44 Best Bakeries near New Vernon

“Delicious fresh salads. Can’t wait to try the breakfast menu!“

“great cookie“

“Just had the apple turnover, it was incredible.“

“From the moment we stepped through the doors, Il Capriccio...this Italian gem, swept us into an experience that felt both timeless and transcendent. The ambiance was warm and inviting — dim lighting, elegant décor, and the gentle hum of satisfied diners made it clear this wasn't just dinner, it was an occasion. Every dish was a masterpiece. The flavors were layered, bold yet balanced, with fresh ingredients that tasted like they'd just been picked that morning. The pasta was perfectly al dente, the sauces rich and deeply satisfying, and each bite felt like a celebration of Italy's culinary heritage. The antipasti, main courses, and desserts weren't just delicious — they were memorable. Beyond the extraordinary food, the service was impeccable — attentive without being intrusive, knowledgeable about every wine and every dish, and genuinely passionate about creating the best possible experience for us. What sets Il Capriccio apart isn't just a great meal — it's the emotion behind every element: the care in presentation, the harmony of flavors, and the effortless fusion of tradition and creativity. This is, without question, the best Italian restaurant I have ever eaten at. A visit here isn't just dinner — it's a culinary journey that I'll be talking about for years. Highly, highly recommended!“

“Just started ordering from Anthony & Sons all the way from Northeastern PA and couldn't be happier with the selection and fantastic service. Excited to incorporate their breads and rolls into our menu.“

“THE BEST HANDS DOWN! Wouldn’t be Morristown without!!!“

“Wow, just wow. This was amazing, I mean absolutely AMAZING! I have never had any pastries like these before and they were breathing and beautiful. I got the ganache cream cake slice, amazing, and a chocolate pastry, fabulous. The service and atmosphere were unforgettable. Love it, would recommend“

“Excellent allergy friendly bakery! It is awesome to know that a bakery with such an amazing selection is safe to eat for my kids while everyone else is enjoying the same desserts. Their breads are amazing by the way!! Great job two fields!!“

“An issue occurred with my delivery order and my order ended up never being delivered, outside of the control of the bakery. I reached out to the bakery via email and they called me promptly the next morning. They rectified the situation and refunded my order. Their cakes are so good and addicting that despite the original order never arriving, I ended up ordering a pickup order shortly thereafter.“

“This cafe is a hidden gem and a must-try! You can tell how much care goes into every item. The lemon strawberry cake is phenomenal, the donut is the best I've ever had, and the turkey cheddar croissant is to die for! I'm shocked every time I bite into something- because, how can it all be SO good? They also are one of the few cafes that will actually give you a LARGE coffee! This place outshines the (many) other coffee shop/bakeries in town and is worth the trip every time.“

“⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ I recently ordered a special-request birthday cake from Akanksha at Cakeoholic, and it was absolutely exceptional! The cake was not only incredibly delicious but also beyond beautiful — truly a work of art. Akanksha’s responsiveness, professionalism, and talent made the entire process seamless and enjoyable. She was such a pleasure to work with, and her attention to detail shines through in every aspect of her creations. I would highly recommend Cakeoholic to anyone looking for a stunning and delicious cake made with care and creativity!“

“We cannot recommend Fleur de Sel enough! A big ‘thank you’ for catering my daughter’s bridal shower this past weekend. The food and presentation were outstanding. Patricia and her staff were extremely kind and accommodating when we needed to postpone this event at the last minute in July. We are so grateful to have this wonderful bakery in Chatham!“

“Best connoli cake! The staff are great“

“This is my third cake order from Suzi and let me say the cakes get even better each time. In my almost thirty years on this earth, suzi cakes are by far the most amazing cakes I’ve ever had. Not only is the cake so flavorful and moist, the detail in the design is so perfect and carefully crafted. Worth every penny. She’s my go to girl for any custom cake orders. I’ll never go to anyone else and always recommend her to all my family and friends.

My cake was white cake with Oreo mousse filling and it was DELICIOUS. Need to hide the leftovers from my husband so I can enjoy it all by myself lol

Side note, saw a negative review about someone complaining about the taste of their cake. Sounds like a them problem. That person must be out of their skull because I’m incredibly picky and particular about my sweets and have nothing but wonderful things to say about Suzi, so don’t believe the nonsense. Five stars all around for Suzi.

