50 Best Italian Restaurants near Medford Lakes

“Love the cheesesteak!!! Go there everytime we are in town!!“

“Great dinner on 1/24/25. The pork special was outstanding. Excellent salad plated with the pork steak. Perfectly cooked. Moist and tender. Starters of clams casino and calamari also wonderful. Great service.“

“Always a Great meal. We also love our waiter Jaun. We always ask to be seated in his section.“

“I’m a SJ native and have been going to Scotto with my girlfriend for about 5 years. It is hands down the best pizza around. We will drive well out of our way to get it. It’s a travesty that all of these “best pizza” lists don’t choose it as it should be better known. Look at the reviews.

If you want brick oven pizza or a fancy sit down, yes that is not here. But Scotto is the place to get the best pizza.“

“We had a delicious dinner on Mother’s Day. Our server, Melissa, was a delight. We have passed this restaurant many times with the intention of trying it out. So glad we finally did!!“

“The pizza,wings and fries are really good however even though the cheesesteaks have a lot of meat they are on the dry side. The owners are super nice“

“Food was very good. Disappointed in portion size for price $35 dollars for pasta seemed a lot for this amount“

“My favorite place for food, people and atmosphere. Highly recommend. My favorite is chicken capri, finger steaks and awesome salad with cheese“

“Excellent food, excellent service. Our favorite restaurant in Medford. The food is always fresh and delicious.“

“Have had dinner there several times with friends and everyone has always been most complimentary of meals served. I have personally enjoyed the shrimp and scallops as well as stuffed flounder. Also ordered for take out catering trays of chicken and penne vodka for a family event which were wonderful. Great place with a strong menu and terrific meals. Also ordered several catered dinners for my family including chicken Marcella and penne vodka.“

“Chef Kevin is truly a Culinary Genius. All of his dishes are spectacular. The presentation is well done and the portions are just the right size. Pricing is right on point considering todays world. I can't say enough about the delicious desserts. Always a nice selection. Thank you Chef Kevin for bringing a little piece of Italy to Medford.“

“Carollo’s little Italy is awesome everything we have ever gotten there is great. All the chicken, pasta and seafood dishes are great. We Also love the mussels in red sauce and the bruschetta was the best we ever had. The staff is so nice and friendly and do an awesome job.“

“Went last week and had Chrissy as our bartender and she was fantastic! She was patient as we figured out what we wanted, recommended things, and made us feel welcome. I wrote a great review and decided to come back yesterday with parents. I raved about this place and the service. However we had a different bartender and did not have same great experience. Food was still fantastic but the bartender did not meet the same expectations. We felt very rushed throughout the entire time. Couldn’t find her at times with empty drinks. And no personality. I will come back but will be calling to see who’s working to get the best service especially when dropping $$$.“

“Absolutely love love love this restaurant. Every thing was delicious! this place is old school Italian. I had linguine Bolognese and it came out in this huge white bowl. I couldn’t stop eating it. It tastes like the bolognese I had in Rome.The staff are excellent and on top of it. Very friendly. We were very well taken care of. And I absolutely loved the piano player. What a wonderful musician I was floored by his playing. Five stars. will definitely be going back to this gem. Thanks for a wonderful evening!!!“

“Finally got over to try cibo And let me tell you genaro, did not disappoint! Our food not only was fresh and hot, but every dish was 100% perfection. Take some time out of your busy day and head over and check cibo out! you won't be disappointed..“

“Charming authentic Italian place with the best food and service.“

“We just had our 50th Wedding Anniversary Celebration at Marco's. Can't say enough about Lexi, who coordinated our event. She was so attentive to all our needs and made things so easy for us. The food was fantastic and I asked my guests and everyone raved about the food. Joe and his waitstaff were "The Best". Everything went so smoothly. Check them out. You won't be disappointed! Linda B.“

“We had an event at Tullia’s and everything was amazing! From the moment I first called the customer service experience was fantastic! I was able to drop everything off the night before. The Tullia’s staff did an amazing job setting up our event.. Everything I dropped off was set up perfectly ( Beer, Wine, cake, custom menus, party favors , picture boards) and ready when we arrived. The food was fantastic. The service was perfect and you can’t beat BYOB. Big shout out to Enza! They get five stars plus from me ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️“

“The owner is a very nice person. The atmosphere was good and so was the food! I was craving a couple slices all day of pizza and the owner made sure I got my craving satisfied with their honey siracha chicken pizza. Definitely coming back!“

“We stopped in the Glassboro location on 12/27 and were treated really well considering it was very close to their closing time! Maddie, our waitress was terrific, and had some great recommendations for us. She was on top of everything and made sure we had everything we needed. The food & atmosphere were great too.“

“Tuvimos un bonito almuerzo de cumpleaños para mi hija y sus mejores amigas. Ya habíamos asistido a este restaurante antes. Realmente es un lugar acogedor, familiar, la comida estaba deliciosa. El personal que trabaja allí es eficiente y amable.“

“The food at Allora never disappoints but the new location needs to do something about the noise level in the new space. The gnocchi are some of the lightest I've had. I had the Sicilians, quite a bit of heat from the jalapeño, my husband had the Carbonara. Both took some home as the portions are generous.“

“First visit was for a baby shower so we had a set menu. I had a perfectly cooked salmon, and my mom had eggplant parm, which was also excellent. Service was great. But I think my favorite was the tiramisu 😋“

“We decided to try this place for lunch and were absolutely blown away by the food. It was outstanding. Don't miss the Fried Tomatoes with Lobster. It's worth every penny.“

