11 Best Italian Restaurants in Collingswood

“Lovely atmosphere, very good food and our Waiter Nick was wonderful!“

“My husband and I had the pleasure of celebrating my mother-in-law's 85th birthday at Michael Coastal Italian Grille during restaurant week. Our dining experience was exceptional, marked by unparalleled food quality and exquisite presentation. The owners treated us like VIPs, ensuring a truly memorable evening. The beautiful birthday display and dessert they presented made the evening truly unforgettable. The impeccable white-glove service left us thoroughly impressed, and we cannot praise the experience enough. My mother-in-law was profoundly grateful for the special birthday celebration. We eagerly anticipate our next visit!“

“We had our son’s rehearsal dinner here, everything was great . We Had Taylor , who did everything, she was by herself, due to someone calling out . She severed over 30 people from Appetizers to dessert all with a smile . She helped set everything up and was amazing . Great food and atmosphere! A super special shout out to Taylor , she’s an absolute ROCKSTAR!“

“Finally decent pizza in Collingswood! After shopping on the avenue, we stopped in for lunch. Honey got a gourmet “Chicken Marco Polo” pizza and I opted for a Sports salad, loaded with fresh grilled chicken and really enough for two people. We have been to the Montegrillo’s in Pennsauken but this is closer to home with the same great menu“

“The food is always amazing. They do a great job handling larger groups too, so it is a favorite amongst our fraternity alumni club members.“

“Everything we ordered was great .“

“My niece had her law school graduation party here the other night and the entire family, 21 of us, cannot say enough about the excellent food and service that we received. My elderly mother and I were early when they were still setting up, and they welcomed us with open arms and got us some coffee because it was so rainy and cold. The food was excellent. We had many courses, and my sister-in-law said that they were extremely accommodating and offered many choices at a good price for the menu. The owner was lovely to work with. I cannot say enough about how excellent the food was as was the superb service that we received from the entire team. They were on every need amidst a very busy restaurant while navigating around walkers and people like absolute pros... with a smile on their face the entire time. I sincerely hope that the owner and staff see this review.“

“I attempted to get another carry out order on Sunday, January 11th. App indicated the restaurant was open for business. Then I got a cancellation on the online order app. A 5 minute ride over to the restaurant Showed the proof of it not being open. Disappointing! I ended up going over to another italian restaurant up the street. I told the person what I encountered , and immediately , he said , yes , they have a reputation with being a little sketchy , sometimes with operation.“

“great pizza place! would recommend to anyone!“

“Are you really selling the franchise you built from the ground up? I heard this from a guy in Maple Shade.“

“My first time buying from here via phone. I purchased a hoagie tray for after a funeral service at a friend's house, at pretty much last minute. I had trouble finding the place too. My cell went crazy, and it froze. I couldn't pick up the food on time. To make matters worse each time they tried to reach me ,well my cell wouldn't allow me to answer the call either. Finally we connected and they were extremely understandable. Super helpful in providing directions to get there via phone. I was going in the opposite direction. Thank you nice lady on the phone sorry I don't recall your name. The nice young man Justin too! You guys made my night.I must return I know I owe you one.Please also give the owners one word of advice, please get a better sign (bigger with lights). Thank you again nice lady on the phone and Justin. Happy ending. I haven't forgotten about you two.My super hero's of the night!!!For the atmosphere I gave a few stars because I didn't hear noise in the back ground while on the call all though the phone while getting there.I know you have delivery, but I didn't have my friends address nor did I know the time we would arrive there.Thank you all again.“