12 Best Italian Restaurants in Caldwell

“The best thin Sicilian pizza I have ever had in my 56 years of life. Recommended 100%.“

“Beautiful authentic Ristorante - Don't pass this place up, Reserve your table - BYOB - Chef / Owner Mario is proud and honored to have you as his guest - Hostes Linda - warm & welcoming - Food is expertly prepared - fine ingredients - delicious - I honestly never had a better pasta with marinara sauce - my Bronzino was suculent, tasty & cooked to perfection - Gelato topped it off to much better than 5 Stars..“

“My friend and I are always looking for new restaurants to try and keep a log of places we see on Facebook or Instagram. Casa Nostra was next on our list to try and we were not disappointed.
The place is small and cozy, we called to see if we could get a reservation since it was a Saturday evening, they were able to accommodate us at 7:30. When we arrived we did not have to wait to be seated, the table was ready. The server provided us with menus and asked if we needed our bottle of wine to be opened. Server came back with bread for us and apologized that they were unable to warm it, explained and apologized that they were having issues with the bread warmer. The bread was fine as it was. The owner (chef) came out to take our orders we ordered the special fig appetizer to share, the portion was certainly large enough for 2 people and was very good. For entrees we had the Shrimp Risotto and Lobster Ravioli both were extremely good and nice sized portions. We were too full for dessert. One nice thing about this restaurant was that they did not rush you - there was adequate time between receiving the appetizer and entree which I thoroughly enjoyed as many times the entrees come out way too close to the appetizers. I will definitely be returning again.“

“been coming here since 2008. great food and atmosphere.“

“Buena atención, buen ambiente,comida deliciosa“

“I have been here several times before, and to their Bakery in Newark, and the bread is always excellent. Great pastries also. The food is awesome, and the drinks and wine are great also! So stop in for bread, or pastries, lunch, dinner, and drink, and you'll leave happy you did!!!!!“

“We had a 40th Birthday Party in the private room on Saturday night. It was absolutely fantastic. The room is beautiful ,they had it set up as we discussed. The service was exemplary. FOOD was amazing. We have been enjoying Forte since they opened. I would highly recommend this venue for any private party.“

“Calandra's achieves its reputation to be a place for consistently delicious cuisine, cheerfully decorated environment, excellent service, and the bonus of a bakery where it all started in Newark. The Calandra family has reinvented its traditional bakery to other dining experiences in hotel settings that serve diverse tastes. Kudos on this amazing journey and bringing joy to others!“

“Great food and customer service“

“Wonderful customer service and the FOOD, wow it is absolutely amazing. From pizza to salads, hummus to gyros, fat sandwiches and everything in between.. there is not one item that isn't good. Owner is very nice and accommodating as well - 5 stars plus!“

“The building is enormous! Like going into a castle with esthetics. The selection is intimidating as there are so many delicious goods to choose from . The staff were very knowledgeable and quick moving without making you feel like you were rushed. The pricing is very reasonable .“

“So a few advertisements on instagram & if you know me. I see I go (or try to go) I saw the thin crust pizza and just had to try. Plus pepperoni of course. Hot and fresh. Service was very fast. Came out a little well done but lucky for me I love it like this. Definitely would go again.“