Bagels Restaurants near Haskell, NJ

“The best bagel and breakfast spot in the state! Their food is amazing and so is the service.“

“If there were more stars, I'd give them. We are from out of state (formerly from Waldwick) and needed to send a brunch catering to a dear family. Bagel Supreme was professional, sweet, considerate and kind. I called on a Sunday afternoon at 1 PM (about an hour before the store closed) and the owner had his wife call "within the hour." She did and spent time with me on the phone getting the right order to fit my request for the family. Then sent multiple texts to confirm everything throughout the evening. Talk about going ABOVE AND BEYOND! They delivered PROMPTLY as promised the next day and they sent us pictures of the platters to ensure that we saw what was delivered. Greeting cards to mark the occasion with our thoughts HAND WRITTEN were attached. The store would NOT take money until the order was delivered even though I offered to pay in advance. I will absolutely use them in the future for long distance gift giving (who doesn't like food as a gift)? And this will be our very first stop when we are back in town. 1,000% recommend!!!“

“A great place..Rema, Nart, Willie and Mohammed are wonderful people...Homemade potato salad is delicious...Family owned business who takes care of the community and appreciates those who patronize their business...Thank you for always taking care of me...Willie your the Best....“

“Wayne Hot Bagels supplied breakfast for Teacher Appreciation Week and did a fabulous job! They were friendly, courteous, patient and worked with me to find items that fit within the budget. They even personally delivered for us free of charge. They truly were a pleasure to deal with and I would definitely use them again for future events!“

“Great place to stop ! Large variety of bagels, Plus a lot more then just bagels! Always a friendly face to serve you too !“

“I’m I’m absolute awe!! This was my first time in this establishment and the faculty are super friendly and educated on the gluten free diet (they keep their GF bagels in a separate section) The gluten free bagels here are to die for. I’m talking the perfect outside and a literal fluffy inside that you can’t find in the stores. Will for sure be coming back!“

“Thank you, Jessie and crew! The bagels and breakfast sandwiches are DELICIOUS! The wraps and sandwiches are too! You’ve kept me well fed for years on my way to work and AT WORK!“

“I don’t have enough good things to say about this business. I called 5 Brothers from Wisconsin (not knowing anything about delis or restaurants in Lincoln Park, New Jersey—just going by google search) to order a couple trays of food for a memorial service in Lincoln Park which I could not attend. I am so happy my Google search led me to such a professional and helpful business. The two brothers I worked with listened to my situation and understood what I was hoping to provide food-wise, and then they suggested a mixed tray of baked goods and desserts that were perfect. They even sent me photos and a video of the finished trays of goodies after they put them together. And then they delivered. Amazing. Top-notch customer service. I highly recommend this company for food delivery and catering. Good, good people.“

“This lil shop has INCREDIBLE bagels. Chewy, fluffy, wonderful flavor. Good service members too. The shop is small; but it is mighty. Truly a gem, and highly recommend. The bagel sandwich was also really good, it wasn’t too heavy, a great ratio of food to bagel combo. I can’t wait to come back and buy like every bagel in the shop.“

“Great customer service, everyone is very friendly!“

“Enjoy food and friendly place“

“Great place for breakfast! Hungry Man sandwich was delicious and fit for someone hungry. Omelette platter is big and tasty. Will come back next time in town!“

“Amazing bagels, breakfast, sandwiches and service! Highly recommended!!!😀“

“My favorite bagel place!!! I've tried others but this is the best. Only suggested improvement is to slice the Taylor ham thinner and add more veggies to the veggie cc but the best bagels.Updated review, September 2023, I have recently went to two different bagel stores in the area and by no way shape or form. Do they compete with this place. One in Kinnelon and one in Butler. Just an update, still by far my favorite.Some staff are friendlier than others, but I've worked in a bagel store and I know how grueling it can be, I never hold it against them because they are always busy and it is a very short interaction.I highly highly recommend this bagel store!“

“Best egg sandwiches around. I just ordered my sandwich this morning again 8/10 and the price went up from 2 weeks ago. Last time i went it was $6.95 which is higher then other places but now too much for me with new price. Charged $8.50. I will not be going anymore but was my favorite“

“This is one of my favorite food places. The bakery goods are fantastic. Bagels are made on premises and if you get lucky, you can get them fresh out of the oven.

Though not high end dining, this restaurant checks the boxes. Food is excellent. Staff is friendly and helpful. It is not fair to rate the atmosphere on the same plane as the other two. It’s not fancy but quite functional. Especially since it’s usually utilized as a take out place. Most of the time, I’m passing through. I phone in my order and pick it up shortly after. BTW, the tuna and chicken salads are to die for. Maybe the best I’ve ever had. The egg salad is no slouch either.“

“They are the best because they’re the only bagel shop that actually LISTENS to your order. Toasted dark bagel? Done. Extra crispy bacon? Done. Add little butter? Done.

Any other place you go to, they would miss one of the above.

