6 Best American Restaurants near Cornish

“Taylor was Fabulously humorous. As our waitress she made our dining experience fun. We'll be back!“

“Sadly THIS IS NOT THE SAME BAY HAVEN YOU REMEMBER OR THAT PEOPLE RECOMMEND!!!! imagine my surprise when I opened the app to write this review and see that my review from five years ago was the first one on here that you can see below. I couldn't say enough about how good everything was. And had been years before!
My new experience: i had my son meet me there. He had never been so we could get a twin lobster, dinner and some steamers, and the sides, and I decided what the heck and or did us both a shrimp and scarlet plate to go. For a grand total of over three hundred dollars, which I would not mind paying if everything had been wonderful. But it was not. I'm including a picture of the shrimp and Scala plate that went to my home and my son's was exactly the same cause. Neither one of us opened until we got home. And this is what we found for I believe $38. You can look at the menu. It's around 38. The worst part is. I got home late at night. Looked at my dinner and couldn't believe it was all overcooked. It was horrible. I called the restaurant and spoke with a woman who claimed to be the manager who told me that I had waited too long to call. It was during the week or it was towards the next weekend. Because I work 8- 5 every day. And when I called, they told me that the owners were on vacation and the most she could do is give me credit for another time. I said, are you kidding? You think I want to come back and have this experience again. I was honest with her and told her even though they were really tiny. The twin lobster dinner was delicious. Our steamers were delicious. Our chowder was delicious. But the orders, the take home orders that were already packaged in the bag. That we didn't get to see until we got home. You judge for yourself. As I said, i'm including the pictures, I wouldn't waste the time gas money anything to go to this place again. I tried calling and get a hold of owners again. I left my phone number. Nobody called me back. They don't care!! It's that simple. So for two dishes that cost thirty something dollars. They would rather have people write these type of reviews and warn everybody not to eat there anymore. Because it's not what people think it is. Oh, and she did tell me that the pictures she said they're stock pictures. They're not the seafood platter that's what it used to look like ginormous. And if you look on there, the shrimp are huge. I tried telling her the shrimp are always, and she said, oh no, well, you haven't been here in more than a couple years because we've been, we switched to the small shrimp a long time ago... are you even kidding me? This is what you tell a patron of your restaurant?? So much for customer service or carrying what your patrons enjoy. They're just looking to take any anybody with money. That's stupid enough to leave it there, I guess. And I was one of them. It truly is sad. I'm going to also add a picture of my seafood that I get from my local pizza place in laconia, new hampshire. That is ridiculously visually a hundred times better than what you see here from Bay haven. And there's almost nothing in the container & the bay haven shrimp looks like it came out of a can. Or the tiny frozen ones from the the grocery store.

Old review:
Hidden Gem!! Excellent food, service, portions &pricing. Phenomenal perfectly cooked seafood. Ordered the seafood platter, twice baked potato, cup of lobster stew, steamers and husband had Fried Haddock dinner. Everything was excellent, it was our 1st time here and it's worth the drive and wait for a table because they are busy = All around excellent experience!! Haven't tried their non fried or other dishes next time will try their prime rib surf and turf. Our waitress Christina was excellent!“

“Food was great. Drinks were great. Staff were friendly and quick. Great dining experience.“

“3 of us went for a late lunch the the grill on Saturday. got a lot of apps. Most was good, the mushrooms, a great salad and the scallops were good. We got a shrimp app wrapped in bacon. that was bad. the shrimp was bad. the outside looked fully cooked, but shrimp was raw inside. I ate 1 and my sister ate one. I got very upset stomach where i had to get to a bathroom fast. Sister not as sick, but grossed out by it, as she ate one. My othe sister cut into it and put right down, did not eat it. We should have said something, as they won't know if ya don't say anything, and why did i pay for that? my bad. I need to speak up. The shrimp also may have been old. I really wanted to go for the dinner menu, maybe give another try, not sure. service was good, or quick. we also got buffalo fingers, did not care for the buffalo sauce, so noone ate those. we got 3 deserts, creme broule was the best, very good, chocolate cake was dry and tiramisu was not a tiramisu, it was a sweet cream cake, did not like that. Atmosphere was nice. lplace was clean. This was a special occasion for us 3 sisters, so we had good family time, Just watch out for the shrimp“

“Delicious fare and friendly service! we love this spot!“

“Great place to get a burger and chicken tenders!“