45 Best Pizza Restaurants near Willow Spring

“Hunt Brothers Pizza is a great pizza for anybody searching for really good tasting food the employees are always very respectful their Pizza is also never undercooked or overcooked it is always just right with a perfect amount of toppings“

“Excellent service, atmosphere, food, & prices. They never disappoint!“

“My husband and I tried Roman style pizza here, for the first time and we loved it! Fresher and lighter than NY style pizza (although we still love NY style), very satisfying because of the taste and quality of the ingredients in the Parma and Burrata pizzas that we ordered! Claudio who is from Rome made the experience even better as he prepared our order and explained about the special dough which is the perfect base for the gourmet toppings! We will be return customers!“

“Great food…. Love the pizza have to get the ranch to go with…. Love the salads too the team is so great!“

“Pretty nice place when we visited. Our server was super nice & gave us our space to enjoy our meal in peace instead of being pushy & crowding us the entire time like they do at other restaraunts.
The food was great & honestly better than we were expecting it to be. The cheese bread alone had us planning our next visit.
As a great bonus, the sweet tea actually tasted clean & like tea! instead of like straight dirt, which says a lot to the folks who get tea with their food.“

“Love coming back to this place for our corporate parties. Delicious food, great service, beautiful design and warm atmosphere.“

“Best pizzeria on the planet and definitely in Wake County!!! Good people and Good food…please stop by today“

“Nicest staff. Great food! Love this place!!!“

“I went to Papa MURPHY’S on Saturday and ordered a pepperoni, sausage onion,green pepper and tomatoes pizza on thin crust. The guy working was super nice and explained everything since I hadn’t been back in years. I cooked it on the middle rack instead of the bottom like he mentioned, with the oven safe paper. It was delicious and will plan to be back again.“

“J&S is always our go to for pizza. We decided to use them to cater our party this weekend. The food was absolutely delicious. We had lots of people asking where we got it. Everyone enjoyed the food. Lori and Kaylee were so nice and helpful!“

“I'm originally from the Chicagoland area and love Chicago Deep Dish. No one does it right. The crust is usually super think and the toppings, especially the cheese, is far too sparse. ACME Pizza... you guys literally made me get all teary eyed with the first bite! I was back home again after 20+ years of missing my hometown pizza, I was home. I had to drive over an hour to get to you, but I would do it again! For those of us who miss home, this is definitely a warm tasty slice of home comfort food. Now if you guys ever create a parbaked pie that my hubs could pick up on the few occasions he has to travel to Raleigh for his job so we can have the fresh out of the oven taste when he gets home. . . You would make this former Chicagoan very happy.“

“We enjoyed our half bacon Sicilian pie last night so much! The fried breadsticks were amazing too, as was the pepperoni calzone! The staff member who took our order over the phone was kind and courteous, double-checking to make sure the order was correct. Prices are more than fair. Could not have asked for a better experience and delicious food! Thank you!“

“My favorites here are the Mediterranean pizza (it has eggplant, which is wonderful when prepared properly), the garden salad with Greek dressing, and the stuffed grape leaves. In fact, everything I’ve gotten here has been excellent! If possible, order on Slice, DoorDash doesn’t have everything on their menu. This is my go-to restaurant in Holly Springs!“

“Pizza is NY style, super yum, thin, toasty, and large slices. They have a large variety of pizza and other items. I have had their calzones and stromboli's too.

We usually do the lunch special and end up super full & satisfied.“

“We enjoyed our half bacon Sicilian pie last night so much! The fried breadsticks were amazing too, as was the pepperoni calzone! The staff member who took our order over the phone was kind and courteous, double-checking to make sure the order was correct. Prices are more than fair. Could not have asked for a better experience and delicious food! Thank you!“

“I've been wanting to try Papa's pizza for awhile. Got some good coupons in the mail and decided to go for it. The pepperoni and sausage pizza is great. Cheese bread is great. And the wings were amazing.
Definitely found my new pizza place.“

“5*! Went 1st time today, was excellent, food, service, cozy atmosphere, big room, will be back.“

“Being from Upstate New York, i have been looking for good NY style pizza I habe found it here at La Roma, thank you.“

“We always have a great experience with our local Fuquay location but today was extra amazing! We ordered online in the midst of a lightning storm and didn’t realize we ordered something wrong. When we got there to pick up they had no system access and we’re not he brink of losing power! They were more than accommodating in helping to fix the order we entered incorrectly even in the midst of what could have been chaos! Thank you so much

Vegetarian options: Great“

“I ordered my pizza between lunch and dinner on a weekday, was done in around 15 minutes. For the price it was fantastic. Solid cheese pie, thin crust and slightly heavy cheese. The garlic sprinkle was the perfect amount to make it smell great and make the crust pop a little without hurting the pizza.“

“As a girl I grew up occasionally visiting the buffet at Milanos or picking up pizza here for a birthday. Now I have adult money ? and can get it anytime I want lol! Moved away for years and moved back about two years ago. Was excited they are still here and just as I remember them! My sons love the pizza now too! Their thin crust is my favorite around!“

“This place is great except for the buffet! Please consider adding a salad bar for the price and bringing out fresh pizzas after 1pm…the buffet goes until 2!!! The people at the front are always nice and we are always greeted with a smile and a hello…“

“We really enjoyed our meal and the waitress was very sweet. We will be back.“

“I usually love your pizza, but when the cook pays more attention to his cell phone than the oven, bad things happen. Pizza tonight was burnt.“