“This place is one of the few survivors in this shopping center. The BEST hole in the wall food! If you come across this review and have never tried it, trust me, it is worth the few dollars to give it a shot.I've eaten here since I was in 6th or 7th grade, about age 12-13. Every Friday night and sometimes Saturday I'd sit on the steps out front and we'd all share food. 15 years later it's still the original crew!!If you are reading this and you have had their delicious food (chicken parm with gooey cheese and crispy chicken and roll, or their SPICY FRIES!!!) Please continue to be a consistent patron. This is one of the few places Marlton cannot afford to lose!Thank you crew & owners of Domenico's, I will see you tomorrow!“

“Stopped on our way home from the Columbus flea market. The outside appearance almost discouraged me from entering. But we're glad we did. The guy who served us (I assume the owner) was very pleasant and the pizza was very good with a good crust! We finished off a large cheese pizza with our grandkids. We'll stop by again!“

“Had dinner this evening with family .We had excellent service by our waitress Nicole . Everyone loved there meals .Nicole was very attentive to our needs and helped us pick a nice wine to go with our meals .When we return we will be asking for Nicole to be our server .“

“We have had the most delicious gourmet pizzas from this place (Buffalo and The Works) Also, their chicken wings with the mild wing sauce is the right amount of tangy and spicy. My husband says, " it's the best wing sauce he's ever had!" Highly recommend!“

“How come there is rarely any plain or pepporoni pizza slices available for pickup? I feel like every time I call, they only have unpopular slices available like vegetable slices and pepper & onion, even on a Friday and Saturday night“

“Great dishes Your son is incretable“

“A cool rustic place, very good and pleasant service, very tasty food.“

“I went to Franco’s the other day and the food was delicious got a pasta dish it was great! I will definitely be back, the serves was also great and very friendly!!! Can’t wait to visit them again and try a new dish they have to offer!“

“Hands down the best pizza in south jersey. And we eat all over. Glad it’s in the next town but we would drive two hours for this pizza. Owners and staff are so friendly and it’s really starting to look nice inside.“

“I ordered a Too Good Too Go surprise bag (my first time) and got way more than I anticipated! Sever different types of slices of pizza and zeppoles. I grabbed tiramisu since it’s my husbands favorite (he said it was the best he had in a long time!) the owner was very nice and gracious!“

“Hidden gem in downtown Medford. You’ll feel like you stepped into Italy when you walk through the gates. Coffee is out of this world!“

“I had ordered cannolis, pizelles, and an Italian cookie tray for a friend's birthday and it was absolutely delicious!! The pricing was great, the ordering and pickup was fast, customer service was wonderful! Definitely recommend this establishment!!!!“

“I was born and raised in South Philly. My wife and I moved to Lumberton in 2002. Not wanting to go back to Philly every time we wanted pizza, we looked out here. Finally, we found Anthony's Coal Fired Pizza. Although not as big as the pizza I'm used to in Philly, it is delicious! Perfectly well done on the bottom and not greasy.

Kid-friendliness: Yes, but please control your kids.

Wheelchair accessibility: They can accommodate you.“

“I'm a pizzaholic, I eat it everyday, I know my pizza...This place has legit NYC style pizza, and it's definitely one of the best around...I go out of my way to eat here...Chicken parm is killer and the fries are definitely the best I've ever had, no joke these fries are worth the trip alone...I think they hand cut them.“

“Love the cheesesteak!!! Go there everytime we are in town!!“

“Best pizza in Tabernacle! White works and all in sausage are my favorite. Friendly people, tastey wings. Great flatbread.“

“The seafood buffet was incredible. The lobster and various crab offering were nicely seasoned along with the shrimp offering. Great lobster Mac and cheese.“

“It really tastes good, and the service attitude is also very good.“

“We come here 2-3 times a week for lunch. Food is always amazing and the service is top notch. Highly recommended!!“

“Delicious!!!! Once again fabulous & by the way yummy appetizers too!!! Love the fried green beans!!!!!“

“Good bartenders cold beer and good food. What more could you want from a local bar.“

“This place is amazing. They have French toast for 6 dollars. Great place for breakfast. Also the have this sausage and peppers sandwich that they add an amazing wine sauce too. I usually get it with mild provolone and long hots and it is delish!! 👌🏼 👍🏻“

“I’ve been going here since the place opened, and it’s easily the best place in Mt. Laurel. The owner, Gus, is a fine gentleman and very personable. Very enjoyable atmosphere, and that’s before you try the food. In the 20 years I’ve been going there, I’ve never had a bad meal! Everything on the menu is great, not good, but great! I HIGHLY recommend these guys!“

“Love it! Especially the toco salad and shrimp parmigiana!“

“This is the best pizza place in South Jersey. 10/10. We have been going here for 23 years. I’m 30 years old and even tho we moved out of Marlton they kindly deliver to Mount Laurel for us. Great people work here. Amazing pizza also AMAZING eggplant parm I think so. Wait, I thought oh yeah I don’t know. I think it tells you in the left-hand corner.. Ask for it on focaccia bread it’s HEAVENLY. Family is Italian. Their pasta is actually also good which is a lot to say for a pizza place! They make homemade gnocchi with pesto sauce and it’s also amazing. Like is always almost out the door for pick up as well. If that doesn’t tell you something idk what does“

“I decided to try the chicken parm sandwich with vodka sauce everyone was talking about but with a twist; I asked for it on garlic bread. it was excellent!!!“