And their bagels are delicious. Not too fluffy, not too thick.“

“The food is fresh and plenty of it portions are big just what this town needed you can eat inside or outside and it even as a drive thru window if you choose to eat there ask for Michelle’ye service is excellent and always smiling and helpful very clean place great menu and I’m a foodie!!! Been here over 10 times pops has a lot more than bagels never disappoints I highly recommend this hidden Gem!!!“

“fresh bagels and sandwiches. friendly workers. the best ♥️“

“This place is such a gem! I’m really picky and honestly don’t love many places in the area. They are an old school bakery and everything I’ve had has hit the spot. Bagel sandwiches are good too and so is the coffee! Someone in a recent comment said they have a “new” pastry counter. I’ve been going to place for years and they always had pastries and the quality has remained the same. No affiliation to this place, I’m just passionate about decent food and that’s hard to find when you live in Ringwood.“

“Practicing social distancing and offering car service!! Support responsible local businesses; they need us now more than ever!!“

“I love a good bagel sandwich. A well done Taylor ham and cheese on a toasted everything bagel is my go to. This place makes a great sandwich. I love being able to text my order and get a response when it will be done. I've been ordering from this place for over a year and the food is always ready when they say it will be. In and out in minutes. Great place, nice people, good food.“

“Absolutely delish. The special was priced perfect. Chicken salad on rye toast. Pickles were crisp and perfect. Drink and chips included.“

“Great food and staff. I go there often and I have never gotten anything that wasn't delicious. The bagels are amazing. Unfortunately I am now gluten free but their gluten free bagels are very good. The salads and the fries are really good too. The prices aren't crazy and the portions are decent. The staff is always friendly and willing to accommodate any special requests that I may have. This is definitely my favorite bagel shop.“

“I used to come here all the time in college, circa '98, '99. I haven't been there in quite a few years, but decided to stop with my son the other day. I ordered a Taylor Ham and cheese on a toasted plain bagel and he had a plain bagel with cream cheese. It was the best I've had in years!! Now my son is asking me everyday to take a ride up there. Glad to see the quality remains the same! We'll be back........frequently! The Howard Stern on an Everything Bagel was my go to in college. I'm sure it's still amazing.“

“Great spot for fresh bagels, they have a simple variety and have several cream cheeses, not as many as I'm used to seeing in traditional bagel places. Bakers dozen gives you a free bagel! Staff is friendly and quick with the service. 12 bagels and 1 pound of scallion cream cheese is $27 here for quick reference.“

“Coffee is the best lunch sandwich are delicious servers are great One of my best places to eat“

“I have been going here over 6 years already and everyone is amazing especially my Thomas … always makes my day going in there … i never had any problems there and the food is always fresh … keep up the good work guys !!!“

“Great staff in Allendale. Food was delicious“

“So many choices. It’s a great lil spot for a healthy, drive thru, coffee, smoothies, teas homemade cookies, bagel 🥯“

“Customer service was great and more importantly the bagel was delicious. I’ll soon find out about other stuff from the menu.“

“Everything is so fresh and amazing.“

“EVERYTHING is GREAT!!!!....“

“I start every day off of work at sunrise with a breakfast sandwich and coffee“

“Not sure why there’s so many negative reviews, I always place my orders ahead of time and they’re always ready within 15 minutes. Place is busy and food is good. Only started coming here a few weeks and so far my experience is nothing but great.“

“Delicious, authentic bagels and gourmet sandwiches, including the unique and luscious Big Boy (taylor ham, egg, and cheese with a layer of hash brown on a Kaiser roll), prepared perfectly by the friendly, gracious proprietor. This native north Jerseyan will be back every time I return from out-of-state.“

“The lady behind the counter deserves a raise.She knows her regulars and has their order ready before they even ask.She is training new people and fixing their screwups before the orders get over the counter.She is up at the crack of dawn busting her ass everyday.And they have Great Bagels!“

“My 1st/2nd stop when I'm "back east" / "back home" depending on the time of day. You can't get bagels like this in the deep south, or most anywhere in the US outside the NE. If you haven't had a NY bagel, they're unbelievable. Soft inside with almost chewy outside, absolutely delicious with butter, or as a sandwich. Don't buy too many. The real price of eating old-world bakery fresh breads is: they don't last. They might be somewhat edible the next day, but they're like doughnuts that way: a 1-day life expectancy.“

“We cannot say enough amazing things about the pizza truck we had at our wedding—it was truly one of the highlights of the night! From the moment it arrived, guests were drawn in by the delicious smells and incredible setup. Everyone loved this unique feature, and we got nonstop compliments all night long. The BBQ chicken pizza was an absolute crowd favorite—so flavorful and perfectly cooked. The veggie pies were just as amazing, fresh and full of flavor, and the dessert pies? Out of this world! Every bite was a hit. The team worked quickly and with such great energy, keeping the line moving while making every guest feel taken care of. We especially appreciated the thoughtful touch of take-out boxes—guests loved being able to grab a slice for later (and we did too!). Everything about this experience was seamless, fun, and absolutely delicious. If you’re looking to wow your guests with something unforgettable, this pizza truck is it. Five stars all the way!“

“Absolutely delish. The special was priced perfect. Chicken salad on rye toast. Pickles were crisp and perfect. Drink and chips included.“

“I go every day for breakfast, Maria is fantastic, the guys are great, food is delicious, they know who I am , very respectful and always so nice , great place, whoever helps at counter is always polite but I usually get Maria because I go at 6 am“

“Great bagels with a large selection of cream cheese. Deli sandwiches are huge“

“The Best Bagels Hands DOWN!“

“After I placed my order today, I was trying to speak to the cook about my order (an older Spanish speaking woman didn’t get her name brushed me off and was refusing to understand what I was asking for. Thankfully, Karelis stepped in and handled the situation with patience and great customer service. She listened, understood exactly what I meant, and made sure my order was right. Because of her, I didn’t walk away with a bad experience today — she truly went above and beyond. While I most likely will not come back here. I wanted to honor Karelia great customer service.“

“Great bagels, questionable cleanliness. The food is delicious, but the place really needs a serious cleaning. The floors were extremely dirty, the bathroom faucet is falling apart, and public areas are pretty nasty overall. I can only imagine what the back looks like. The bagels hit the spot, but I left feeling like I needed a shower.“