11 Best American Restaurants in Gaylord

Bennethum's Northern Inn American • $$$
3917 Old US Hwy 27 S, Gaylord

Customers` Favorites

St Elmo's Style Shrimp Cocktail
French Onion Soup Au Gratin
Asian Glazed Boneless Wings
Parmesan Encrusted Walleye
Wild Mushroom Bisque
Filet Mignon Sliders
Salzburg Schnitzel
Tomahawk Pork Chop
Lake Perch

“We just experienced our new fav restaurant up north. Bennethum’s has it in spades.Classy, casual diningWelcoming rustic decor, tasteful done.Top notch serveExcellent menuAbsolutely delicious foodMushroom soup in a bowl big enough for two grown folks.Ribs on point - Salmon tender and delicious.The best asparagus I have ever had.Of course we gonna try the desserts....Yep that Oreo Peanut Butter pie melts in your mouth.Highly recommend Bennethum’s Northern Inn“

4.7 Superb271 Reviews
Snowbelt Brewing Co. Brewery • $$
132 W Main St, Gaylord

“This place is amazing. I've tried three food options and all are exactly what I needed. Beer is great. Service is very friendly.We come back every time we are on our way to treetops. Try the "my chest hurts" ipa if you like iPas. It's fantastic.“

4.4 Superb62 Reviews
KARMA TAPROOM Bar • $
138 W Main St Suite A, Gaylord

“Absolutely WONDERFUL place in town. Clean, friendly staff, great priced drinks! The atmosphere is everything. I will never step foot inside Tim’s again after discovering this place. This place does NOT serve food but you are free to order from the local restaurants in town and bring it in and that to me is awesome! Small businesses supporting small businesses. The owner and his wife are almost always there and they are great people too! If you haven’t been into Karma, you need to try it! Hidden gem of Gaylord.“

4.6 Superb33 Reviews
Cops & Doughnuts Jay's Precinct Coffee & Tea • $
1151 S Otsego Ave, Gaylord

Customers` Favorites

Blueberry Paczki
Cake Doughnut
Bakery

“This is our best donut find, so far, for Northern Michigan. Unlike Tim's around the corner, they use a good amount of filling on their lunch sticks and eclairs. They have a pretty decent variety of doughnuts in addition to other guilty pleasures like breads and cookies. Buy everything fresh made today or off the day-old rack. You can also fill out an order form and return another time. The prices are in line and the people are friendly. The shoppe isn't very big but I've never seen a large crowd. It's a must stop when we're down here. 01/24“

4.3 Superb64 Reviews
Michaywé Pines Golf Course American • $$
1535 Opal Lake Rd, Gaylord

“Played Treetops, The Tribute and The Pines. Greens here were the best. Kudos to the greens staff as this course was maintained very well. A fun course to play that is very fair if you stay out of the trees. Great sandwich at the turn and reasonable beverage prices. A great time at a great course??“

4.5 Superb32 Reviews
ALPINE TAVERN & EATERY Bar & Grill • $
220 S Otsego Ave #1, Gaylord

Customers` Favorites

Smothered Brisket Dip & Swiss
Brisket Grilled Cheese
Crab Stuffed Whitefish
Pulled Pork Sandwich
Beer Battered Perch
Sweet Potato Fries
Pulled Pork Nachos
Firecracker Burger
Chicken Wings
Fried Pickles

“Second time we've eaten at the Alpine. Food was very good for a Tavern style restaurant and our service was great. The background music was a bit loud, which detracts from the atmosphere. Recommend the brisket grilled cheese sandwich.!“

4.1 Good97 Reviews
Culver’s American • $
1397 W Main St, Gaylord

Customers` Favorites

Butterburger Deluxe Cheeseburger
Cod Dinner Fries and Cole Slaw
French Fries and Cheese Curds
Chicken Sandwich Deluxe Combo
Butter Burger and Fries
Sourdough Butter Burger
Mushroom Swiss Burger
Single Butter Burger
Deluxe Butter Burger
Fish and Chips

“Food is always good...never had a bad meal at Culver's in Petoskey or Gaylord....only a suggestion for Gaylord store .. it is nearly March 1st and beautiful weather....you still have Christmas decorations....time for Spring decor....it is pretty...but out of season.“

4 Good88 Reviews
Mooney's Ice Cream Parlor American • $
601 S Otsego Ave, Gaylord

“Best ice cream ever! If you grew up in Michigan, odds are Mooney ice cream is a favorite. They continue to add more great flavors over the years plus continuing the traditional favorites like Blue Moon and Superman ‍♂️ I had coffee with chocolate shavings. It was great. I'll be back next summer for more.“

4 Good34 Reviews
Michaywé Inn The Woods Restaurant American • $$
1535 Opal Lake Rd, Gaylord

Customers` Favorites

Italian Grinder
Whitefish
Perch

“Although busy they tried hard and when my order came out wrong they immediately fixed it and the Manager was quick to check in and offer apologies. Food and drinks were great and we thoroughly enjoyed the cheers like atmosphere in the bar area.“

4 Good23 Reviews
Porter Haus Bar & Grill • $$
3885 Old Hwy 27 S, Gaylord

Customers` Favorites

Ooey Gooey Hot Fudge Brownie Ala Mode
Mary's Kielbasa Dip
Porter Haus Nachos
French Dip Sandwich
Smoke Haus Burger
Prime Rib Dinner
Prime Rib Tacos
Boneless Wings
Shrimp Tacos
Loaded Fries

“This place was very good. The look the atmosphere the servers the drinks and the food were outstanding. I would give this place more then 5 stars if I could. We will be back for dinner choices and try different drinks. I have found my new place to eat. We have a mission. Try there special drinks. Very tasty. We will be back. Thanks for the great service.“

3.9 Good109 Reviews
Legends on the Hill American • $$
625 Resort Blvd Suite A, Gaylord

“Had the place to ourselves on a Sunday fall evening. My filet was good, however it had mushrooms piled on it which wasn’t listed on the menu. My wife’s salmon tasted over-powering and a bit dry. Our waitress and bartender were friendly! They had a nice bonfire going outside. Colors were great on the hill!“

3.8 Good13 Reviews
Loading...
map Map