28 Best Pizza Restaurants in Kalamazoo

“Great food and service!!“

“best pizza around they truly make everything here with love and im so thankful I had the opportunity to find this hidden gem in kalamazoo.“

“The pizza was good but dry in my opinion and could use more sauce and cheese. We got the meat lovers thin crust. I would rate it 3.5 out of 5.“

“Hands down best pizza in the area!“

“So I've always loved this Blaze, and it's been one of my late pizza-calls... Buuuuut, as with any relationship...sometimes things can take a slight turn..and sometimes they can even go a bit....sour....and by things...I mean chicken 😬

So, Long story long, My partner and I each ordered a build your own salad, and idk... I'd like to think I'm not really the jealous type but when my salad arrived, it didn't take long to notice something definitely seemed, well.....a bit fishy. 🥴Don't get me wrong, I love a good traditional Caesar dressing made with anchovies, I'm also the opposite of picky...that said I don't like my chicken coming home late smelling like bad decisions.

anyhoodles, ALL this just to say that when I called and reported the situation, Shelby, the manager on duty, was SO very understanding and immediately (after confirming I wasn't just a dummy about the dressing) offered to make it right. My partner and I ended up having a great night with great food (sans anything chicken) and fell asleep content with a great (not fishy) taste in our mouths.

thanks again, and to Mr./Mrs. Blaze, please make sure to give Shelby all the props (and promotions 🤷‍♂️) she deserves 🤗“

“Met the owner through my retail workplace. Got to talking about his restaurant and how I’d never tried it since not being from the area, amongst other things. This man brought lunch back to us and the pizza was PHENOMENAL!!! Thank you again sir!!! Bbq Chicken pizza is highly recommended, minus the pineapple (unless you’re into that sort of thing!) lol“

“The yummiest slice I’ve had in as long as I can remember. 🍕 Will definitely be back!“

“Met the owner through my retail workplace. Got to talking about his restaurant and how I’d never tried it since not being from the area, amongst other things. This man brought lunch back to us and the pizza was PHENOMENAL!!! Thank you again sir!!! Bbq Chicken pizza is highly recommended, minus the pineapple (unless you’re into that sort of thing!) lol“

“Simply the best. Always great.“

“I cannot say enough good things about Bilbo's! We hosted a party of about 50 people there (sight unseen because we're not local). They made it so easy and so nice. Our friends and family commented multiple times about how great the space was and how good the food was. Our servers were impeccable, and Jake & Raegan the owners made the planning & night go smoothly! We had the section of the restaurant with pool tables & a pinball machine, too. It was perfect! Delicious food, great service, perfect set up! What are you waiting for? Check them out!“

“Just found this place.....I like it!“

“Really good pizza at really good price.“

“We ordered a pizza online and picked it up right on time. I was surprised when I realize the pizza place is in a gas station. Fresh off the oven, friendly staff greeted me and I brought it to our hotel room. (We are just passing through) I must say it was the BEST chicken bacon ranch thin crust we ever had. WOW!“

“I go here every so often to get a sandwich usually. Im a huge pizza guy but never tried it, finally did last night and man am I disappointed in myself. This is by FAR some of the best non deep dish pizza ive EVER had. Ill be a returning a lot more often.“

“Omg this is of my favorite place to get food .Those wings amazing Kevin C was very friendly just love his energy when we first came in..Just keep up the great and keep those amazing sandwiches coming“

“Great atmosphere. Good food.“

“Love my Jets, they always deliver on the best pizza in town. The options are all great choices, and I don't think there has been a single thing I wouldn't recommend. Whenever me and my friends get together for a game or some other gathering, we get Jets.

Vegetarian options: Salads, non meat toppings

Dietary restrictions: Gluten Free“

“Normally I don’t get angry over restaurants - I get it customers suck , some times staff sucks , I get that okay but what I’m not happy with is the pure audacity that DRIVERS haveI placed an online order last night and paid for it in full on my debit card - now I did not have the extra funds to leave a tip and I know that sucks but not every one is going to tip DRIVERS ARE AWARE OF THIS BEFORE ACCEPTING THE DAMN JOB.That being said nothing was wrong with my food it came just as I ordered it — the driver - Warren was his name - was friendly when I talked with himThe problem however lies in the fact that this afternoon my debit card was charged for an extra $5.00 and made my account go negative .. now every one is going to say oh it’s just $5.00 let the driver be — no cuz is the bank going to just let me be and not make me pay the fee for my account going negative ? No they are not so $5.00 just turned into $40.00 all because some one felt entitled to a tipEven though dominos drivers are paid in tips AND hourly he still felt the need to have more — embodying greedI call the store to address my problems and I’m told — we hold a $5.00 on the card — now if I was naive I would probably eventually just be like okay I guess sure fine — but seeing how I use to work there as an assistant manager less than 5 months ago as well as have placed other online orders prior to this one with no “ extra fee “ — I know better that has never been a thing — not for online orders or in store orders — then I get told by “ the manager “ that answered the phone Im alone and have food I need to be making - so I’ll do this when I have a chance but that driver does not work today — and unfortunately I’m failing to see how either of those things are my concern ?? You are the manager I am the customer and my customer concern is just as important as the next so thank you Jo - that’s her name - for making a customer feel like your not listening or even caring because your store is short staffedYou may not have lost me as a customer but for Christ sake - do better make it right and treat every customer and their concern the same“

“The pizza here is AMAZING!!! My absolute favorite is the BBQ chicken pizza. Best in town, hands down!!! The people working here are so nice and friendly. They will get your order done right and fast!!!! Not only that, but the delivery drivers are really good too! They deliver quickly to your house and follow instructions!!! I will always recommend Cottage Inn Pizza to my friends and Family!! Thank you for being amazing!!“

“First time visiting. Had a smash burger and fries. It was an excellent burger. The taste made my mouth come alive“

“This location is serving up wonderfully fresh and hot pizza! Love the 3 cheeser bread!! I’ve ordered 3 times in the last week! Yes, it had some issues a couple years ago, but over the last 18 months I have gotten nothing but awesome pizzas. Whatever changes needed to be done were done.“

“the Chinese food was excellent and would get the tacos again“

“Fun music venue and great pizza.“

“Most excellent service and the food is amazing. I recommend the cajan crust flavor Chicago style pizza. Very friendly crew working there. I really like going there. 5 Stars to this place. See you again soon.

Parking: Very convenient“

“Excellent old time classic venue with good brews and food on the north side of Kalamazoo.“

“Really good pizza at a decent price, always fills my stomach.“

“the only thing I would say bad about it, is they can't cut a pizza to save their lives. every time we order, we have to cut it ourselves as it's either not deep enough of a cut or not cut at all 🙄😒 can't always fault them especially when they get busy but it's not hard to cut it properly“

“amazing atmosphere! super fun to watch the hockey playoffs.“