Custom Cakes near Fairfield, NJ

Calandra's Bakery Bakery • $$$
244 US-46, Fairfield

Customers` Favorites

Vanilla Cupcake and Strawberry Shortcake Cupcake
Brownies NY Style Cheesecake Cannoli & Eclairs
Mixed Small Pastries
Chocolate Mousse
Pepperoni Bread
Mini Pecan Pie
Cookie Display
Chocolate Cake
Birthday Cake
Sausage Bread

“Located off a busy 46 East in Fairfield, this family-owned and operated establishment is one of our favorites for sweet desserts and Italian pastries. Upon arrival at Calandra’s, the recently remodeled bakery was busy, which is a good thing, and moved fast on Easter Sunday. Parking was not a problem. My partner and I decided on an 8” raspberry square cake. The cake was not only visually stunning, but it was also incredibly delicious. The flavors were perfectly balanced, and the moist layers melted in our mouths. We can recommend this place.“

3.8 Good68 Reviews
Sweet Kneads by Ridhima Bakery •
38 S Livingston Ave, Livingston - 6.19 miles

Customers` Favorites

Gluten Free Strawberries and Cream Cake Jar
Oreo Cakewich-Oreo Lover’S Dream
Gulab Jamun Rabri Mousse Cupcake
Assorted Mini Cupcakes-Dozen
Cold Coffee Tres Leches
Chocolate Chip Cookies
Dirty Coffee Cake Jar
Gluten Free Brownies
Rasmalai Tres Leches
Cookie Dough Cupcake

“So happy we reached out to Ridhima for our daughter’s hunger games -Mocking Jay theme birthday party. The cake was delicious to eat and gorgeous. Pictures don’t do it justice. Ridhima is very easy to work with and v patient. Highly recommend Sweet Kneads!“

5 Superb65 Reviews
Stuff by SJ Bakery •
342 Bloomfield Ave, Montclair - 6.88 miles

Customers` Favorites

Chocolate Dipped Oreos
Strawberry Cake Cup
Celebration Cakes
Classic Cupcake
Birthday Cake
Cake Cups

“Really impressed! We asked Stuff by SJ to make a custom cake for a pizza-themed birthday party. Working with them (Drew) was super easy and stress free. They were helpful, responsive, well priced and even delivered our cake to the restaurant ahead of the party. Everyone complimented the design and taste of the cake so it was a big hit. I’d definitely go back to them for our next cake.“

4.8 Superb79 Reviews
Mo & Jay Pastry Pastry shop •
44 Main St Suite 1, Little Falls - 4.17 miles

“***4 1/2 stars**I'm not sure how crazy I am about this place being a few blocks from where I live, but I suppose that's not Mo & Jay's fault. I've been aware of this bakery/pastry establishment for a few years (I think it showed up in this relatively new apartment building on Main Street two or three years ago), but hadn't actually thought to go inside until yesterday morning. I was entrusted with obtaining a dessert for a weekend BBQ, and it occurred to me that this was at least the easiest spot to quickly grab something. The fact that the desserts were extremely good ended up being a pleasant accident/bonus.I brought one of my top tier chums to assist with the purchase. From very brief research, it seemed like the eclairs were the big selling point here. I thought it would also be a little wily on my part to get them because I tend to not enjoy eating food that has stuff in it, and figured I'd be unlikely to do anything too naughty with that. That turned out not to be accurate, but I digress. We got the five for $25 éclair deal, and procured a raspberry, a lemon meringue, a nutella, a pistachio and a cookies & cream. Just as we were about to wrap up, I also impulsively grabbed a cheddar/bacon scone, which was humongous and understandably caught my eye.The eclairs were definitely a hit. My personal favorite was the cookies & cream. The flavor was incredibly on point, and it was almost like a meta ice cream experience. The only issue with that one specifically was that the cream inside was runnier than the other pastries, which made it a little messy. Not a huge deal. The runner-up was probably the raspberry for me. Again, extremely flavorful, almost to a fault - it was overwhelmingly tart, which is obviously kind of a calling card for raspberries but if you're not into that, I'd stay away. The nutella was actually a little on the bland side for me but not bad. The lemon meringue was a big hit for everyone else, but I'm not a huge fan of that flavor to begin with - I don't think that's a mark against this place by any means. In hindsight, we probably wouldn't have gotten the pistachio, but none of us are hardcore pistachio fans. The cream consistency and dough for all of these was very high quality, and understandably a lot of this is going to come down to how you feel about specific flavors.In a final twist later on, I sampled the scone around dinner time and was very pleasantly surprised - the scone was very moist and tasty, and was reminiscent of a Red Lobster cheddar bay biscuit, though probably at least twice the size and with actual pieces of bacon in it. Very strong recommend on that front.The service was very good. We had a pleasant female cashier assisting us as my chum was literally squatting on the ground eagerly peering into the display case squealing out flavors to get. Zero issues there, and we were in and out within a few minutes uneventfully. There were also a lot of cakes and other types of pastries, so I expect I'll be returning shortly to obtain their assistance with another BBQ.“

