15 Best Pizza Restaurants in Clayton

“First time here and I'm already in love. The atmosphere was great. Very chill and my interactions with employees were warm. And the pizza is delicious ? ?. I was very surprised and am very happy. One thing for the store if you see this. I ordered the ff pizza cause that is the best combination I have ever heard of. I but I was disappointed with it only because the ff were not cooked all the way. That brought down the enjoyment big time. Still great idea just need to make sure fries are fully cooked.“

“10/12/24 We Hosted a 50th Birthday party for my wife at Veneros, Monti Hall . The Location was setup very elegant , the staff was super nice, accommodating and professional. The food was superb! We all had a Blast there last night! Thanks to Veneros and their Staff for a Fantastic night and the memories forever!...“

“My definite go to on any day!“

“I can't say anything about the service or atmosphere because I tried them out on door dash. I just moved to Garner from Raleigh and have been trying out different local pizza places. I actually intentionally picked this spot because a lot of people mentioned the sweetness of their sauce in their reviews. I LOVED it. I grew up with a German father who always threw a little extra sugar into his red sauce and this pizza sauce brought me back to my childhood with just one bite. Not only that but I tried something outside of my comfort zone, The Dante's Peak specialty pizza - I'm a carnivore who prefers veggie pizza, but this particular pizza was a killer combo of meat and veggies!! The banana peppers gave the perfect balance of sweet acidity to the saltiness of the pepperoni and sausage. And of course I loved the sauce. They coated it with toppings and the crust was a perfect balance of fluffy and crunchy. I am SO pleased and full. I couldn't be happier with this choice and will be a repeat customer.“

“First time there. They were quick to take our order, order came out in like 8 minutes. We got the BBQ chicken pizza and the stuffed Howie bread and let me say OMG. This was the best pizza we had ever had 10/10 totally recommend. Will definitely be back. And just FYI we came from Four Oaks“

“Had such an amazing time celebrating my boyfriend’s birthday! Thank you for hosting our surprise party and for the incredible service! Keri and the rest of the team took great care of us. ☺️ The food and drinks were delicious and I’m so happy we had a space to hang out and spend time together!“

“We go here at least once a week and are never disappointed!! I recommend the specials that they have weekly because they are always amazing!“

“Service wasn't great but food was very good.“

“Being new in the area I have been trying everything around me and found this place. So far the best pizza in the area! Not greasy at all, semi thin crust (perfect) wings were good size not the joke that everybody else are serving, and the service was excellent too! This will be my to go place from now on for Italian food!“

“La Cucina always delivers on quality! We love that they deliver (to our house) as well, plus it's always quick and reliable. Their calzones are super crispy and my wife loves that she can get a Gluten-Free lasagna here (since she has celiac disease and most Italian restaurants don't serve GF lasagna). I definitely recommend their garlic knots as well -- smothered in garlic and olive oil, delicious! Definitely a favorite of ours, and convenient too!

Dietary restrictions: Gluten-Friendly!“

“I typically do not order late, but my husband was hungry so we saw this place was open til 12 on Google. Ordered online and picked up. Walked in and was greeted right away, pizza and wings were hot and ready for me, perfect timing. Great customer service. I am not a pizza person, but my husbands pizza was so good I stole 2 slices, I ordered wings for myself which were also great!“

“Anthony’s went above and beyond for me and am forever grateful.
It was my wife’s Birthday and Our 13th Anniversary, I was a bit strapped for time to make things perfect and being relatively new to the area I wasn’t sure so where to turn.
Being from the Boston area originally we both like to have some authentic Italian food from time to time and this is what she had requested.
After checking menus of various places Anthony’s checked all the boxes for us.
I secretly wanted to make this a special event for her so I had to keep things kinda quiet.
I called messaged Anthony on Saturday to see if there was anything they could do for me on a Sunday afternoon. I knew it was late notice so I wasn’t going to get my hopes up. I was looking for flowers, decorations and maybe a special table for her and us. He replied “I got you” and would have his manager Mary call me.
Mary called me and asked a couple of questions to make sure she understood what I requested. I also mentioned to her that neither of us were drinkers and asked if they did “Mocktails”.
Ok, so with all of that being said. Anthony and Mary sure did “Have me”.
We arrived and they had a beautiful setup all arranged for us. A special table with flowers and balloons to celebrate her Birthday and also our Anniversary !! She has also gone out of her way to pick up some non alcoholic wine and Tequila mix !! What service already, I knew I was in good hands.
The meal started with some fresh Foccacia bread and dipping oil, it was perfect. We then shared an order of Mozzarella sticks. My wife ordered Cheese Tortellini and myself Chicken. Rollatini, let me tell ya folks, this was the best Italian meal I have had in years !! We finished it out with some of the best Cannoli I have had.
I would recommend this place to anyone, anywhere !!
I was so impressed I had to order a Sicilian Pizza to take home … and let me tell ya, fresh, huge and full of flavor it was !!
Thank You Anthony and Mary for making this special day one to remember !!
You now have two more customers for life ❤️“

“Whenever we frequent this Pizza Hut, there's only one person covering seated guests, but she does a great job! The drinks, appetizers, and pizzas all came out promptly and correctly.

Kid-friendliness: There are a couple of TVs in the dining area that play kid-appropriate content. The booth seating is my kids' favorite.“

“A really really good pizza is a rarity "in the south" so I miss a great pizza from the North End, Brooklyn, even South Shore bar pizzas. But Domino's Brooklyn style come the closest and sort of "holds me over" til I get up north again.“

“This is hands down one of our favorite pizza places in Clayton, NC. Very comparable to Lucy's in Orem Utah and that is quite high praise as Lucy's is our favorite outside of homemade pizza.
It is easy to order and the wait never exceeds 20 minutes for pickup, that I have witnessed.“