24 Best Italian Restaurants in Springfield

“⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ A Perfect Night at Retro Metro! From the moment we walked in, we were greeted by two lovely ladies who made us feel right at home. The ambiance was warm and inviting, with a cozy yet vibrant energy that set the stage for an amazing evening. Our waiter, **Dillon**, was new but absolutely fantastic—attentive, quick, and so eager to learn while providing excellent service. **The drinks were a highlight!** My espresso martini was *divine*—rich, smooth, and almost like a dessert with what tasted like a hint of chocolate at the center. My fiancé’s smoked old fashioned (made with **Blanton’s**) was **next-level good**—bold, perfectly balanced, and so flavorful. For starters, the **calamari** was cooked *perfectly*—crispy, tender, and not rubbery at all. I had the Major crossing medallions and he had the Ribeye. Both seared to perfection with amazing flavor. The garlic butter mashed potatoes, well let me say I could have eaten a whole bowl of them! The chocolate chip cookies were the cherry on top! Oh and the chef came out to say hello because duh, the food was amazeballs and customer service was top tier! Overall, **Retro Metro exceeded every expectation**. We can’t wait to come back!“

“All I can say is mmmmmm….everything we had was absolutely delicious. And the service was exceptional for our party! Definitely will be going back for more!“

“NYE was outstanding! Nicola and his lovely wife are so friendly and welcoming. The food was wonderful and our waitress was superb! Highly recommend!“

“Went to this lovely restaurant on Wednesday 19 April for dinner. Our server Mike was extremely friendly and helpful. Food was excellent and so pleased to see a real carbonara on the menu. Dessert was to die for. Had never seen or heard of a Sans Rival cake before but pastry chef, Sophia did a fantastic job with this delicious dessert. Can highly recommend this restaurant and if we’re ever travelling through Springfield again will definitely go here again.“

“Just love the food and atmosphere is nice to be in“

“We were in Springfield for a basketball tournament. Unsure of where to dine, we discovered a well-known establishment and were thrilled to eat there with my family. Upon arrival without a reservation, we were seated promptly, appreciative of the kind service and the staff's remarkable knowledge. Everyone exhibited exceptional kindness, and as a discerning diner, I found the spaghetti, bread, calamari, salad, and all dishes outstanding. My husband ordered the fried lasagna, which was promptly delivered to our table, fresh and hot. The staff's kindness was impressive, creating an atmosphere I truly appreciate, and we intend to return. Thank you for hosting us and treating our family with such consideration, which means a great deal, as it appears to be a very popular destination! I loved that the owner brought out our food and spoke to his customers. This is one of the best Italian restaurants I’ve ever been to! Thank you, Nonna’s Italian Cafe.“

“Incredibly happy with my meal! So accommodating to allergies! I was able to enjoy a fabulous dish replaced with dairy substitutions (oatmilk and plant butter). I haven’t had such a lovely meal out since having my diagnosis. Thank you Gilardi’s!“

“Just had a lunch special,the portions were perfect,staff very friendly and helpful. Will definitely eat here again.“

“Classic clean dishes, and the best steaks in town!“

“Thanks for the excellent catering order yesterday. It was delicious! We always have excellent food and service here. Just wish they gave a Veterans discount.“

“Literally the BEST buffet I've ever been to. All of the food is delicious, and the staff are friendly and provided excellent service! 10/10 would come here again. I recommend trying the Creme Brulee Cake- it's the best I've ever had!“

“Ott’s Pasta Catered our band banquet at Mt. Vernon Missouri. The food was fantastic, piping hot, creamy Italian for the salad was fantastic as well. Highly recommended. It was delicious!“

“Just love the food and atmosphere is nice to be in“

“Just love the food and atmosphere is nice to be in“

“Loving the food, so happy to celebrate the simple Wedding Monthsary today...“

“This is our favorite pizza place in town!“

“I recently dined at Olive Garden and had a fantastic experience. Our server, Noe W., provided outstanding service—he was professional, polite, and attentive to every detail. He truly deserves a bonus for his excellent manners and dedication.

The food was great, especially the Chicken Alfredo, which was creamy, rich, and perfectly seasoned. The Seafood Alfredo was also a standout, with a generous portion of shrimp and scallops in a smooth, flavorful sauce. The Shrimp and Chicken Carbonara had the perfect balance of smoky bacon, tender chicken, and shrimp in a delicious, cheesy sauce. Every dish was fresh, hot, and well-prepared.

The only downside is the prices, which I personally find too high. However, I understand that inflation has affected everything. Hopefully, they’ll come down in the future.

I really hope that management sees this and rewards Noe W. with a raise or a special bonus. His service truly made the experience exceptional, and he deserves to be recognized for it.“

“Hands down the best pizza place in Springfield. A little more expensive than the chain places but more than makes up for it in the quality of their food. They do have seating in the restaurant but it is a little limited so be aware of that if you're gonna bring a large group.“

“Our waitress was amazing; so knowledgeable and patient with all of our questions. Atmosphere and decor was welcoming. Food was fantastic!“

“Sad to hear it closed, loved that place. No more pizza inns in the area now“

“We stopped by today for lunch! Our server was fantastic! She was so attentive and friendly! The subs and crab cakes were delicious! The banana cake was phenomenal! Loved all the cross country and track pictures! Brought back memories of my High School years! We will definitely be back!!“

“Will definitely be going back here. Got a piece of their cheese pizza and it was cooked just like they do in New York. Would highly recommend if you miss New York pizza.“

“Always a great experience“

“We have not found a pizza place we like anywhere in this small town. And we do love our out west Pizza Hut and this one here and only this location is a blast of awesome food from the past. The employees were awesome, the cleanliness of the restaurant was awesome and the food on multiple occasions now, has been perfect. I am sooooo happy, this town finally got a awesome Pizza Hut back in place. Stay awesome ( West Sunshine location) Pizza Hut!

Dietary restrictions: I'm allergic to everything and I have Alpha Gal on top of it. It's almost impossible to stay alive. But guess what, your food saved my life.“