4.8 Superb38 Reviews
Creations by Sabrina Bakery • $
706 Main St, Boonton - 5.7 miles

Customers` Favorites

Birthday Cake
Wedding Cake
S'Mores Bar
Cupcake

“In 2023 we had our daughter design our wedding cake. We went to many places and some couldn’t design it the way that it was in the sketchbook. They wanted to take off a tier or change the flowers for fake flowers. When we came to Creations we not only found the perfect flavors but they said they could make it the way it was sketched out. They asked for the colors I wanted and the type of wedding to get a sense of what we wanted. Let me tell you, we wren’t disappointed. It was as if the cake came to life. Cake arrived on time and intact. Thank you Creations for being so reliably amazing.“

4.8 Superb35 Reviews
Gio’s Gelato & Espresso Bar Ice Cream Shop • $
822 Franklin Ave, Franklin Lakes - 10.87 miles

Customers` Favorites

Bomboloni

“The best gelato in NJ hands down. I'm from Europe and always have a hard time finding authentic gelato, well this is it! I drive from NY to Gio's for the affogato with nocciola gelato, and my girls love the strawberry one. Delicious, local, and the owner/staff are wonderful people.“

4.9 Superb26 Reviews
Mattarello Bakery & Café Bakery • $
254 Bellevue Ave, Montclair - 5.88 miles

Customers` Favorites

Lobster Tail Napoleon Rainbow Cake Raspberry Mousse
Bombolone
Tiramisu

“This was my first time visiting Mattarello bakery and I will definitely come back!When I walked in - I was welcomed by smiling and happy barista.It was hard to choose what I wanted to try,they have a lot off different cookies,pastries and cakes,the lady who was working there helped me to choose the perfect pastries to try.I had bombolone donut with custard cream, lobster tail with chantilly cream and a large cappuccino.Everything tasted amazing.Fresh,a lot(!!!)of filling which made me really happy.For coffee lovers - they have different types of milk to choose for your cappuccino,latte or matcha latte.I had a cappuccino with almond milk and look at the cute bear!I can’t wait to come back another time to try something new!?☕️ “

4.5 Superb61 Reviews
Delice macarons madison nj Bakery •
82 Main St, Madison - 10.35 miles

Customers` Favorites

Hazelnut Chcolate Croissant
Almond Hazelnut Croissant
Egg & Cheese Sandwiches
Chocolate Chip Cookie
Baguettes

“I truly beautiful, and amazing Cafe, with beautiful decor on the inside and out!The owner takes pride and absolutely everything that comes out of the kitchen, which is handcrafted and made with love! Some of the best chocolate chip cookies, flourless, brownies, cakes, macaroons, and croissants, as big as your head!“

