28 Best Pizza Restaurants in Cary

“The pizza is delicious and coming from NJ, I know good pizza. I grew up eating NY style pizza and the pizza here is a very close second and a nice small friendly place to take your family for a quick bite to eat during the week when you can’t decide what to cook at home.“

“We love Salvio’s, but I’m so sad that with the new online ordering system there is no option for roni cups except for on a specialty square pizza. Please add roni cups back to the build your own pizza ☹️ High quality pizza, delicious!“

“Awesome service and food!“

“Great Food. Excellent Host.“

“Great food…. Love the pizza have to get the ranch to go with…. Love the salads too the team is so great!“

“Beat icecream and pizza experience. Wide variety of Indian icecream and Indian pizza are outstanding. Their Vada pav and dabeli are must try. Hidden gem in Cary. Highly recommended“

“Can I suggest getting shirts made that say “once you go square no others compare” Compliments of my wife we just want free pizza for the idea no royalties needed.“

“Very good Italian food and pizza, albeit pricy for the casual open-kitchen concept dining room. The pasta with fried chicken and vodka sauce was a must try. Most of the staff is friendly and hardworking. I did not appreciate being asked to “wait 10 minutes before ordering” via the QR code at the table or “the kitchen staff will be stressed and it will be obvious.” Quite awkward to watch the clock with a half empty restaurant to place an order. Maybe they prefer that customers order out instead of dining in?“

“Very family friendly! Ate outside, they provided balls of pizza dough and coloring pages for the kids, and even gave us gelato samples at the end! Food was also excellent, as always. Highly recommend!“

“A total delight! The pizza creator was alone in the mid afternoon and my order was ready on time and served with a smile! Thanks for a great experience today 😊

Dietary restrictions: Gluten free and keto options as well as vegetarian. Great tasting too!“

“really glad i found this pizza shop. best ny style pizza. great undercarriage, no flop, not too thin. my goto is the margherita and the sauce tastes great. when i come back, thinking of asking for extra crisp. this place is One Bite worthy.“

“We enjoyed our half bacon Sicilian pie last night so much! The fried breadsticks were amazing too, as was the pepperoni calzone! The staff member who took our order over the phone was kind and courteous, double-checking to make sure the order was correct. Prices are more than fair. Could not have asked for a better experience and delicious food! Thank you!“

“Probably the best NY style pizza around! But the real reason this place has been a local favorite for so long is their amazing customer service. Ownership makes everyone feel like family and absolutely makes you want to come back! Our family has been weekly regulars for over a decade now and highly recommend Brothers whenever possible.“

“YUMMY PIZZA and friendly staff!“

“We are Brixx regulars, but I was very disappointed in the Italian meatballs. They are highly processed and taste terrible! I used to love the meatballs with polenta so I thought I’d try these. I’m going back to wings or a salad. Very disappointed.“

“Excellent pizza!! Definitely a NY pizza!!“

“This was my first visit to Jet’s in years. The pizza was good but I will remember this visit for the positive energy coming from the people. They seemed to like each other and like working there which is not the case in a lot of places. Great job!“

“I had dinner here for my friend's birthday celebration and I must say the service was great. The food was good and the atmosphere was welcoming. I would recommend this place to family and friends and give you 5 stars.“

“We are Brixx regulars, but I was very disappointed in the Italian meatballs. They are highly processed and taste terrible! I used to love the meatballs with polenta so I thought I’d try these. I’m going back to wings or a salad. Very disappointed.“

“Depending on your budget and appetite, this is a fantastic choice! It is may be on the smaller side, but the quality makes up for it, plus unlimited toppings! Today i chose my two go to's, half classic pepperoni, and half spinach and ricotta. Both were delicious!!! Definitely going back to try my other favorites. I'm not usually a thin crust fan, but it is the perfect thin crust ratio to toppings. Depending on my appetite I could eat five of these 😋 today one was perfect!“

“Hands down THE best breakfast sandwich I’ve ever had! Very friendly staff and hands on owners making the experience memorable. Will recommend to everyone!“

“Great food selection with great prices“

“Extremely friendly staff, everyone was great to deal with and so helpful. Will definitely return! Pizza and wings were amazing.“

“Always good, reliable and quick. They come through when you need them the most. Always turn to Marco’s for my pizza needs.“

“Yujin did an amazing job. Guy was working alone and made a fantastic wrap and pizza. Give this guy his own restaurant!“

“I had an issue with my order, but the customer service team handled it promptly. My son, who is on the spectrum, was upset because the cheese was missing. They quickly rushed over to rectify the situation. I’m very happy with their service.“

“Great experience ordering here and eating inside with my children and husband. The only (2) changes that I highly recommend are 1) increasing the air conditioning during the summer season and 2) serving larger size wings. Today's July 18th, it was up to 97 degrees today in Cary! The pizza was tasty, super hot, and we left satisfied. Both gentlemen who were there were polite, fun to be around, and served us with care.I like this location, the people who work at this spot, and its food. Thanks!“

“I recently visited Cicis Pizza in Cary, NC, and had a great experience. If you're looking for a family-friendly restaurant with plenty of variety and excellent value, Cicis is a fantastic choice. From the moment we walked in, the staff was welcoming, and the restaurant had a fun, casual atmosphere that made it perfect for families, groups, and pizza lovers of all ages.

The pizza buffet offered an impressive selection of options. There were classic favorites like pepperoni and cheese, along with specialty pizzas featuring unique toppings and flavors. Everything was fresh, hot, and continuously replenished, so there was always something new to try. I especially appreciated the variety because everyone in our group was able to find something they enjoyed.

Beyond the pizza, the buffet included fresh salad options, pasta dishes, and plenty of desserts. The cinnamon rolls and dessert pizzas were a big hit and provided the perfect ending to the meal. The quality and selection made it feel like there was something for everyone.

The restaurant was clean and well-maintained, and the staff worked hard to keep the buffet stocked and the dining area organized. Even during a busy time, everything felt efficient and well-managed. The team was friendly and quick to assist whenever needed.

One of the best parts of the experience was the value. For the price, it's hard to beat the amount of food and variety available. It's a great option for families, birthday celebrations, sports teams, or anyone looking for an affordable meal.

Overall, I highly recommend Cicis Pizza in Cary, North Carolina. The combination of fresh pizza, a wide variety of buffet options, friendly service, and great value makes it a fun dining destination. Whether you're dining with kids, friends, or family, Cicis delivers a satisfying and enjoyable experience that keeps people coming back.“