35 Best Pizza Restaurants near Rye

“Love this place, good variety for my family, diffently recommend this place....very friendly“

“Excellent quality food and service. Highly recommend!“

“DELICOUS PIZZA YUMYUMYUMYUM“

“Third year update - this place continues to delight and amaze! Tried the butter toffee cake, equally great. All the pizzas are spectacular.
This is the second year in a row we had an early dinner here, and once again it was amazing.
All the dishes have a special touch to them, something unique and delectable.
The pizzas are spectacular, with wood fired char on the crust. The sandwiches are equally wonderful, each with perfectly balanced spices.
My special of the day spicy martini was one of the best I ever tasted, potent yet eminently drinkable.
The desserts are out of this world, especially the brownie sundae.
The service was terrific as well. Can't recommend this place highly enough!
Looking forward to next year!

Parking: The parking lot is ample“

“Kiddo (15) and I camping in the area and craving a non-chain yummy cheesy pizza. This place was definitely 10/10. Garlic. bread with cheese with marinara dipping sauce was perfection. Staff and atmosphere were great too. Highly recommend!“

“The pizza was great. I loved every bite of it. It was made more healthily. Our server Kelly was catering to our needs quickly.“

“Nik and Charlie’s is the best! I was housesitting in the neighborhood and ate there four different nights. The food was great, and the service was even better. The woman who runs the front counter and the takeout phone is a delight. I wasn’t sure if I had been overcharged one time, and she very kindly showed me the receipt from my order that day and explained my confusion away and didn’t even make me feel bad about it. Superior customer service. It looks incredibly clean inside, and their BLT is really really good. I look forward to my next time getting food from Nik and Charlie’s.“

“Love the new place. And the food is ALWAYS awesome! Owner and workers are very friendly and work hard.“

“We tried the Grandma Pizza today. It was absolutely the BEST pizza we have had in years! SO GOOOOD!!! :) :) :)“

“We have been to this restaurant several times and decided to go to lunch with a friend from out of town. The restaurant has great food, the atmosphere is very inviting and the waiter was very attentive.

Parking: The parking lot is small out back but there is extra parking in front of the restaurant. The restaurant is popular but we always seem to find a place to park.

Wheelchair accessibility: My husband uses a walker and it was very easy for him to get in and out of the restaurant. Everything is on one floor.“

“Have been buying their pizza slices for years, and it's always been the best pizza I've ever had from anywhere! Delicious, great variety, hot, and always ready to eat on the spot or take home. The service is wonderful. Always with a great smile! Keep up the good work. It's hard to find food and service this good!“

“Not many pizza places in the area serve slices anymore. Gigi's is the exception. I ordered two massive, crispy slices for under $10. They hit the spot after a long work week. I can't wait to custom order a delicious pie in the future.“

“This place is honestly great! Great service great food, and hot and fresh!!! I got the chicken ranchero sub, I took out the ham because I don’t like ham all that much, but then I added pineapple too it, made the sandwich so much better, there is also bacon and lettuce tamatos, and cheese on it!! 100/10“

“They just have the best pies. I get one every Friday (almost), and we live for it!“

“Good place with good food love to eat there“

“ordered extra cheese pizza and there was even LESS than when I order regular....used to be good but it's now TERRIBLE“

“Every year we stop here to get the steak sub with onions and peppers and we are very pleased every time. The bread is the softest we had. Not sure if the two guys are thee owners but very pleasant. I would recommend this place for sure. We drive through York just to stop here . It’s just an old fashion Pizza shop with great food. Thanks guys.“

“Absolute best pizza ever, also so nice!!!“

“My family and I order from Badgers every couple weeks. It’s our favorite pizza around and we all agree they’ve got the best steak and cheese sub around! :)“

“Great food at a great price. Theresa & the staff are great. The entertainment has come a long way. Not too loud - just right for the size of the restaurant. Tonight (8/24) the music was exceptional. Thanks for having us.“

“⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ food and quick delivery service 👍“

“Amazing awesome place from wallys. Because related from like from a weekday what the sit around or actually what the parental guests said about named about wallys but you know what, they'd think it's a mascot? No. And maybe they'd never heard or seen that place where the rockstar viewers or those kids like that know about that place. So the place was nice they have it to dine there If you'd like to dine there. And if you like to get to the concert, you might like to check the poster when yote throughout the entrance and especially you're checking those concert dates from online to check it. This is a nice place to be a biker, motorcyclist, and a rockstar. At the guitar dine in.“

“Best worst venue ever! Place is setup like a 1800's brothel with a stage. They cram as many of the seats (folding chairs) in there as they can. Pay $0-40 in parking depending on which side of the venue you're coming from and what spots are available. some shows have reentry while others don't (standard unstandardized practice with venues). Despite all that, I've been several times and every show was incredible! 10/10 would recommend going to the ballroom over any of the "bigger" venues in the region. Can't wait for my next visit“

“Our first time at OTTO Pizza! Food was Terrific! Service was great! We will be back!“

“They have the best food and very generous portions. Chicken parmigiana is the very very best. Can’t wait to go again and have the steak and cheese“

“Best subs and Pizza anywhere. Jennie amd Liz at the counter know there regulars by name! we go there for dinner 1x a week!!“

“Soo good worth the DoorDash wait for delivery all the way to Hampton. Tastes amazing re heated and even better for breakfast. The Maserati pizza was amazing and the fried dough bites are sooo yummy!“

“Tara just made me the best sub ever thank you so much I know it was hot in there I appreciate you“

“Great food and service. Anyone would enjoy a meal here, but if you like cars, history, or anything to do with motorsports it is a home run.“

“Greg’s is a great local Hampton spot with great food and even better bartenders! A place you must visit!“

“It was so good. It tasted so good. I’ve highly recommend if you’re going on vacations for this one. The delivery was on time. I got it really fast after I ordered it.

Kid-friendliness: It’s really good my kids love it. I really recommend it. It’s like you’re in a hungry and also I recommend New York style by the way, but like say you’re really hungry like you’re craving something. I really recommend buying stuff they’re hungry you’re hungry really fill up your stomach and your taste buds will be in heaven.“

“Cute little shop! I go here frequently for the Post Office portion, and finally decided to look around a few weeks ago. A lot of unique, cool, and local things there! Even got some of my Christmas shopping done there. Definitely worth a look around.“

“AMAZING FOOD!!! SERVICE WAS GREAT“

“Love this place. There's always a local debate on which is real "Beach pizza" between Tripoli bakery and Christy's. You can only find Christy's at THE BEACH while Tripoli can be found throughout the city's of Methuen and Lawrence.“

“We love Rosa's. The food is always excellent and authentic. Gluten free penne pasta is undetectable from traditional. The house salad will make you ask; "How do they do this?". Atmosphere is so comfortable and inviting. Great service too. Remember if they are busy it's because they are GOOD!“