50 Best Pizza Restaurants near East Amwell

“Simple and fun place for the best pizza around! Ringoes best kept secret - Franks Pizza! We love the regular pie but you can’t go wrong with the Sicilian either. So good!“

“After many friends telling how good AMA is I decided to grab a pie and meatball parm sub to give them a go. My words will not give their food justice but it is delicious. Napoletan done the right way. Not to mention the owner is beyond good people. Greeted me outside while I was waiting for them to open and then offered me an espresso while my food was being prepared. We will most certainly be back.“

“Really good food and service. We really miss going but moved to Pennsylvania. However this spring we will be in more frequently.“

“Vito and his staff are amazing and the food is always above and beyond have never had a meal or pizza I haven’t liked. Food is always fresh and hot when I pick up. Thank you for all you do!“

“This pizza is out of this world. I drive far for this and it’s so worth it every single time. Love the truffle pie.“

“All .. salad pizza is my favorite“

“A great local spot with excellent food. The staff is friendly and makes you feel welcomed. Stop by if you can, you won't regret it.“

“Excellent food and better people. Food is very tasty, fresh, and great 'inventions'. Love Angelo, Lorenzo, and Emilio. They treat you like family. You will find homemade scones made by Angelo which are very good. No one makes a better white pizza than Angelo. All the pizza is very good, the bacon chicken ranch one of my favorites. And the dinners, Jim loves the seafood, are always very delicious. No better server than Lorenzo. He knows you and will recommend for what you might like. Love the hugs. Couldn't ask for a better gem in Flemington. It is my happy place, which is what is saved on my phone.“

“My wife and I had the Margherita pie on the olive oil crust tonight for lent and it was sinfully amazing. It was so good I think I will have to go to confession. Joe and the team are rocking. Thank you for being dedicated to great food. I try pizza all through NJ, CT, NY and PA to search out pies that are above average (haven't found a great pie in PA - sorry). Great pies are all different - there are many styles, but a really good pie is a really good pie. And this is a really good pie. I hope you enjoy it, we will be back to try the other offerings.“

“I grew up eating Nicolas pizza and moved away as a young adult. Upon visiting Nicolas over a decade later, the pizza was so good it quite literally made me cry. I cannot recommend it enough. In this humble cooks opinion, this place makes the best pizza in the world.“

“Out of all Nomad Pizza 🍕 restaurants from NJ to PA, this has to be my favorite. The pizzas are simply the best here. Just wish they would take credit cards, would be so much more convenient.“

“Food is awesome but it's the service that makes this place better than just good. Tonight my car wouldn't start and someone who worked in the restaurant came out in the freezing cold to help me. It reminds me that there are good people in the world. Thank you!“

“5 ☆☆☆☆☆ Great cozy little Pizza Restaurant. The food and service is 2nd to none! Highly recommend!“

“I would like to say that this is the best pizzeria in Hillsborough NJ! Truly I love the service when ever I deliver it’s always a on time and they always let me know when they are here thru txt message, also the food is amazing!!! The pizza and everything else on that menu! Thankyou so much Bella pizza 🤍🤍🤍“

“Best in the Lambertville area, highly recommeded.“

“Glad to see Catanzs back in action!! We just had a Large pie with Peppers & Onions delivered for dinner. Awesome…no disappointments here. Crispy crust….thin like we ordered it. You guys rock!! Thanks!!“

“Love their food one problem they always deliver to my house on a Sunday I called up ordering for delivery the guy told me that they don’t deliver to my area Told him your boss told me you do he asked his boss he then said oh well we’re backed up so why don’t you order from the Hillsboro one the Hillsboro one is further away from me then Flemington location I will give them another shot because I like their food but I’m making it clear I’m unhappy with their staff and the way I was treated when all I wanted was a pizza Sunday night“

“Absolutely wonderful! I ordered Mamma’s Tomato Sauce with pasta and it hit the spot! Tasty and amazing!! Couldn’t recommend more and I will definitely order again or stop in next time!“

“Absolutely the best pizza around!“

“Great food, friendly service! Highly recommend!“

“While your food is delicious, your customer service need work. Some of the younger kids rush you off the phone and when you pick up your food its even worse. no thank you, no nothing. just sign here and they walk away. almost short of bring rude“

“We eat there often and are never disappointed. The food is delicious and the service is very professional. The atmosphere is warm and welcoming. Additionally, I had a catered affair there for Chrismas Eve and it was wonderful. There were 19 people who are still raving about the food and service...which is so rewarding on a night that the restaurant was crowded with many groups celebrating.“

