Ice Cream Shops near Newington

“I recently tried Crumbl Cookies, and they were really good! The cookies were soft, thick, and full of flavor. I liked that they have different flavors every week, so there’s always something new to try. The cookies are pretty big, which makes them great for sharing. They can be a little expensive, but the taste and quality make them worth it. Overall, I would recommend Crumbl Cookies to anyone who loves sweet treats.“

“Good selection of base flavors and add-in options. But it's a tiny shop and the flow of which way the line goes is unclear, with people coming in both doors. The indoor seating is a handful of two-seat tables, but there are a few benches outside. For families, it's definitely more economical to split large sizes if the kids can agree!“

“Homemade ice cream- unique and delicious flavors! Great customer service“

“Aggie’s has been one of the highlights of summers in South Berwick for generations. It’s a cash only operation, so come prepared. Many, many hand scooped flavors and they also have soft serve. The soft serve Pinkie cone is a real bargain at $1 for babies and four legged friends. Covered seating area with picnic tables adjacent to parking lot. Enjoy.“

“This is a Portsmouth must!! Great ice cream and super friendly customer service, we had the peppermint stick ice cream and I recommend ordering it before it's gone!! We ordered it and took home a pint!“

“always great ice-cream. highly recommend“

“What a sweet addition to Newmarket! This friendly family has made a beautiful space with delicious food - the Key Lime Pie is OUT OF THIS WORLD!!! This new spot is not to be missed!“

“On vacation and stopped in to try the local ice cream. Husband and I ordered the 6 scoop banana split. This treat could feed an entire family. Huge portions. Definitely bring an empty stomach and friends and family to enjoy the yumminess.“

“The best ice cream for more than 30 years of traveling throughout the world and living in various states…I come back to Portsmouth for the salted caramel chip❤️“

“Stopped in to Kilwins to grab a soda for my diabetic boyfriend who had low blood sugar, they don’t sell loose sodas but were very kind and just gave him one so we really appreciate that! Excellent treats, caramel apple was delicious and they offered to cut it so it was easier to share which I really like, and the fudge is delicious 💖💖 thank you guys next time we are in Portsmouth we will stop in again :)“

“Great experience. Everyone is polite and patient.
I'm severely allergic to peanuts and tree nuts, and I love how I am able to get toppings here because they use separate toppings for nut allergies. I do not come across these types of places often. Good flavors and very allergy-accommodating.“

“Always yummy and friendly!“

“Was cash only due to a technical issue. Icecream is good. Just off the highway, great place for family with small kids can head home from Hampton Beach, pop in and they head home. Dad's if you want to be a super dad; after a long day at the beach, bring the kids ...“

“I got my Christmas tree at Emery Farm this year, and it was a great experience! All the trees were really nice and in really good shape, they sell cider donuts you can munch on, they had a cozy campfire going near the tree lot where you can keep warm while you're waiting, everyone is very friendly, and they are giving away a cute wooden ornament with a tree purchase! I wrestled it in my door and onto a stand, with minimal needle loss despite the manhandling. It may not be the cheapest option, but the quality is there and they make the experience worth it. If you are able to support local places instead of big box stores and corporations, it's really a good thing to do and it really does make a difference. It keeps our money in our community instead of the wallet of some big faceless far-off corporation. 🌲💚“

“so I traveled over an hour to get here and omg this place is my new favorite. the decor is medieval themed, with awesome dragons, cool kings chairs, and cool games. the candy selection is out of this world. my family is from Ireland, and I love Irish chocolate. they have chocolate that was even hard to find in ireland last time I went. they have the best chocolate covered gummy bears, all the unique candy at the candy counter is amazing as well. the shakes are also great, packed with candy and flavor. I absolutely recommend this place.“

“What a sweet addition to Newmarket! This friendly family has made a beautiful space with delicious food - the Key Lime Pie is OUT OF THIS WORLD!!! This new spot is not to be missed!“

“Great food time and time again!“

“Izzy’s is actually open despite what this says. We went both days of our visit to Portsmouth. There were six vegan options including ice creams and sorbet. We particularly loved the cookie dough! The place is cute and the young people working are just lovely! Very highly recommend! Updated from previous review on 2026-05-14“

“I’ve had Clyde’s cupcakes on multiple occasions. They catered for my business’s grand opening last year and the cupcakes were a hit! Everyone at the opening loved them. I am planning to have them cater again this year for my baby shower. Chyna was very responsive and helpful when I was placing the order with her. They even dropped off the cupcakes for me! I would 100% recommend getting their cupcakes for your next event.“

“Was in town and went there for a nostalgic experience from when it used to be Golicks but the small twist cone I ordered was barely above the cone for an underwhelming portion at twice the price.. the ice cream is still really good though…“

“Just a quick note from someone who never writes reviews. Sitting at The Beach Plum with my three kiddos and so impressed and grateful for the wonderful service we’ve received here. We had a tiny issue with one meal which was immediately acknowledged and fixed tenfold. Two members of the team checked on us several times after to make sure we were doing okay and then sent us home with an extra meal for later on the house. My kids learned a great lesson on wonderful and kind customer service and The Beach Plum will continue to be a favorite spot for us! Thank you!!“