummy side salad and bread for a little over $20. The italian dressing was top notch too. So good and such a good deal. Even my almost one year old loved it 🙂“