19 Best Pizza Restaurants near Oak Island

“First slice! Thanks to the staff for his surprise!“

“Great pizza; great service!“

“Just had dinner there. Enjoyed speaking with the brewer about his creations. Grat food-had pesto pinwheels. Crust perfect. Highly recommend you check it out!“

“Have come here from time to time over the years. Great bar. Food was good but Now? Expanded menu. Great specials. I’m a foodie. Many places I’ve ate trying many typical sports bar food and have my favorite burger places. Today the wife and I stopped in. First off friendly bar staff. I decided on the Carolina Burger. Added a patty. Here to say I’ve had many good burgers. But this was my favorite hands down and the FF were the best. Truly was. Cheese. Onions. Chili. Slaw. Mustard. Added Texas Pete and pepper. Messy but not crazy. Stayed together. Asked extra crispy on FF. As I always do. Thry actually did. We decided this would be our lunch stop when down. Met owner. Solid. Bartenders. Solid. So don’t come here lol. 😂“

“I was on Oak Island for a vacation. I ordered my pizza on a Saturday night, knowing in advance that it would take longer than normal. When I went to the location, I could see that the team was working as hard as they could to get all the orders out. I understood that it would take 30 to 40 more minutes for me to get my pizza. The team was working hard, they were upbeat and positive, and fun to watch. What annoyed me were visitors that came to the location expecting their pizzas to be done in 15 minutes. I saw visitors, walking to the register and literally getting into an argument with the employee that was working there. People were walking out with 8 to 10 pizzas each while other people expected their one or two pizzas to be done in 15 minutes. My pizza was hot, tasty, and made exactly as I ordered it. The next time I come back to Oak Island, I will definitely order another pizza from Domino’s.“

“Absolutely phenomenal margarita pizza - easily the best I’ve ever had. Don’t skip the hummingbird cake, it is house made and to die for!“

“Our weekly favorite. The two piece special and Greek Salad.“

“I have tried the pizza, pasta, & subs. They were all great! The desserts are awesome too.“

“Excellent pizza almost as good as Ct's Pepe's which is where I learned about great pizza. 2 areas of improvement needed. 1) spread sauce and toppings farther out on the crust. 2) Cook the crust longer to get it brown or more cooked instead of soft. Needs crunch.“

“The very best place for pizza, subs and wings in the surrounding area. Very good food & service. Do yourself a favor and check them out and see for yourself!!!!.“

“I have been a big fan of Mo’s Pizza for years. Today I tried some other menu options and was completely blown away. The pasta and marinara are excellent. The vegetables are well prepared and fresh. They are not heavily sauced but rely on their natural flavor. The roasted potatoes were exceptional. Service was very friendly, prompt and professional. A real plus is being able to get a first rate meal without having to sit in traffic for an hour. Plenty of free parking more bonus points! Highly recommended!“

“First time here. I had a take out, and I ordered the spaghetti. Its very basic, and the sauce tasted like it came out of a bottle, no favor, and the noobles needed salt. I only eat what I could, and threw out the rest in the garbage. As for the restaurant itself, it needs be renovated. Looks like an old pizza hut from the 80's.“

“Best cheese steak I ever had! Loved the cheesecake too! Thank you!“

“Awesome pizza. Awesome spaghetti and meatballs. Awesome stromboli. Haley is the best server hands down. Tastes just like the previously closed Angelos.“

“the Chinese food was excellent and would get the tacos again“

“I went in and grabbed a hot n ready three meat pizza and paid for it, when I was walking to my truck I looked at the sticker which said sell by 4:36 and it was 4:09. The box was barely warm and since they switched from the boxes you could see into there's no way to tell what it looks like til you open the box.
So I got to my truck and opened the box and basically the cheese was completely dried out and the toppings were at the least unappetizing. I want back in which I hate to do and asked for a different pizza. The cashier's and cook both told me they've had issues with the prior cook making way too much food and have had this same problem which they've reported numerous times. Anyways the cook told me to not apologize and he'd happily have me a new pizza in about 6 minutes.
You might ask why 5 stars. Well I don't feel like it's the cooks fault it's not as if those pizzas were out of time and he seemed very disappointed to keep having said issue and was more than happy to make me a fresh one. I appreciate that very much I now regret not giving him a tip so I wanted to make sure to somehow make my appreciation known.“

“I mean I do recommend it but I got a medium pizza last night that was so sad and soggy and half cooked. I couldn’t even eat it. I had one slice that was good to eat. I ate the crust off another piece and even the crust was sad. I’ve been here so many times that were good. This time was so sad. I called and called and no one picked up. Then I had to go to work before I could go back. In the photo is the sad pizza not even 10 hours later.“

“Incredible meat sauce, always fresh pasta, salad and bread“

“Food is decent. I personally think the 🍕 is a lil pricey.“