“Amazing food, and I ordered their lunch specials, cripsy chicken sandwiches, and fries, and it's definitely worth it. The service is fast. The chicken was prepared very well, and the grandma sauce was delicious. The fries that came with meal tasted very food. I will order from here if I am around this place. Definitely support this business. Good service, and they do have indoor and outdoor seating, a very casual atmosphere. Restrooms on premises, too. Small parking lot. The menu is robust.“

“I love there buffalo pizza 😋so delicious“

“Ate in dining room for pizza and pasta. Pizza came out hot and fresh, fried calamari was very good and the chicken francaise was hot, tasty and plentiful. Great for a casual meal whether it’s pizza you crave or a pasta or meat dish. Service was good not overly friendly but they served as expected and checked in on us. Take out seems to be very popular here. Good for kids.“

“I grew up in the area and this is my go to place when I am back in the area. I stop every single time.“

“Love this place Friendly staff excellent food and service,great atmosphere and fair price“

“very good service, friendly staff and delicious food.“

“This has become our go-to pizza/italian place. It’s not the closest pizza place to us, but it is worth the few minutes extra drive. Highly recommend the penne vodka, and their soups especially the cream of broccoli (and I’m not a broccoli fan)“

“Everything, EVERYTHING they make is so wonderful. The salads are creative, use lots of seasonal ingredients. The pasta is wonderful. Gnocchi Vodka...OMG. The meatball, braised short ribs, sausage is truly special. We seldom go out but when we go there, the atmosphere and service are great. We mostly order to pickup. Never had a problem. Well worth the extra bucks compared to other Italian restaurants nearby. Go there or order pickup! No disappointment!“

“Got 6 pizzas from gabbys for a bounce city birthday party. My son has a severe egg allergy and they promised to mark a pie and take extra care with it. He was able to eat it without any issue and we all enjoyed the pizza a lot. Thank you Gabby’s!“

“Awesome - love the broccoli rabe and sausage appetizer - so good Great pasta and chicken dishes also.“

“The food is tremendous and the staff is awesome“

“The endless games....and the stuffed crust pepperoni pizza😋“

“Jose is a top shelf cook. The pizza is top shelf. Let’s just say the entrees will not disappoint you. The picture I posted is a chicken dish with broccoli rabe tomato’s chicken over garlic bread. Wonderful!!!! Highly recommended and you will not be disappointed.“

“Our food was delicious! Stuffed shrimp and veal with mushrooms in a frangelica cream sauce.“

“praise for recent improvements, including fresher ingredients, better-cooked pizzas with fluffier crusts, and enhanced customer service, with efficient, polite staff and timely deliveries, even noticed delicious deep-dish orders nicely done“

“This place is a hidden gem . We were there the other night with 5 people and everyone loved the food they ordered. We have been there a couple of times since it changed ownership and it’s great. It seems to be empty except on the weekends and I have no idea why. Maybe because it’s a few miles out of town. It’s more than worth the drive in my opinion !“

“Outstanding food, great atmosphere and attentive staff.“

“I have lived in this area for 3 years now and i have been ordering pizza from this location and the pizzas have been mediocre, but I think a new person is now making a pizza because since the past few weeks, the pizza has been AMAZING. OH MY GOD!!!. The new york style pizza is so thin, and the light sauce (requested) is put on it with so much finesse. I want to kiss the hands of this new person who is making the pizza. Absolutely delicious.“

“August 3, 2024....Just had the most delicious meal in recent memory, the Stuffed Chicken Breast over Spaghetti Puttanesca at Amalfi's in Lawrenceville!!! Outstanding! MUST TRY!!!! If you are fortunate enough to get ANDRES as your server as well, you will have a PERFECT dining experience.“

“really cute place we drove 1 1/2 the fried chicken was so good my son had 2 drum sticks he also had soft serve twist with rainbow sprinkles and he loved it. the mashed poatotes was to die for. the Philly chesee steak was good to. we will be back again“

“Always great food and excellent service highly recommended! Never a bad meal love the sweet and sour calamari !!!“

“Visiting from out of town and this restaurant was recommended to me. I ordered the chicken francese with linguine. It was divine. The chicken was so good it felt like it was melting in my mouth. I highly recommend this place to eat. Especially this dish.“

“I recommend New World Pizza & Cafe. Their pizza is amazing and they have great customer service. Anthony Dimeglio, owner of New World Pizza does a great job with customer service. I highly recommend booking New World Pizza & Cafe for your next event.“

“Everything is so GOOD! I'll be back!“

“Muy bueno todo, un poco expensive pero bueno 🙂“

“Delicious food and reasonable price“

“excellent and quick service, Delicious food and a great atmosphere !! The owner is very nice and attentive to every customer making sure they are having a good time while eating the delicious food.“

“Went there with the family (10 people), the food was good, service was correct (the waitress was nice and got pretty much everything right), could have checked up on us more often (probably short-staffed). Nothing special about the atmosphere.
I would go back there.“