Italian Restaurants near Stillwater

“Delicious, fresh, hand made pizza. We love patronizing this local establishment. We'll definitely be back!“

“Great experience, food was excellent and service was amazing! Andres recommended great appetizers and wine. He was very welcoming, knowledgeable, and made us feel at home! Highly recommend!“

“Great pizza! Friendly staff. Will be back for sure!“

“****do NOT recommend**** Waited 10 minutes for our table only to see that literally only a handful of table were being used. Ok fine… then waited over 20 minutes to be greeted by our waiter. Order an app and our entrees. Then waited literally over an hour for our app to come out and 30 seconds for our entrees. Hostess tells me “it is what it is” and Manager acted as if it wasn’t a big deal that literally we’d been there for almost an hour and a half waiting!!!! Tyler apologies and takes the blame but management only takes a measly appetizer off our bill. We order two pizzas which came out cold and raw and an app and she only takes off an app. Worst place ever. Disappointed!!! Only thing this place had going for it was the view aside from that everything else wasn’t worth our time“

“Sweet atmosphere! Delicious food. The wine is unlike any menu in the area! Service was SO awesome! Love this little place. I felt absolutely elated to finally visit Olio. Olive Oil ice cream! Short Rib! Italian wine. 🍷Ciao!“

“My daughter and son in law visited Sunday, May 25th, 2025. Everything, with the exception of salad and Tour of Italy was awful. I had Create Pasta with Mushroom Sauce. Terrible watery, no flavor. Daughter had Zupa Toscan which was tasteless and watery. Her entree was Chicken Margarita flavorless with many green peppers on top. Such a disappointment for a reputed good eatery.“

“Friendly staff and very kind! Doubled checked time for my in store order and made sure it was ok with me, also threw in a free beverage for my son and I!! Thanks awesome people!“

“Our experience from start to finish was great! Pam S., our waitress, was attentive, not hovering. She knew what we needed before we did. Our grandchildren were with us and their food, as requested, came out first. The food can’t get better and the prices are fair for the portion size. Always a great spot to get great food!“

“Brinley put her soul into an avocado piada. I came a little late to pick up my order and was expecting a cooler more soggy piada but I was left speechless tonight. The wrap, chicken, and vegetables were crisp, the sauces perfectly placed with great proportions and the warmth still resonating. She deserves a raise.“