44 Best Pizza Restaurants near Eureka

“It is definitely old-school style! It was once a drugstore from back-in-the-day and has been Primo's for the past 20+ years. The staff was very friendly and courteous, and my food was BEYOND exemplary — totally fantastic! My burger was hot and juicy and fresh off the grill, and the French fries were piping hot and tasty! I recommend highly!! And .... don't walk out the door without a milkshake!!“

“This pizza is incredible. Cannot believe that I got it from a gas station“

“Fast and great pizza and friendly delivery“

“They didn't get my order right but charged me for it. Service was bland, and the atmosphere was ok , I seen people with out protection gear for customers food.

Kid-friendliness: Yes

Wheelchair accessibility: Yes“

“I worked at 2 pizza places as a teenager so I’m the last person to criticize what they do… at the same time my daughter and I went in on a Friday night and somehow my online order was overlooked. Everyone in the store was accommodating and one worker in particular (I’m sorry I didn’t get the name) went above and beyond to make my child happy. He overheard her talking about flipping the dough and gave her a small piece to play with while we waited and then gave her a soda to make up for our order being “lost” as we watched everyone else come and go with their orders. Not only was I more than willing to wait with understanding, but I also had my child complaining when we had to leave because she wanted to stay longer. Thank you for the little things!“

“Been years ago in old town eureka it's on Watson? Had steak Tuscany Steak and Shrimp Cocktail never had pizza! Funny waitress spilled salad all over customer oops! There was a flood and Jo Boccardi sold? pizza out of a truck! Never had pizza!“

“This place was pretty good. It’s definitely the classic St.Louis style pizza with provel cheese, which i happen to be very familiar with being from the city. Kind of has the IMOs kind of vibe to it. Pizza sauce was perfect not too sweet not too spicy. All the ingredients were fresh, and the pizza crust was really crispy. Will be coming back to try other options on menu“

“Great food and great staff!“

“Service was amazing, food was deliciously yummy! There was a mix up with our order (it happens, we're all human!)... they went above and beyond to correct the mix up. 1st time customer. I really appreciate the service and quality of the food (fyi the place was packed when we showed up, so I can't be the only one who thinks so haha)“

“Best pizza I have found since moving to STL four years ago! But not just the best here. One of the best ever!“

“Outstanding flavor! Loved the sauce and the cheese...everything!“

“This was a great place for a quick pizza. We went at 5:20PM on a Friday and we're able to be seated immediately. Staff was super friendly!
We tried the Alabama shaker pizza and it was AMAZING. Pickles on pizza should be way more available! Unlike most pizza places there was only 1 TV so beware if you're hoping to watch the game while eating, it'll have to be on your phone. The prices were a little steep for a thin crust, but it was a cute joint and worth it for a casual date night.“

“We were celebrating our daughter receiving her Ph D. This place was highly recommended. Had a WONDERFUL experience. The food was fabulous. The staff extremely friendly. Nice wide open space. Being in the business. I was watching the other staffs interaction with guests and other co workers. EXCELLENT VIBE in the house. HIGHLY recommend. All in All. Guests Staff. Food. Cleanliness. Home Run. Great Job 👊👊👍👍“

“Amazingly positive and great staff, cracking jokes and gave us free drinks as well as great service. The food was amazing as always and the atmosphere of this place was incredible!! 10/10 I would make the drive just to come again. Keep it up y'all are awesome.

Kid-friendliness: Very kid friendly, arcade games and aquariums as well as TV.“

“I was passing thru MO on I-44. I saw sign for Imo's. I get an Imo's Pizza every trip to/thru MO. I had never been to the Pacific location. It was the best Imo's Pizza I have EVER had, & I have had many!!! Manager Amber was so helpful & kind. I was tired from driving all day from OK, where I had just finished a dog-sit, on my way to a MO dog-sit. The staff were very nice. It was my best experience in all the visits to an Imo's!!!! My trip continued with me being tired, but full & uplifted by my wonderful experience!! Thank you Amber for your kindness & generosity & uplifting attitude!!!“

“Staff was friendly and fast. Clean. Great deals!!! VERY fresh ingredients

Vegetarian options: Absolutely LOVE the gourmet vegetarian pizza!! I'm not a vegetarian, but this is my FAVORITE pizza! Delicious!

Kid-friendliness: LOVE the mini-Murphy where my daughter can make her own little pizza. She looks forward to it!“

“The wait was a bit long but well worth it. Staff was very kind and it was some good pizza“

“We haven't been since our kids were little but now that we have grandkids it's a great place for a rainy day. Lots of games for all ages and they have a large area for parties or large groups. The salad bar is pretty standard as is the pizza. And every so off Chucky comes out and takes pictures with the kids.“

“It is either Jesses or papa johns, doesnt take a rocket scientist to figure out who to call. Food is great as well, best cheeseburger around for the money.“

“Cons
1. The bar stools are far too close together.
2. Even though I was given an extra half pour for the extra long wait in getting my (1) order of wings, which I appreciate greatly, it still took far too long to get my (1) order of wings.
3. No Laphroaig, please stock Laphroaig.

Pros
1. The Kickin' Buffalo wings are out of sight (especially with a Rumple Minze shooter)
2. The bar staff are phenomenal (should actually be #1)
3. Very excellent choice of beers on tap
4. Keep rocking it Kerry“

“I'm too afraid to pick up a pizza from here because their drivers act like it's their first day behind the wheel every time they're whipping in and out of that lot. a couple pieces in the passenger seat doesn't change the skills required to operate a vehicle safely boys“

“Out of towner here from a place with terrible pizza (Appleton WI). I'm sold on Imo's and very happy at the moment, munching this thin crust. I don't think I've ever had a pizza this thin, it's fantastic, sauce is on point as is the cheese and toppings. The toasted ravs are the best I've had in STL yet, I tried a place on the Hill and thought they were ok but yours are clearly better.

