Pizza Restaurants near Rye

“Love this place, good variety for my family, diffently recommend this place....very friendly“

“DELICOUS PIZZA YUMYUMYUMYUM“

“Third year update - this place continues to delight and amaze! Tried the butter toffee cake, equally great. All the pizzas are spectacular.
This is the second year in a row we had an early dinner here, and once again it was amazing.
All the dishes have a special touch to them, something unique and delectable.
The pizzas are spectacular, with wood fired char on the crust. The sandwiches are equally wonderful, each with perfectly balanced spices.
My special of the day spicy martini was one of the best I ever tasted, potent yet eminently drinkable.
The desserts are out of this world, especially the brownie sundae.
The service was terrific as well. Can't recommend this place highly enough!
Looking forward to next year!

Parking: The parking lot is ample“

“Excellent quality food and service. Highly recommend!“

“Got a Large Extra Cheese for my Birthday and it was awesome. Always a great Pizza up there with Regina's North End and Mamma Lisa's in Somerville. Just wish they would deliver through DoorDash or Uber Eats.“

“The pizza was great. I loved every bite of it. It was made more healthily. Our server Kelly was catering to our needs quickly.“

“Without a doubt, the best steak and cheese sandwich in the Seacoast , yes, better than Jitto’s!!! Today I had one that had the nicest provolone cheese, which I asked for a beautifully toasted golden brown edge charred roll. It was so juicy when I picked it up and bit into the sandwich. It shot juicy liquid all over my shirt now that’s a great steak and cheese.“

“Love the new place. And the food is ALWAYS awesome! Owner and workers are very friendly and work hard.“

“We popped in here based on reviews for a quick dinner before a comedy show last night. Our server was super attentive and kind, the pizza was loaded with toppings, and our check came to a grand total of $26 for two drinks and a pizza. Pretty unmatched value for 2025, definitely recommend!“

“We tried the Grandma Pizza today. It was absolutely the BEST pizza we have had in years! SO GOOOOD!!! :) :) :)“

“Good place with good food love to eat there“

“The live karaoke is a nice event. All the bartenders do a good job every time I go there. Always remembering the drinks I got last time.“

“My family and I order from Badgers every couple weeks. It’s our favorite pizza around and we all agree they’ve got the best steak and cheese sub around! :)“

“This place is honestly great! Great service great food, and hot and fresh!!! I got the chicken ranchero sub, I took out the ham because I don’t like ham all that much, but then I added pineapple too it, made the sandwich so much better, there is also bacon and lettuce tamatos, and cheese on it!! 100/10“

“ordered extra cheese pizza and there was even LESS than when I order regular....used to be good but it's now TERRIBLE“

“Every year we stop here to get the steak sub with onions and peppers and we are very pleased every time. The bread is the softest we had. Not sure if the two guys are thee owners but very pleasant. I would recommend this place for sure. We drive through York just to stop here . It’s just an old fashion Pizza shop with great food. Thanks guys.“

“Great food at a great price. Theresa & the staff are great. The entertainment has come a long way. Not too loud - just right for the size of the restaurant. Tonight (8/24) the music was exceptional. Thanks for having us.“

“Have been buying their pizza slices for years, and it's always been the best pizza I've ever had from anywhere! Delicious, great variety, hot, and always ready to eat on the spot or take home. The service is wonderful. Always with a great smile! Keep up the good work. It's hard to find food and service this good!“

“Great venue, except the bartender that served me twice then kicked me out when I returned to the bar for a third drink. (Not my fault he didn't see the marks on my hand) I'm well over the legal age.
Heavy set bald guy in case the venue sees this“

“My family and I just left this establishment full and Happy!! The atmosphere made you feel like you are a regular. The young waitress (I believe Kate) was so friendly and bubbly, the cheft made sure we had everything we could possibly need. We will definitely be adding this place to our must stops when we come back!! Thank you for going above and beyond!!“

“They just have the best pies. I get one every Friday (almost), and we live for it!“

“It was so good. It tasted so good. I’ve highly recommend if you’re going on vacations for this one. The delivery was on time. I got it really fast after I ordered it.

Kid-friendliness: It’s really good my kids love it. I really recommend it. It’s like you’re in a hungry and also I recommend New York style by the way, but like say you’re really hungry like you’re craving something. I really recommend buying stuff they’re hungry you’re hungry really fill up your stomach and your taste buds will be in heaven.“

“Absolute best pizza ever, also so nice!!!“

“Best pizza in Portsmouth. For real. Don't miss out. There isn't another pizza joint in the area that even comes close to being as good.“

“Went to Gibbs for the first time last night for dinner. Our waitress was so friendly and accommodating, offering to bring out my son’s food first so he could eat sooner (he’s almost 3). We ordered the grilled wings which were delicious as well as the Reuben and prime rib. Everything was good! Friendly and laid back atmosphere. Will come back again.“

“They have the best food and very generous portions. Chicken parmigiana is the very very best. Can’t wait to go again and have the steak and cheese“

“Big slices and decent pizza, as long as you’re not looking for anything fancy.Something to note: Sal’s pizza is a chain and other locations allow you to order online but not this one. We tried to order a specific pizza that was on the online menu, but when we called they didn’t know what we were referring to and took our order by individual toppings instead (and charged by the topping, which was more expensive than the price for the equivalent pizza on the menu).Also - the price per person in this review is low because we split the pizza cost across 7 people.“

“Best subs and Pizza anywhere. Jennie amd Liz at the counter know there regulars by name! we go there for dinner 1x a week!!“

“⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ food and quick delivery service 👍“

“Holy Fu*k!! Perfect, exactly what I wanted. Had 2 cheese slices.“

“Soo good worth the DoorDash wait for delivery all the way to Hampton. Tastes amazing re heated and even better for breakfast. The Maserati pizza was amazing and the fried dough bites are sooo yummy!“

“I work at the Moffatt-Ladd House across the street and have been meaning to come over and experience their menu, as we often have overlapping customers. Our host sat us right away, drinks were fabulous, and all the meals were absolutely amazing! (I had the caribbean grilled swordfish.) My mom had been here with her parents in college in the early 80s and clearly Casey is carrying the mantle well. Thank you especially to our server, Rachel!“

“Cute little shop! I go here frequently for the Post Office portion, and finally decided to look around a few weeks ago. A lot of unique, cool, and local things there! Even got some of my Christmas shopping done there. Definitely worth a look around.“

“We love Rosa's. The food is always excellent and authentic. Gluten free penne pasta is undetectable from traditional. The house salad will make you ask; "How do they do this?". Atmosphere is so comfortable and inviting. Great service too. Remember if they are busy it's because they are GOOD!“

“great service amazing food“

“I got my order through DoorDash. It was a large extra cheese pizza and two steak tip subs with french fries. Beats up on places like community oven like you wouldn’t believe. Where I am right now in Hampton it’s hard to find good delivery pizza and this is great stuff would highly recommend“

“We visit the Community Oven every time we stay up in New Hampshire when going to a concert at Club Casino! It's our favorite place to go for pizza , the best pizza !! Great vibe, great bartender, and very friendly people !! We've tried other places around and they're good but this has become our place because it's the best place!“

“Had the most amazing chicken noodle soup. Totally homemade“