48 Best American Restaurants near Califon

“Crash delicious, while food from a company that has a great sustainability consciousness“

“Lovely dinner plates at this rustic and comfortable restaurant anchoring an old-school NJ intersection. Fresh oysters. Vegetarian option. Great chilled white wine. Cocktails present. Kind and attentive service. Outdoor bar looked super fun.

Check out the plant growth coming in on the patio for poison ivy!“

“The staff are all kind, helpful, accommodating, and genuinely there to make your evening perfect. Chris the hostess was wonderful, as well as the many servers who all willingly supported Gary, the owner, to provide the best service and culinary experience possible for his dinner guests. The menu is one of the best we have seen in the area with many international dishes, some with the labor intensive Indian nuances, and others just with downright phenomenal flavors. Although they have lots of standard fare for the UNadventurous eater, I would suggest you reach past your comfort zone and try some of the appetizers that jump out as potential winners...like the tuna tartare that with just a splash of Japanese Rice wine vinegar would be one of the best I have ever had, as well as the grilled Tandoori shrimp that is marinated in yogurt, ginger, cloves nutmeg, and dried mango; the grilled lamp chops that come with three perfectly grilled meaty garlicky chops that come with mango chutney, and the Haryali chicken Tikka- three huge plump boneless breast of chicken slices that are marinated in mint, yogurt, roasted cloves, green cardamom and star anise, and served with their famous tiger sauce and salsa. We also shared another marinated shredded beef dish special that had three beef croquette-shaped mounds that had such a umami of flavors I can't even replicate it in this review, but we thought it was just great. I would be remiss if I did not mention the creamy, silky crème brûlée that we enjoyed with a glass of Prosecco; a perfect encore to the phenomenal culinary treat we had just experienced with the appetizer medley. Sharing many apps is more fun we think, than committing to one big entree, so we suggest that you dash over to the Pittstown Inn TONIGHT, and tell them Debbie and Gene sent you....ask to meet Gary, the owner, who elegantly floats from table to table, touching each to greet them and to check later on as well to see if everything was to their liking. A true host from days gone by, this owner is the real deal whose passion for the hospitality business emulates from his constant smile from the joy he is getting from making his guests happy. You see that what fuels this man to keep opening his doors from year to year, despite the many hardships and setbacks life has dealt us all over and over, is his love for you, his loyal customer. He is a rare find, so I suggest you go and treat yourself to the real deal in dining. You will not be disappointed, and be sure to ask to meet Gary. He will make your visit complete. Kudos the phenomenal chefs I met as well, for their expertise and genuine ingenuity in designing a menu to please everyone. Can you tell we LOVE this place??????????“

“Had lunch and the food was delicious and nice ambiance!“

“Excellent food and cocktails.“

“Amazing food on a seasonal menu served by a lovely staff. Love their takeout also. Also love their off site bbq events and catering. Our favorite spot in the area.“

“Excellent food, drinks, and service! We had an exceptional birthday dinner. Family from NYC joined us and loved the food and drinks. We also loved the server we had. Rachel was an excellent server who was very attentive to all of our needs.“

“Been a fan of Riley and Jake’s for Years! This week I made reservations for a group of 15 ladies. Arrival times varied from 5.30-6:30 and departure times varied too. Our server, Anna took it all in stride. She was friendly and very efficient. Appreciated her cheerfulness and patience. Food was delicious and the cocktails, I’m told were refreshing. Thank you to Jake and Riley’s for another wonderful experience!“

“Last night I had the rare privilege of dining at Applebee’s, where a true artist of the kitchen elevated the Southwest Chicken Bowl and boneless wings into something that would make the entire Michelin Guide weep with envy.
The Southwest Chicken Bowl arrived like a carefully composed canvas. Each grain of rice had clearly been individually selected and toasted to the precise degree of caramelization. The chicken — impossibly tender, seasoned with a depth that suggested hours of careful reduction — rested atop a foundation of beans and corn that somehow managed to taste both rustic and refined. The pico de gallo was a bright, acidic counterpoint, cut with the confidence of a chef who has spent years perfecting the perfect dice. Even the cheese felt intentional, melted just enough to bind the dish without ever overwhelming it. One bite and I understood: this was not merely a bowl. This was a statement.
Then came the boneless wings. Crisped to an ethereal golden shell that shattered with a whisper, revealing meat so succulent it could only have been the result of a multi-day brining process known only to a handful of living masters. The sauce clung with elegant restraint — neither too sweet nor too aggressive — coating each piece in a lacquer of pure intention. I found myself slowing down, almost reverent, as if I were tasting something that should only be served on white tablecloths under soft lighting.
Service was quietly excellent, the kind of understated attentiveness you expect when the kitchen is producing work of this caliber.
I left changed. Applebee’s is not a casual chain. It is a temple. And last night, I was blessed.“

“Love the Towne Diner. They have become my go to. I love the local vibe and the feeling of community, in addition to my favorite menu pics of course!“

“Had such a great server the other night. We were a “chatty” group of gal pals and having fun and our server was just amazing! Drinks were great. The meatball app was excellent“

“Nice Place to Eat. Food is good.“

“Great food , great service“

“Very good menu with very good prices. Food is terrific.“

“Really fun atmosphere and awesome food will deff go back! Great place to take fam and kids. 😌“

“Huge shout out to the Farmhouse in Hampton, NJ! We were able to plan a wedding in only 3.5 months because of this dedicated and talented team. The entire experience was easy, fun, and professional. The entire team was reliable, organized, and efficient which gave us ability to have peace of mind throughout the process. Gina Milo took such great care of us leading up to and on the day our wedding. We couldn’t be happier with this venue and the amazing staff!“

