20 Best Italian Restaurants in Freehold

“Owner should learn how to treat customers We were a party of four and we arrived on time for a 7:45 reservation. When we arrived there were many people waiting to be seated. We were told that the wait would only be 10 - 15 minutes. Fifteen minutes later we were told that the wait would be an additional 10 - 15 minutes. A half hour later my wife was told that the wait would only be another 10 - 15 minutes. After 45 minutes I requested to speak with the owner and I was told that I was speaking with the owner (at that point there was only one other group waiting to be seated). They informed me that a group of six with an 8:00 reservation was just seated. I said that it was not fair to make us wait 45 minutes since we did have a reservation and the people with a later reservation were just seated. I said that I may have something to say about it after the meal. The reply was "if you have something to say, say it now"! I replied that I would reserve my thoughts until after the meal. How insulting, imagine waiting over 45 minutes and then being told if I had anything to say I shouldn't wait till after my dinner, that I should say it now. I replied that I would wait till after the meal before I had any additional comments. With that we were refused service and we were told to leave. I am a 75 year old retired veteran and in my life I was never treated in this manner. When we grew up we had more respect for others. This is not how customers should be treated.“

“Our favorite date night spot!! From the moment you enter- elegant atmosphere, warm faces and nice music set the tone for a wonderful night. Anthony the owner makes you feel like you’re the only diners there- making sure you’re enjoying yourself, getting your food in a timely manner and making it special. He is such a kind generous man. The servers Faith, Carson, and JoJo are absolutely incredible- they are knowledgeable about the food, friendly, and their work ethic is incredible for such young people. They truly made our night special! The food is the star- best rice balls we’ve ever had!! We have been dreaming of them ever since! The homemade burrata, meatballs and eggplant were also just amazing. We had the homemade gnocchi and chicken scarpiello- again the best we’ve ever had We are locals and try to get here as often as we can for date night- and we are always so amazed how it continues to be just 5 star every time. It’s a special, special place and we are lucky to have such a gem in our small town. Thank you Anthony & Heather!“

“We had such a great dinner with friends. The food was outstanding and so was the service. We have never been disappointed when eating at this restaurant. I highly recommend for any occasion or no occasion.“

“Came here on a pickup….last order on a Sunday night. Had a few laughs and banter with staff here. Nice dudes along with their crew. Counter man offered me a slice to go which hit the spot on a long delivery night and it was superb! Highly recommended establishment!“

“Never had a meal I didn’t love“

“Yesterday we had a Luau/Pool party at our new Toll RegencyFreehold Community .. we explained to Frank we had a very bad experience with a previous caterer and he promised us we would be pleased and not to worry. Well, we weren’t just pleased, we were excited and we all felt DAngelos far exceeded our expectations. The compliments kept flowing during the party… the service, setup and food was AMAZING!! Thank you Frank for an awesome job! We can’t wait to call you for our next event!!“

“I attended an event at Frankie Fed's on June 30th. It was my first time at the restaurant but it definetly will not be my last! The thin crust pizza was the best I've ever eaten and the wait staff was great. I can't wait to go back!“

“Delicious food, wonderful staff and great music.“

“Every time I mention the Olive Garden, my Italian friends look at me funny and laugh but I swear the food is pretty good.
Yeah it may not be authentically Italian, but the food on their menu like the crisp and not chewy calamari, the creamy chicken Alfredo & shrimp Alfredo and even the spaghetti with eggplant is always on point. Every time either myself my wife or my teenage daughter orders from the menu we are quite happy.
Tonight our server Jaylen was awesome. She brought us our drinks, appetizers and main course pretty quick. She was very friendly, polite, and extremely helpful which is what every diner experience should be when you go out to eat.“

“Very good food. God service .“

“Had a bridal shower for 48 people. The food and the service was great. Everything ran smoothly. My guests raved about the food.“

“The food is amazing! We had a 4-day, outdoor event and ordered lunch delivery each day from Pies in Poets. Everyone loved the food! Christine helped us choose the variety of items; she was friendly, professional, and knowledgeable about their menu. Delivery was easy. We will be ordering again for our next event!“

“Besides the awesome food they have the best service of anywhere. We often travel over an hour to go there.“

“Food very good, best grandma pizza“

“We had visited Lemon for a special family celebration. Steve, Chef Ash and the entire team were absolutely amazing and hospitable. Service was great; food was delicious. A good times had by everyone. Thank you, Lemon!“

“Amazing food and prices! We use mateos for our catering and Friday night dinners!! They never disappoint and have loved each dish more than the last. Highly recommend!!“

“As regulars at Trevi, we can't say enough about how accommodating the staff is! They always make us feel welcome and go above and beyond to ensure we have a great experience. Their penne vodka is out of this world, and the pizza is simply fantastic! Whether you’re dining in or ordering out, you won’t be disappointed. We highly recommend Trevi to everyone—it's a must-visit!“

“Everything we order from Romeo’s is top shelf! Sunday we ordered the new items copper sharp cheesesteak and hot roast beef sandwiches…and can’t forget the disco fries! Delicious as usual! P.S. the large tray of cavatelli with sausage and broccoli rabe that we ordered last week to bring to my brother in laws was a big hit too!“

“Great food and nice people“

“Great food!! Never disappoints us!!“