22 Best Steakhouses near Montville

“Forgot how nice of a venue Rails is...it is really beautiful! Came here to celebrate 30+ years married and thoroughly enjoyed ourselves. Had oyster (east and west coast) appetizer and octopus with delicious garbanzo beans in a really tasty sauce!! Then had a NY strip and skirt steak... both cooked perfectly for medium rare. Had a side of creamed spinach which could've been cooked a little more...and very creamy. Next time I think I will get oil and garlic spinach instead..just a preference. Shout out to our waitress, Danielle,...very attentive and gave us a piece of cake on the house to take home and celebrate our anniversary...Also invited us to the speakeasy...but c'mon it's only MONDAY??? Saw.some people enjoying mac and cheese as an appetizer...looked good, but that would have been too much for us!! No starches ordered, but they looked good.“

“I used to like this place a lot. Last time I was there I was treated like a common criminal. The hostess even walked away with my order to make sure I didn't steal it. LoL. Weird, but I'm not going back to that location. After spending so much money there and having so many birthday parties there , to have this happen was eye opening. Zero Stars for service.“

“Crystal was an amazing server. Was efficient and engaging. I enjoy having servers like Crystal because they create a great dinning experience.“

“They have the best social hour!! The food is amazing and the atmosphere is great!!!“

“My husband and I had an amazing dinner at Masseria Italian Steakhouse in Morristown tonight! The cozy, elegant vibe (especially by the fireplace) was perfect after a chilly walk. The food was incredible—delicious bread to start, perfect appetizers (carpaccio and grilled octopus), and standout mains. My husband loved his NY strip steak, and my branzino was so tender and flavorful. The cocktails were on point, too! Shoutout to Mamadou for the great service and to the owner, Joe, for stopping by our table and showing us the wood-fired grill on our way out. Such a nice touch! Everything was top-notch, and we can’t wait to come back with friends. Highly recommend!“

“Ate here for the first time with my sisters, and we had a fantastic experience. Our server, cherrylynn, gave us a run down of the menu and was very attentive. We had the jerked chicken wings and yuca fries and were in love. Would be dining here again“

“Excellent steak at a reasonable price. Good bar for a pre dinner drink. Very good service with a friendly staff. A little loud at times to carry on a conversation but that all lends itself to its lively atmosphere. I’d definitely recommend Arthur’s and will be back.“

“Exceptional Hospitality & Outstanding Dining Black Bull Steakhouse never disappoints! Despite planning to close early for snow, they graciously welcomed us, showcasing their top-notch hospitality. The service was impeccable—attentive, warm, and professional. And the food? Simply outstanding. Every dish, from perfectly cooked steaks to delicious sides, was exceptional. Our waiter Artie was amazing. A huge thank you to the team for going above and beyond, despite wanting to close early because of the snow, they welcomed us graciously and provided amazing service. If you’re looking for a steakhouse that truly values its guests, Black Bull is the place to be!“

“A first class old school American Steakhouse. They dont miss a detail and every cent spent there gets a value return of good feeling, good nutrition and a boost to self esteem. Manage Frankie Gonzalez is a gentleman of the old school. His staff is first class“

“Great service, reasonable pricing and delicious food“

“Haven’t been to Jimston’s steakhouse in quite sometime…. Had to visit Livingston today… stopped into my old stomping grounds for some dinner and it did not disappoint.. great to see Jamie and enjoy som memories. The burger was outstanding!“

“I've been going to LongHorn for years, but this last visit was excellent. Carlos was our waiter, he was professional and attentive. The food was better than usual and my guests were totally happy from the steaks to the lava cake and short cake. The only thing that was negative were the prices. I understand everything has gone up but I can buy a good 3 piece pack of Filet minon at BJ's for $17. My 9oz filet was $35. Our bill for 6 people with tip was close to $300. In any case if you go it will be worth it.“

“Had dinner here around 5 today and had the sweetest server, Deonna! she was super helpful with everything we needed ???“

“Went with family and friends for NYE and everything was on point from start to finish.“

“The only reason this isn't five star is because the seafood tower was incredibly disappointing. It was clearly frozen seafood that had been thawed to serve. All the other food was excellent, wait staff was attentive, drinks strong, overall good experience. Would go back again but would not get seafood there.“

“My visit to Outback on Rt.46 in Parsippany New Jersey was one of the most pleasant experiences of my entire trip. My waiter's name was Lucas. He was friendly, professional, helpful, efficient, polite, patient, mannerable and had great expertise about service and was knowledgeable about great foods listed on the menu.. He treated me with such dignity that I felt special actually I felt regal. He is an asset to Outbank Steakhouse. Thank you Lucas, I will be referring relatives to your restaurant. I had traveled for 7 hours to New Jersey to attend a funeral. This type of service made a sad heart glad It was a healing experience.“

“Grew up going to the Nutley location and now they're in Fairfield. I swear on their Ribs but they have a fantastic beer list with great local options and awesome happy hour specials for drinks and apps ( highly recommend prime rib Sliders). Met family for dinner the other night and got the "Baby Spinach" Salad with steak added and the steak was cooked perfectly and every ingredient was fresh. Huge menu that could accommodate pretty much anyone. Great stop in the area.“

“We recently had our wedding and reception at Segovia and are beyond pleased with the results. The staff accommodated our every need; Angela and Matt, who helped us with the booking and menu, were pleasant and professional always. All of our guests commented on how delicious the food was, and the upstairs private room was perfect for our party of 30 people. Particularly deserving of praise is Steve, who went above and beyond to make sure that we were happy and that our special day went as smoothly as possible.“

“Been going there 40 years.. the place has gone to hell in a hand basket.. the soup bowl is 1/2" deep, $5 for each shrimp (not the old jumbo shrimp- too small for $5 each), no bread, no longer offering lobster, been waiting a hour for entree.“

“I went with my daughter on Sept. 9th to celebrate my birthday and it was an amazing experience. The atmosphere was awesome, the food was great, the staff was friendly and the guests that sat with us were so sweet and friendly. We had lots of laughs during dinner. Thank you again to my princess for making my birthday so special.“

“Had a great time with a great group of people“

“It was an excellent dining experience.“