I can’t wait for Suzi to make my daughter’s birthday cake!“

“Muy buena atención y rica comida“

“It’s a gem. Go there and you’ll see.“

“Bakery is my long time favorite for years no matter where I move I will always come back for my cookies and our Birthday cakes Blessings to the owner“

“Loved all his desserts and bread.“

“Many Colombian eateries in the area, and an equally diverse mix of bakeries. However this is the one I visit the most because it's delicious, consistent (!), inexpensive, and clean. Don't be put off by any lines inside, they move quickly. A+ all around!“

“Original italian bakery with sweets, pastry, breads, savory items and panini.
The Arancine (rice balls) are excellent. Good quiche and great pastries. The owner is very nice and lived in Sicily.
I bought some bread, that I found to be excellent.
Street parking, about 6 tables for 2 and good service.“

“Having a passion for bakeries, this one takes the cake! Every item is delicious and made with care! The creative and whimsical decorations are nostalgic and seasonal. The chocolate mousse is creamy and crunchy - really good! Highly recommend!“

“todo muy bueno 100% recomiendo“

“The best Rico Pan Bakery in New Jersey“

“We contacted Kaela to create a tornado birthday cake for our son’s 6th birthday. She made the process seamless and enjoyable. She was transparent and so easy to communicate with. The final product was amazing and our son loved it. The golden Oreo icing is so different from other flavors we have tasted and delicious!! We recommend Kaela for your next cake/event, you will be very happy with your choice. My son said the cake was impressive.“

“Just started ordering from Anthony & Sons all the way from Northeastern PA and couldn't be happier with the selection and fantastic service. Excited to incorporate their breads and rolls into our menu.“

“Just recently raised my review from 3 to 4 stars. The cookies and mini pastries are spectacular. Will have to work my way through the cakes next. Might up it to five stars. The macarons were a bit less crisp than my wife would have liked, but I blame that on the humidity and transport (I took too long enjoying the sunshine, nothing against the bakery), otherwise they were wonderful.“

“This small Mexican bakery tucked on a side street near the train station, has a nice selection of sweet delicious treats as well as Mexican street foods (nachos, sandwiches, tacos, etc) at an affordable price. Staff is friendly and helpful. Entrance is handicap accessible and there is metered street parking.“

“buena atencion ,ademas quedo muy lindo el remosado . Felicitaciones.“

“This place is so good. All their baked goods taste so Devine, and the way the workers talk to you as if you're family makes the atmosphere wonderful. Great Colombian music and a fine treat of Colombian goods both sweet and savoury. 10/10 would come here again and again and again!“

“Deliciosa comida y el personal muy amable,recomendable al 💯“

“Little Colombian bakery, with a small seating area, that specializes in freshly baked bread and pastries. Delicious and very affordable. You can find empanadas, chicharrón (pork), almojabanas, etc. A place to get casual delicious typical bakery food. The personnel is kind.“

“Muy buenos pasteles yo solo ayi compro para las fiestas de mis hijas“

“buena atención bueno no de todo el personal pero si tiene una puntuación el negocio del 1 al 10 de mi parte un 8 👍“

“The quality of the goods is second to none. We catered our entire Thanksgiving dinner from the Shrewsbury location and it was top tier in all respects. It’s not just the Italian specialty items that are excellent, it’s the whole range of prepared foods. The meat and fish departments are like the neighborhood markets of my youth. The employees are courteous and available and knowledgeable. The people who work there care about the customers and seem to like their jobs. If you’re a food person (whether you like to cook or just eat - for me it’s both) don’t miss this place. I love it even for regular grocery shopping. One note: you get what you pay for and here you get a lot so expect higher (but not insanely so) prices. It is well worth it.“

“amazing strawberry banana tres leche cake!!!!“

“Last week I bought some oatmeal and it was vinegar and it was not the first time that it happened to me and the service is very regular, there are two or three very attentive girls, which is why they will not stop going, they are the best Colombian bakeries“

“Amazing cakes, both taste and presentation. Always moist and never too sweet!“

“Delicious treats and amazing service. Five stars for Dessert Ladies!“

“Great employees always friendly. Delicious Bagels and omelets just to name a few.“

“Wonderful place to meet, enjoy a healthy meal and a good conversation. Owner is a great restaurateur, and staff is friendly and helpful.“