15 Best Pizza Restaurants near Manteo

“Straight from the pizza palaces of yesteryear is Garden Deli & Pizzaria. Delicious pizza, great wings, and perfect mozzarella sticks are a plenty here. There is also a sweet black cat outside; a sign of the kind and skilled people who operate the establishment.“

“Unfortunately I stopped in on a day they were short staffed. The restaurant was clean and the manager was nice. She is hiring if you are local or in the area for off-season. I had a pepperoni personal pan, which I have not had in years. It was decent. I will stop in again soon.“

“The hubs and little are Vanilla ice cream conisours and the gentleman that attended us at the window convinced them to try new flavors by getting a double scoop which was awesome. While we tried the vanilla, cookies n cream, salted carmel, butter pecan, and strawberry cheesecake. We all agree that hands down the Strawberry Cheesecake was the best...“

“Had the pleasure of eating there last night with a group of friends. The Smashburger’s were off the chart. The service was fantastic and the food delicious. Would definitely definitely go back 👍👍👍“

“First time having Nags Head Pizza Company! Quick delivery and some of the BEST pizza in OBX! Pizza is thin and doesn’t come loaded with sauce which is perfect! Absolutely loved the positive affirmations on each box!! This place ABSOLUTELY does it right! Will definitely be ordering again!“

“The best pizza on obx. Consider switching to Follow your heart vegan mozzarella! It’s way better than daiya wayyyy better :)“

“Everything is super excellent, the only detail is the girl who answers the phone line, you never understand what she says and she doesn't even want to talk to answer, it bothers me to place orders when she is on duty but otherwise everything is super excellent“

“Delicious pizza and the salads are the best!!! The best service ♥️“

“I want to commend the staff and management. Tonight I sat for a while waiting for my pizza and although it had been a very long day and it seemed like I constantly was being held up trying to get home, these workers were great. They were very friendly and kept their composure like they always do when I am in there and witness the impatient and rude behavior of others. Especially a group that seemed to think that just because there was 1 table there that it meant it was a sit down restaurant that should have been at their beck and call. Clearly allot of people get pizza there every night so it is hard to keep their warmer full. Personally I prefer getting it nice and hot:) Even with the rude mutterings not so quietly thrown their way they remained friendly and were constantly working and pleasant. So yet again I commend them and I am thankful for the military service of the owner and am glad they are able to post it proudly on their window.“

“Great pizza. Kind of unorthodox size, 28", but it was one of, if not the best carry out pizza I've had. 1 slice is like 2 regular slices, the price was good too. 5 stars!“

“Ordered the bbq chicken and supreme pizzas with extra cheese tonight. Delicious!! Both had great flavor and it tasted like all of the toppings marinated well with each other making both pizzas taste really good. Can’t wait to order again.“

“A cozy little pizzeria with great food and staff. The use of fresh ingredients really shines through. 10/10 recommend!“

“The redhead male that works here must be Superman. He legit does everything by himself with a positive spirit!
He greeted us, took our order, answered the phones, made the food, brought it to us, clean the dishes, did a curbside order and also took time to chit chat to give that great customer service!

I hope he owns this place, if not. He should! He sure runs with pride as if he owns it!

Great service, food was out fast, it was delicious, and reasonable priced.

10/10 would recommend this place!“

“Stopped in and enjoyed a Barbecue Chicken Pizza with my wife while here on vacation and I think we found our new favorite pizza in the OBX. Excellent crust!“