17 Best American Restaurants in New Baltimore

“Such a cute place! Very friendly owner.“

“We always look forward to our dinner at Fin's when we are in town. Great service, great food and great drinks! We recommend it to all our guests as well!“

“What a great place with really good food. My tacos were amazing.“

“good food, great breakfasts, good prices, and always great service. I highly recommend breakfast.“

“Thank you for your support we work hard to make everything and everyone happy long hours pay off when I see comments like this it makes it All worth it“

“I believe our waitress was lizzie. she did a great job, food was really good to. will definitely be back to see lizzie 🙃“

“Service with a smile. Sliders were perfect. French fries are by far the best I’ve had. Pepsi had the perfect fizz. Great experience we will be back for those hand battered fried mushrooms 🍄‍🟫“

“great staff food was real good medium on price but large portions for price military friendly“

“We had a great Coney Island style breakfast here. Waitress and other wait staff were very nice. They had only a handful of omelettes to choose from but all solid breakfast choices. Eggies were as ordered. Good shredded hash browns and good ranch. Will return.“

“Friendly Service. Great Homemade Food .. Biscuits and Gravy are Delicious 😋“

“The food and service was great ❤️“

“1st time visit this past wknd. Could certainly use some updating but the one very large update needs to be serving draft beer in an actual GLASS… Ive never been served a beer in a hard plastic cup (?)much less 32oz.. I ended up ordering bottles after that… Also, the menu was paired way down cause it was a band night.. We arrived 1 1/2hrs prior to band so full menu should have been available… Do better is all I can say…“

“Our server was very friendly. She gave us great service! Sorry I can’t remember her nam“

“Heather is the greatest!!! Not only is she a great bartender but she also double duty’s it with doing karaoke at the same time! Service was fast, drinks were great. My wife and I kicked off our anniversary here and Had a good time. We’ll be back soon!“

“awesome place really enjoyed the burger friendly owner“

“Saw them on FOX2 Sunday 9/7, the food looked really tasty, then they showed their wings. Got the 25 for $25 and....THEY HAVE THE ABSOLUTE BEST. We haven't had takeout wings THIS DELICIOUS in literally years. The Savvy Sauce was good paired with, but we never had it and it had a heavy dill herb flavor to us. Still delicious, when we order again (addicted!) we're going to try a different sauce. So glad they have such awesome chicken so close to home!!!“

“Leo’s Coney Island in Chesterfield is more than just a place to eat. it’s an experience that keeps you coming back. From the moment you walk in, you’re greeted with warm smiles and a welcoming atmosphere that feels like home. The staff is friendly, attentive, and always ready to make sure your visit is perfect. Whether you’re stopping by for a quick bite or sitting down with family and friends, the environment makes you feel comfortable and relaxed. The food at Leo’s is consistently delicious and always hits the spot. Their menu has something for everyone, from classic Coney dogs and gyros to hearty breakfasts, fresh salads, and comfort food favorites. Everything is made fresh and served with generous portions that leave you full and satisfied. You can taste the care and quality in every dish, making it a go-to spot for any meal of the day. What really sets Leo’s Coney Island in Chesterfield apart is the sense of community. It’s the kind of place where regulars are known by name and new customers are treated like old friends. Whether it’s a weekend breakfast tradition or a late-night dinner after a long day, Leo’s brings people together with great food, great service, and a great atmosphere. It’s truly a local gem that always delivers an amazing dining experience.“