Place was clean, staff is pleasant.“

“Family owed and very friendly family! Great food“

“I VERY rarely give 5 stars. I ordered the Sweet Heat pizza and was blown away. This was easily top 5 pizzas I've ever had. I genuinely can't wait to come back to the St Louis area just for the pizza. If you are in the area, this is a MUST GO!“

“My go to place when I want to have some fun! There’s never a dull moment at twisted pixels! The staff is fantastic and the regulars are great too! Whether it’s a trivia night, bingo night or karaoke night, it’s always a blast! If you’re in the area and haven’t checked it out yet, it’s a must! Get on in and check it out!“

“Candicci’s catered our wedding, and it was everything we hoped for and more! We heard tons of praise from guests saying it’s the best food they’ve ever had at a wedding! Every single dish was delicious, and the portions were generous. Every guest was full and happy! Jeff was super responsive, communicative, and easy to work with. They gave us a free tasting before we booked so we knew exactly what we’d be getting. The whole catering team was professional and accommodating, especially with dietary restrictions. They were also very affordable! I cannot recommend Candicci’s enough!“

“Always made to order. I have dairy and gluten allergy in the family. The pizzas always come out perfect. Hot and delicious. Thanks Dominos pizza staff for such a great job.

Dietary restrictions: If you ask, they will try.“

“We got there very late and close to close and we were saying we were going to leave so they could close up but they were very hospitable and insistent that we stay, and we did. Extremely friendly staff and can't wait to frequent and go back.“

“Amazing pizza! Best lasagna! Great staff! 5 Stars!“

“Consistently good STL style pizza and sides, fast polite delivery staff. 👍👍“

“My favorite place for a burger in West County. Beer is cold and staff is friendly. Good healthy options if you’re into that kind of thing. Golf simulators, but remember to make a “tee time” which is easy to do via their website.“

“We called in our order ahead of time. They said that there would be a 30 minute wave which was not too bad we went somewhere else first and then we came and picked up our pizza and we did the person that answered the window he was very nice and polite. Great experience!“

“On July 12, got two orders of the hot honey chicken tender sandwich. They were overcooked and were hard and dried out. The last time I had them, they were cooked just right and very tender. Lately, I feel it is hit or miss.“

“The food was delicious! Our server was Carol and she was absolutely amazing!! Very attentive, cheerful, fun and organized!! I will definitely return the next time I'm in town!! Definitely a 10/10 experience!“

“Amazing service and really good food! Thank you so much!“

“Great food and staff! Very attentive“

“If you’re like me, you like crispy, thin crust pizza with fresh ingredients and MOZZARELLA cheese. This place delivers! This was some of the best thin crust pizza I’ve had in the area. I ordered a bacon/pineapple and sausage/pepperoni. Both were so delicious we were fighting over the last few slices.

I had a rough experience my first time as they were struggling with a short staff. I originally posted a poor review and the owner reached out to me personally. The owner was super cool and apologized for the experience and offered me a gift card. Their response totally turned around my experience and impression. I will most certainly come back! Excellent pizza and excellent service.“

“Very nice woman working the takeout counter, she was friendly and helpful. We just went inside to pick up our carryout order that was placed through the Pizza Hut app. Only downside would be that the quality of the food has went downhill as far as the large pizzas we got definitely looked more like medium pizzas and there was hardly any toppings on it which unfortunately seems to be the way most places have been doing to save money the last few years. All in all it was ok.“

“Amazing pizza! Best lasagna! Great staff! 5 Stars!“

“I’ll be real—walking in, I wasn’t sure what to expect. The place has lost the vibe it used to have: no tables, no pinball…feels more like a waiting room than a wing joint. Definitely miss the old energy and the breaded wings from back in the day. BUT credit where it’s due: the staff was super friendly, and those wings? 🔥🔥🔥 Absolutely hit the spot. I threw a little salt on them and they went from good to straight-up bangers. If you’re in it for the flavor and not the ambiance, this place still delivers. Would love to see them bring back some of the old charm, but for now? Still worth the stop.“

“I don't normally order pizza from any pizza place. I am usually disappointed and I am price sensitive. I decided to do Domino's because they are running a special. I ordered a specialty pizza with some extra fixings on it. Probably one of the best pizzas I've had in years. the vegetables were perfect especially the chunky tomatoes. large chunks of moist chicken and just the right amount of cheese on my favorite thin crust. I just could not stop eating this great pizza. the gal Autumn at the cash register was very friendly also.“

“Don't really understand the bad reviews. We've had good experiences each of the half dozen times or so we've had Marcos. I always find the staff friendly and our orders have always been correct. Really appreciate the later hours too!“

“Papa John’s is a national chain and consistent with the product they put out. It is a solid pizza choice. The reason for my 4 star rating is how fast and efficient they were on a Saturday night. My food was delivered in 25 minutes by friendly team member. With starving kiddos traveling in St. Louis. Much appreciated“

“I love their limited edition pretzel pizza it's the only place that has cheese sauce instead of pizza sauce that makes pretzel pizza and it's the only reason I go here and they only have it once a year. This year they stepped it up and added a stuffed cheesy crust to the pretzel pizza and it's a game changer!! Love it!! They need to make it permanent and I'd visit more often.“