“Live Michealangelos pizza. Gonna eat there tonight. Good buffet with courteous staff.“

“I am a photographer and recently photographed a rehearsal dinner here! It was a great experience! The staff welcomed me as soon as I arrived and I honestly felt like ‘one of the family’! The event space was perfect! We had room to mingle and the lighting was wonderful for my photos! The decor and colors are great and added to my images perfectly! The food was amazing.. the staff and service perfect! If you are looking for a place to hold an event, do not hesitate! And let me know if you need a photographer as I would be happy to capture images here anytime!“

“We ordered take out from Cristo’s Bistro and it was fantastic! This place is definitely a neighborhood gem. The staff were so kind and the inside of the restaurant looks so cozy-we will need to “dine-in” next time. We ordered the “Grandma Pie” and the “White Hot” Pizzas. Both were full of flavor and delicious! We ordered the Penne alla Vodka and it was perfectly cooked. A great meal! We will definitely be ordering again very soon. The entire family agreed-BEST pizza we have tried in Holly Springs!“

“We use to eat here at least once a week but have noticed changes the past few months. The staff is not as friendly as they use to be. The garlic knots are not nearly as good, they have been cold in the middle as if they are warming them up in a microwave. Pizza is still good but after today's visit we will have to say goodbye for a while.“

“The cheese pizza was nasty...where's the cheese...it was dry!! Very unhappy with my order.“

“This place is great. Absolutely exceptional and friendly service. Savannah knocked it out of the park. The food quality is a great value for your money. Ingredients are fresh and cooked perfectly. Very nice crusty with the right char, crispy yet light. Angier has a diamond in two cousins. Will be back again!“

“I went at night, only seen 2 people working and they were super friendly and customer service was a 10/10…. hope to see more friendly faces more often & the food was super HOT AND AMAZING. i tried it for my first time and i will be coming back again 🤩“

“My husband and I are here and the pizza 🍕 was awesome. I love the fact that we were able to create our own with the size that matched each of our appetites. The pizza makers were all nice and patient with us as we made our decisions. The lemonade 🍋 drink was very tasty as well.“

“Have eaten here several times. Always enjoyed their pizza. Was happily surprised to find they’ve added to their menu since the last visit. Ordered the brand new item, lasagna; and it was amazing! Hearty! The chef, Erik, personally and proudly brought it to the table. It was the best homemade lasagna I’ve ever had!! I will definitely order again!“

“Picked up a Chicago Style pizza that was excellent (I’m from Chicago). It’s the only one I’ve tried since moving to NC that even comes close to the deep dish deliciousness. In addition your Bada Shrimp and Cesar dressing are really good.“

“La Piazza catered my daughter's wedding this past Saturday and OMG, it was the best EXPERIENCE ever!!!! The food was ABSOLUTELY DELICIOUS, the amount of food was incredible. Guests were coming up to me all night and the next day asking who catered the wedding, because the food was so delicious. I HIGHLY recommend Anthony for all your catering needs. If you are looking for delicious authentic Italian food then he is your guy to go to. He was absolutely the best to work with. He stayed in constant communication with us the entire time. We also had him make 20 pizzas for the rehearsal dinner and EVERYONE loved the pizza's. He helped make our daughter's dream wedding come true. His staff was AMAZING. Anthony, WE APPRECIATE YOU!!!!THANK YOU FOR EVERYTHING!!!!“

“I just wanted to say my husband and I were in last night at the Holly springs location after the dinner rush. He had the special and I had the baked ziti bolognese which both were fantastic! The service was excellent! The waitress was wonderful!!! She was the sweetest. I wish I got her name but I do know she’s from Naples and we talked a bit. Just overall fantastic dinner, great atmosphere. Great job Mama Mia’s! 🍝❤️ cannoli was amazing 🤤“

“Hunt Brothers Pizza is a great pizza for anybody searching for really good tasting food the employees are always very respectful their Pizza is also never undercooked or overcooked it is always just right with a perfect amount of toppings“

“I have been told that this is an excellent place to go for excellent pizza.
I was not disappointed and the portions were like nothing I have ever seen.
Very impressed customer service outstanding.
And the price was extremely reasonable.“

“My kiddos, love this place better than other popular chains. I placed an order online that I messed up and they happily made it right for me. Everything came out fresh and looked amazing. I ordered ahead and it was ready at the time promised, I will definitely continue to visit this location when my kiddos want pizza. Thanks for your superior customer service, it's hard to find in 2025.“

“Hunt Brothers Pizza is a great pizza for anybody searching for really good tasting food the employees are always very respectful their Pizza is also never undercooked or overcooked it is always just right with a perfect amount of toppings“

“Hunt Brothers Pizza is a great pizza for anybody searching for really good tasting food the employees are always very respectful their Pizza is also never undercooked or overcooked it is always just right with a perfect amount of toppings“

“If you’re from Chicago - yes, this is the Rosati’s you know and love. If you’re not from Chicago, try the pizza, their thin crust is *chefs kiss*. I have no doubt that their deep dish is equally as wonderful. We will definitely return.“

“I love there pizza slices and that they have sodas I can drink ! Also one of the guys gave me some garlic knots thank you !“

“The most awesome chicken salad sandwich and Buffalo Chicken and Philly Cheesesteak Egg rolls ever!!“