4.7 Superb21 Reviews
Lake Hiawatha Dairy Ice Cream Shop • $
79 N Beverwyck Rd, Lake Hiawatha - 3.99 miles

Customers` Favorites

Chocolate Peanut Butter Ice Cream
Chocolate Ice Cream
Vanilla Soft Serve
Ice Cream Treats
Ice Cream Cakes
Black Raspberry
Birthday Cake
Easter Cakes

“I recently went to Lake Hiawatha Dairy and had the most AMAZING experience!!! They have so many great tasting, homemade, fresh ice cream flavors to pick from with some being very unique! Blueberry Pie For The Win! They also have plenty of to-go cup sizes to pick from! The toppings selection is plentiful and delicious! The owner, Karen, and staff, Amy and Bianca, are so nice, helpful, and wonderful to talk to. Make sure to visit ASAP!!! You won't be disappointed!!! HIGHLY RECOMMENDED!!!“

4.5 Superb47 Reviews
Three Daughters Baking Bakery •
12 Vose Ave, South Orange - 9.8 miles

Customers` Favorites

8 Inch Feeds 12 - 16
Croissant
Bakery

“I ordered 2 dozen cupcakes from Three Daughters Baking Company for our daughter’s Baby Shower on Feb. 25, 2024. They did a wonderful job accommodating my request. The cupcakes were delicious and not too sweet. I had sent them a Pinterest photo of how I wanted them to “swirl” the icing so it would look like a flower on top and use several colors of icing because I was going to arrange them in a “cupcake bouquet.” I was very pleased with how the cupcakes tasted and also how they looked.Photos attached show the cupcakes by Three Daughters Baking. (The flower stems and ribbon were provided by the customer. )Their service, their food and everything was excellent! I highly recommend Three Daughters Baking Company!“

4.6 Superb27 Reviews
Mia’s ice cream Ice Cream Shop •
78 Main St, Bloomingdale - 8.33 miles

“This ice cream shop is a GEM! The variety of flavors is so impressive and each is delicious. We have LOVED Lavender Sky, Pistachio Rose, dairy free Pistachio, Rainbow Cookie, Cheesecake and a Rocky Road. Yummie :)Such a cute little spot for a quick drop in. I don’t see myself returning to a big chain ice cream shop again, this little spot tops them all by far. Enjoy!!“

4.6 Superb23 Reviews
Flavor For Favors LLC Bakery • $$
222 Fairway Ave, Belleville - 8.88 miles

“Wow wow wow! I ordered 3 dozen Minecraft themed cupcakes for my son's sixth birthday, and they were amazing! The cupcakes looked amazing and tasted even better! So soft and fluffy. And the buttercream topping was so smooth and not too sweet. Jason will not disappoint if you need a baked cake for an event. HIGHLY RECOMMEND!!“

5 Superb7 Reviews
Rudy's Pastry Shop Bakery • $$
23 Willet St, Bloomfield - 9.04 miles

“We ordered a custom cake for my wife's birthday celebration and it was perfect, as tasty as it was beautiful. Colleen worked with us on finding the perfect design, and helped us choose a great filling. Highly recommend Rudy's for a special occasion.“

4.7 Superb11 Reviews
David's Custom Cakes Bakery • $$
1237 Belmont Ave, North Haledon - 8.17 miles

“We had a custom Ups truck made for our wedding on September 30th, 2023. They did an amazing job!!! The cake was magnificent. There wasn't a person who wasn't blow away when they saw the cake. It tasted good, too. We will always use David's Custom Cakes when we have an event. Their communication and delivery were also perfect.“

4.5 Superb20 Reviews
Borinquen Bakery Bakery • $
406 Broadway, Newark - 11.01 miles

Customers` Favorites

Sandwich De Amon Queso Bacon Y Huevo
Sándwich De Pastrami
Bacon Egg and Cheese
Pan Sobao Y Quesito
Tripleta Sandwich
Pastrami Sandwich
Flan Y Tembleque
Beef Empanada
Sugar Donuts
Empanadas