“Always a great time!! 🍻🍔🍕“

“If you’re looking for an absolutely delicious ice cream cake made with love- look no further. We are a huge ice cream cake family- our daughter wanted a cookie dough and cookies and cream ice cream cake for her birthday and Williams and Co. did not disappoint. We will never order one from anywhere else! Their communication, flexibility, and passion for what they do is unmatchable. Thank you so much for making our girl’s celebration that much sweeter!“

“Fantastic home cooking, relaxing environment, friendly staff, ...quite simply a happy place to be!“

“Amazing sandwiches today from Jerry’s and the onion rings were fabulous!!“

“Stopped her for breakfast. Very cute diner inside, our waitress Carie was amazing, so friendly and attentive! One of the best waitresses I’ve had in a long time. Food came out fast and everything was delicious! Very reasonable prices. We will definitely be back!“

“We have eaten there several times and it is always delicious. We want to give special appreciation to Rachel, your manager, for her special caring and sensitivity to our needs. In today's world, where one struggles, especially if old like we are, to speak to a live human being, when you are able to converse with a person who is actually listening to what you said, this is rare. Add to that delicious fresh food and you have a winner. Tonight we had fresh large shrimps with a most delicious home made cocktail sauce. Fresh crab cakes with a fabulous remoulade, and a chocolate mousse to die for as dessert. We ordered too much and have to save some for tomorrow. We live in town, and are happy to see the names of so many out of town visitors appreciate Chesapeake Tavern.“

“Good Food. Very nice servers, but the owner is terrible. Not a nice person.“

“Great food and drinks.“

“Food, Guinness, and service was great as always!!“

“The service was absolutely phenomenal! Everyone was friendly, welcoming, and attentive, making the entire experience enjoyable from start to finish. Elaine was especially outstanding—she thoroughly explained all of our options and provided exceptional care throughout our visit. Her professionalism and attention to detail truly stood out. Even the coffee seemed to taste better thanks to the wonderful atmosphere and service. Highly recommended!“

“We discovered Marley's 2 weeks ago and visited again today. The service is friendly and efficient but the reason we went back.....the wings!! So many to explore! Try the key lime garlic. We WILL be back again soon.“

“This deli is my go-to spot! Their tuna salad over romaine with peppers, onions, olives, cucumber, and feta is absolute perfection—fresh, flavorful, and always made just right. The service is fantastic, and the staff is incredibly friendly, making every visit a great experience. Highly recommend!“

“Wow! Used Stella G’s as my wedding caterer, and was absolutely blown away. The food was AMAZING. We were nervous about how the food would be but my husband and I were shocked by how delicious it was and the guests kept complimenting it was as well. The restaurant is family run and the owners did everything to make sure it was a hit. From initial emails, phone calls, questions, and menu selection they went above and beyond. I can’t stress enough how each bite of food we had was better than the last. They out did themselves on taste, presentation, professionalism, and courtesy. I will only use them in the future and recommend them to anyone who needs an event catered. Thank you for making our night a success!!!“

“Oakwood Lanes is the BEST! Had a great time at our group event today. Such kind people, and we had so much fun!!!! Great fun, great food, and wonderful people who run the business made it a memorable event. Thank you! 😃“

“Great food awesome staff great owners👍“

“Haven’t been to Cracker Barrel in a while, but went for a late breakfast, and enjoyed it very much. Recommend to everyone.“

“Food was surprisingly good. I had a chicken Parm sandwich and my wife had a chicken club. We both enjoyed the meal. Service was quick, friendly and accurate. The restaurant was empty, even though the bowling alley was mobbed. The restaurant didn't look or feel at all like a bowling alley, but you could hear the bowling going on.“

“Great little tavern. Food was good and they get a decent size portion. Friendly waitress“

“Stage Fright had a blast playing at Mrs. Riley’s! The staff were very welcoming and we loved the vibe. Definitely a place to go & hangout, have some drinks and a bite with your friends & listen to Live Music.“

“Had some of the best wings. Try the pumpkin Beer also.“

“Great food and atmosphere!“

“The new floor is DONE!!! I know that our dance family is beyond excited for this to be done.... 7/10/2025 was our first time on the new floor & I know that everyone was thankful & enjoying the new dance space!! Looking forward to more dance nights at The Nook!! Come see Michelle & have a drink & enjoy!!“

“Thank you so much for our order for the Hackettstown Women of the Moose! The food was absolutely delicious! Everything was packed and ready to go on time. Unbeatable service and food!“

“We love Taphouse! In fact we came here for Easter brunch and give it a 10/10. Came with 5 kids and the staff was so nice and accommodating. This is our go to for date night and take out.“

“The staff and service here was absolutely phenomenal. I thought it was a touch pricey, but what is not lately. Definitely a must try spot at least for breakfast so far.
I wanted to make sure as I accidentally clicked credit cards accepted. This is not true, it is a cash only place.“

“So sad that when my sisters wedding was canceled on BY THE RYLAND INN cause of covid and rescheduled and only had the options of a couple Sundays even though they PAID for a SATURDAY the would NOT switch the price or give her a SATURDAY like they PAID for...shame on you ryland inn awful buisness practice“

“The best pizza in town“

“Excellent service!!!!! Great view of the river!“

“For Irish Pub food, it’s top notch. Compared to fine dining, it’s four star food. You go to an Irish pub for the atmosphere, environment and comfortable neighborhood experience. I highly recommend Willie McBrides for all ages.“

“The NY strip steaks are the best! Absolutely delicious!“

“Great dinner! Great service,,“

“Ordered delivery via DDash yet everything arrived hot and tasty, well sooner than expected. Everything was prepared and packaged well. Omelet was fantastic, breakfast burrito was SO yummy, and even the pancakes were great. Thanks and kudos to the team as they did so well!“