44 Best Pizza Restaurants near Allamuchy

“By far the best pizza I’ve ever had! The crust is not dry like most places. They have ruined pizza for me anywhere else!!“

“Today was our first visit here and we will definitely be coming back. Their Sicilian pizza is super delicious. I can’t wait to go home and try their cannolis.❤️❤️“

“The food is awesome on both sides! Shabo and family are wonderful hosts! We love NY Pizza and Monte Casa!“

“I loved this experience very good. The real tall blond lady helped me with my walker and walked me to the door. Such a kind and caring soul on gods green earth. Blessed thy heart!“

“Bruno’s easily has the best pizza and pasta in the Hackettstown area. The staff are always welcoming you with a warm smile and are friendly. The Pizza is a sensational experience in your mouth. The pasta is cooked at a perfect level. The atmosphere could be a little bit more Italian but it’s still a 4/5 stars. Without a doubt I will be coming back multiple times.“

“We have been coming to Sals for long long time. The food especially the Cheese Steak sandwich and fries are the best. When it’s cold outside Sal makes a pasta fagioli that’s out of this world. Don’t forget the zepoles. Thanks Sal and son, for making Sal’s Pizzaria a great place to sit down and eat a slice of pizza and enjoy a glass of wine to go with it. 👍“

“Food is always great. Love the rice ball appetizer, wings, chicken fingers, salads, sandwiches and pies. Try the Drunken Chicken Parmesan.“

“I went to Pezzo Pizza with three children under 5, and the staff was just incredible. They were so, so sweet and accommodating — not always an easy task with little ones, I get it! I felt completely at home, and so did the kids. The food was really good too, which made the whole experience even better. It’s rare to find a place that makes dining out with children feel easy and enjoyable, but Pezzo Pizza really delivered. We’ll definitely be back!“

“We had a wonderful birthday celebration meal here. Our server Rob was excellent!!!“

“Great food and drinks.“

“I ordered Mike’s Special Pizza yesterday, and it is amazing! Reminds me of a combination of their Chicken Aurora Dinner (which I love) and their Grandma Pizza (so so good.) My kids also love the burgers here. I look forward to ordering again!“

“Staff is very friendly and everything I’ve eaten there is fantastic. The wings are the best I’ve ever had in the area. This restaurant is a definite go to. Keep up the great work.“

“Love there pizzas ..highly reccomend ❤“

“Best Sicilian Pizza around!! we've eaten at practically every pizza place in Sussex County. This is awesome!“

“Amazing owners! Best experience ever so far! What a kind humble people! Great food too! We couldn’t ask for a better night!“

“Pizza was amazing and calamari was out of this world“

“Carmine's is our go to place whenever we crave Italian or a cheesesteak. Husband and I were there yesterday for late lunch. Excellent pasta fagioli soup, huge slices of pizza, and overstuffed, cheesesteak. Great service and reasonable prices. We were informed there is an extra charge if you're not paying cash. This is becoming a common practice and we were informed of it. Server was excellent and made us feel welcome. I was asked if I knew of any pizza parlors served gluten free and of course I recommended Carmine's.“

“Owner is so nice and the pizza is one of the best in town 🇮🇹 Highly recommend!“

“Fantastic couple who owns and operates the restaurant. Love the base red sauce flavor, warning though that it’s on the sweeter side.

Great pizza. Wife loves the penne vodka.

They also make Italian desserts for the holidays for takeout sale.“

“Always very nice. Best pizza in area“

“Last night I had chicken francese at Franks. I like plenty of lemon tast and that is how it arrived Portion size allowed take home for today“

“DELISH! I ordered a full tray of chicken Parm and of baked ziti. My family devoured everything and asked to take a dish home. Very generous servings and delicious. The phone order was soooo nice and the delivery was timely. I would recommend for your next catering need.“

“Nick and family are amazing. I've been getting pizza, pasta, salad, and sides from Roman's pizza for years now. Always ALWAYS GOOD food, always delivered on time with a smile, always super tasty. Their pizza and pasta is really great but pro tip, their salad is always super fresh!! Also try their wings, ugh so good. Thank you guys, will continue to order from you for years and years. You are the best!“

