13 Best American Restaurants in New Buffalo

“Last dined at Skips in January 2026 , let me say this , first biggest complaint is that after looking at my credit statement I saw that they tacked on an extra $20 charge on my credit card without my permission , after questioning them they did remove the charge , second the food was fair at best , I ordered the Walleye which I'm not sure it was even Walleye , it tasted and looked more like Tilapia ( 2 small filets ) , wife had the Salmon which she said was just ok . I bragged about this place to the others that were with us and they agreed it was nothing to write home about , ,will I go back to Skips , no but they probably don't carel“

“Absolutely amazing experience. The service was outstanding from start to finish — attentive, friendly, and professional without being overbearing. The food was incredible, full of flavor, and clearly made with quality ingredients. Every dish came out fresh and perfectly prepared.

The atmosphere was just right — perfect lighting, comfortable vibe, and a great setting whether you’re there for a date night or dinner with friends. You can tell they put thought into every detail.

Highly recommend. I’ll definitely be back.“

“We didn’t expect our experience at Timbers to be so enjoyable. We were so surprised at how nice, fun and helpful the staff was. The food was good (pizza, salad & cheesesteak sandwich) and prices weren’t too bad. Just can’t say enough about the dining staff, great job!!“

“AMAZING ICE CREAM!! Also the staff is so welcoming and helpful!! Definitely more friendly than the rainbow cone. I will bring my family here over the other peace!! Thank you guys“

“I have been going to The Stray Dog for years. I have never had a bad experience there. The food is great and the service is superb! Also, if any of the ladies out there need a "personal plumber", I am available to service your unfulfilled fantasies.“

“Starting with the staff unbelievable efficient, friendly and very personable! As for the dinner it was one of the best we have had in years everything was very fresh and cooked to perfection! We highly recommend this restaurant it will be a delightful experience a well worth every penny! Truly enjoyed!“

“ordered garlic bagel toasted with cream cheese & veggies…Delish…loved the crunch… do you sell bagels by dozen for take home?“

“Absolutely wonderful! We will definitely be going back. Great food and service with a lovely atmosphere.“

“Love the new bar since the remodel! Great people, staff, and drinks 😉!“

“⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️I've been coming to Casey's for years. Always great food and service. This summer we had Adam as our server, each time we ate there. This guy is great! I highly recommend Casey's and definitely ask for Adam. He goes above and beyond! Even made sure on our last night to have sweet tea for us! Thank you ! Hope to see you next summer!“

“It wouldn't let me post my review unless I said I recommend...People need to be warned. Apparently if you are not a regular, they will give your table to one of them even if you reserved months in advance. Hostess and Manager do not value out of owner business so go somewhere else. The only option I could choose was "slow service" but wait staff were better than management.“

“I love their bison burgers with extra goat cheese and their banana daiquiris are absolutely delicious!“

“The buffet was good, but I think they put way too much pepper on the food. There’s a lot of people out there cannot have pepper … that’s why you put salt and pepper shakers on the table so people could put the salt and pepper on the food by themselves. The cooks put way too much pepper on the food especially the mashed potatoes. Don’t need to do that. Nobody else does that.“