New American Restaurants near Buxton, ME

1 The Mustard Public House

4.9 Superb 10 Reviews

1420 Long Plains Road, Buxton

“Thrilled to have another dining option in this area; judging by how busy it was Sunday evening I'm not the only one! All the members of staff we interacted with were very friendly. We liked the MPH burger and loaded fries but the star of the show was the black forest cheesecake. MPH black forest cheesecake is now ranked #2 on my list of Best Desserts I've Ever Eaten, usurping the long held position of the original recipe Maggiano's butter cake with seared grapes (it's not the same now) and second only to a tiramisu I had in Paris in 2016. Big news: gluten free bun that doesn't disintograte the second you touch it!!! If you try to take it home as leftovers it does, but I think that's reasonable. We will be back, and hopefully soon because I want to try the pumpkin martini.”

2 MK KITCHEN

4.8 Superb 513 Reviews

2 School Street, Gorham · 4.77 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Sharing a few words about our incredible dinner recently. I had the best Bolognese ever. The Caprese salad was amazing as well. My lovely lady raved about the salmon she had. And the service was outstanding. Outstanding experience in every possible way. Thank you! We will be back soon!”

3 Paloma's Restaurant

4.7 Superb 263 Reviews

15 B E Grand Avenue, Old Orchard Beach · 11 miles

• Take-Out

“Fresh and delicious! Have a margarita! ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️”

4 Joseph's By the Sea

4.3 Superb 392 Reviews

55 West Grand Avenue, Old Orchard Beach · 11.25 miles

• Delivery

“What a great find! Booked a table after reading the reviews. The meal was perfect, the new to us cocktail was potent and delicious, the servers were amazing, the owner was gracious. Thank you Barb, Dot and Dawn. We will be returning next year at the same time to celebrate my 70th!! Seems it will only allow 1 picture.”

5 Bell Buoy Restaurant

4.1 Good 312 Reviews

24 Old Orchard Street, Old Orchard Beach · 11.03 miles

• Take-Out

“I come specifically to Old Orchard Beach every year just to eat at The Bell Buoy. They serve the best seafood and are very closely located to the pier and beach. You can’t go wrong with anything on the menu, but the lobster is a huge selling point. Friendly staff, great food, good service, and a mere walking distance from many of the other attractions. I cannot recommend this place enough, and hope it remains open forever.”

6 Dewey's

3.6 Good 65 Reviews

15 Old Orchard Street, Old Orchard Beach · 11.09 miles

“Best homemade clam cakes around!”

7 Sunset Bar & Grill

3.9 Good 189 Reviews

4 Fernald Street, Old Orchard Beach · 11.2 miles

• Take-Out

“Fried chicken burger and hamburger where delicious. Our server was sweet but running around ragged. We had to wait quite a bit for everything. Live music was good. The outside chairs were a bit uncomfortable but the atmosphere made up for it.”