“My favorite little Bakery in Newark. The ladies are always so pleasant. I usually get the pan sobao con mantequilla y cafe. Deliciousness!!! Ive ordered the morcilla from here. It comes frozen and you have to cook it at home. It is so good. My mother loves the Rice pudding they make for Christmas and the Budín. Honestly, I haven't had anything and been disappointed.“

4.4 Superb34 Reviews
Frozen In Time NJ Ice Cream Shop • $
129 S Livingston Ave, Livingston - 6.36 miles

“Under new ownership, this shop is amazing! The ice cream selection is great and so are the toppings. Name brand toppings, not the gross knock offs. As well as soft serve, ice cream sandwiches and also they have cakes coming soon.This is my favorite ice cream place, glad we have such a good one right around the corner from us!And they're open year round! Love ice cream even in the winter!“

4.3 Superb40 Reviews
Ice Cream Station & Deli Ice Cream Shop • $
10 Lakeside Ave, Pompton Lakes - 8.45 miles

“Stopped by today my first time and i must say EVERYTHING was amazing the food, ice cream & the service was top notch we had her home made chicken rice soup ,Italian combo and chicken salad sandwich made by Song she took such good care of us through her busy shift and made us feel so welcomed ! Her cakes are unbelievable she is so gifted ?❤️“

4.2 Good41 Reviews
Keeping You Sweet Bakery • $$$
1400 Willowbrook Mall KIOSK 5536, Wayne - 2.45 miles

“I stumbled upon Keeping You Sweet while at the Willowbrook Mall, and naturally, I had to get some gluten-free goodies. The kiosk is in a central location and easily accessible. I was able to place a small order and the person working at the counter was helpful with making recommendations. I was delightfully surprised by the apple cupcake I got, it was so sweet, balanced, and light. They were sold out of gf lemon options when I went, which only means I'll need to return and try again!“

4.2 Good23 Reviews
Gencarelli's Bakery Bakery • $$
446 Broad St, Bloomfield - 7.87 miles

Customers` Favorites

Black and White Cookie
Strawberry Cheesecake
Strawberry Shortcake
Birthday Cake
Carrot Cake
Doughnut
Brownies
Eclairs
Cookies
Bakery

“I have been buying cakes and bread since 1999 for this bakery! I had a very bad experience on Saturday, March 30, 2024. We ordered my daughter‘s birthday cake 12 days ahead of time, when I went to pick it up the rude manager said I have to wait on that line.. I advised it was already paid in full, and it was not fair to me to wait half an hour online, but she didn’t care. I did advise the manager that I had to go to a venue ,and I didn’t want to be late, but she really didn’t care .I really think that they need to revamp this policy immediately,and make sure that when you order a cake or whatever you can go on a special line, not have to wait 30 minutes or something you already paid for. I understand The holiday policy, but my order was a birthday order. It had nothing to do with Easter ,and it was for the Saturday before. When it was ordered the girls did not tell me I’d also have to wait on Saturday to pick it up. They really need to have a better policy. My advice is the corner area to the right of the store would be for picking up prepaid orders only.“

4.1 Good79 Reviews
Plum Bakery Gluten Free Bakery • $
179 Glenridge Ave, Montclair - 6.8 miles

Customers` Favorites

Bakery

“Vegan cakes and cookies are lip-smackin delicious. If you’re not into dairy and eggs and butter in your baked goodies, you’ll be into Plum Bakery. Give it a shot, vegan friends.Vegetarian options: Cakes and cookiesDietary restrictions: Vegan, vegetarian“

4 Good27 Reviews
Pink Sweets Cupcakes • $
581 Northfield Ave, West Orange - 7.94 miles

“Pink Sweets at our wedding waved their sweet wand and created an enchanting array of treats. From tantalizing brownies to luscious cupcakes, every bite was a heavenly delight. The flavors were divine, and the presentation was a work of art. Thanks to this cupcake shop, our taste buds were in seventh heaven, and our hearts were filled with sugary joy!“

3.8 Good21 Reviews
Loading...
map Map