“Muy buena comida me encanta la pizza y las alitas de pollo con picante“

“Really great slice. I started visiting Chester 25 years ago as a young kid. The thinner than average crust at Bella's stood out to me even then, but still feels true to NJ Style pizza which I strictly classify and golden brown and crispy crust/bottom which achieves those wonderful golden brown micro bubbles. I'm normally skeptical of pizza joints which use a mesh tray to cook, however this place is quite the exception. The mesh tray might be their secret to that really awesome bake on their crust.“

“Best pizza I've ever had which says a lot since I drive over the road as a truck driver and have also worked in NYC for 20 years. A mind blowing selection to choose from at lunch, perfectly thin and crispy, high quality ingredients. Wow.“

“Basic pizzas. Plain, pepperoni, sausage. Best around. Good price.“

“I love that place so much!!!!“

“On Friday, I came across an article that this was voted number one in Sussex County New Jersey. I was intrigued. I love Pizza so much; unfortunately, for many years I had no desire going out for pizza because everywhere I went It was terrible. I’m born and raised in Milford, PA in Pike county. I fell in love with L&B’s in Brooklyn; but it’s been 17 years since I’ve been there last. Friday night I ordered the presto pizza two slices of it, and I fell in love after the first bite. The waitress and I’m sorry I forgot her name asked me what I thought and I loved it. It was incredible. My mission now is to try every pizza on the menu. That’s my goal finishing out 2025 into 2026 thank you thank you thank you. You have gained new customers, my husband and I. 💚🤍❤️“

“Awesome Deli! Best hard rolls! Broccoli bites are amazing! Hamburgers are awesome on a nice hard roll! G&S is awesome“

“I had a lovely lunch with my friend. The food was delicious and the staff were so sweet and friendly. It felt like grand dining room at a gorgeous country side. I was very happy dining here today. I’ll definitely be back!“

“Best pizza in town. Also better than 90% of pizza in NYC. My family loves Enzo's Pizza.“

“Frank’s is the best pizza place around! Their food is always so fresh and the waitstaff is great. Would highly recommend to anyone in the area!“

“Most solid place around. Never disappointed!“

“I really don't have any negatives. I ordered the sausage Parmigiano dinner. The garlic bread was not the way I would make it, but it was OK. The sauce was good, the sausage was good and everything was presented well. The salad and the house dressing was good! Seems like it's a family run operation, we need to support that! Support thier business, I don't think you will be disappointed.“

“exelent!!!! the best place in nj“

“Great little family run deli!

We get take-out sandwiches (breakfast and lunch primarily) fairly regularly from G&S.

I've only been disappointed once by a slightly stale sub roll, 99.9% of our sandwiches have been perfect, so the one roll was just a fluke.

We are ALWAYS satisfied by their terrific comfort food. I highly recommend G&S!“

“Food is always excellent. Best pizza in town! The Grandma Pie and Eggplant Sorrentino Pie are especially fabulous! Mangia!“

“Horrible experience worst service I ever had to many people and people didn’t know what to do and not a friendly atmosphere I wouldn’t go back“

“Come back to stillwater area every December to visit family. Since taylor ham egg and cheese is not available in montana and they've never heard of a hard roll i tend to eat one 3 times a week while I'm here and fredon deli has the best in the county. The rest of the food is pretty darn good also.“

“I was looking for a place to hold a small(er) afternoon party for about 60 friends & family members, and McQ’s came highly recommended for great food, wonderful atmosphere, and top notch service. They did not disappoint. The general manager, Alexis was a pleasure to work with, and was helpful with menu choices, and whatever additional asks I had. (A table area for a display, AV hook-up for a slide presentation, and complimentary drink “coupons” for my guests. The entire staff (including the kitchen) was friendly, and determined to make this a fun (and delicious) event. HIGHLY RECOMMEND. I give them 5 stars 🌟 out of 5.“

“Food was amazing … Fast and delicious“

“Ron's did our banquet of 160 people and everyone said the food was excellent. We found the staff on time with the food, extremely helpful, fairly priced and very generous with amounts. We will be using Ron's going forward. Thanks so much, Ron, it was great!“

“The best pizza in town“