50 Best Caterers near Nutley

“Great place if you want to have a successful event or a wedding reception. I had my wedding at Mamma Vittoria Catering back in October 2019, and went to some other events organized at this catering hall. Food was fresh and very tasty, and the staff is always friendly and professional. I have had nothing but great experiences with Mamma Vittoria and everyone working there.“

“Best food for the best prices and accommodating service!!! Simply the best. Thank you!“

“We absolutely love the Kurly Kurdish shop. I had a Kurly kone with cherry vanilla ice cream. This is the best sweet treat. I recommend everyone stop in and try one!“

“Good food“

“I would bring a bus group from the Detroit area every year before the pandemic for tours in the New York area.
I would have to order 56 sandwiches with 3 to 4 different choices.
Our bus wouldn't arrive to our hotel until after 8:00 pm
(after your normal business hours)
Upon our arrival, someone would deliver our lunches that evening for the next day.
I have always appreciated the extra mile that they went for our bus group.
The sandwiches were always delicious.
I look forward to doing business with you in the near future“

“We had my daughter’s wedding at Venetian and we couldn’t be happier!! The food was amazing and the service was the best I have ever had any where!!“

“MAHFY was fantastic for our ~100 person wedding, we had a cocktail hour style reception which provided an array of heavy hors d'oeuvres, along with a grazing station and fruits! The team was very professional and ensured that every guest was fed including my husband and I. I would definitely recommend them to anyone looking for catering services within the Tri-state area!“

“From the moment of pulling up to the venue i knew the experience awaiting inside was going to be special. The ambiance, the level of service, professionalism and attention to details were all in order. Lavish grounds wrap around the outside with mini gardens embedded. The inside is tasty decorated with just enough without being too much. The food offered during cocktail hr. was steady with each new bite teasing the palate in a very good way. The servers were highly skilled and trained. I was very very impressed. The reception room changed 3 times from cocktail hr to buffet to deserts and cordials each transformed quickly and elegantly again with attention to details. The entire staff and MGMT from valet to chefs and servers deserve a 5 star standing ovation for a perfect performance.“

“Seafood pimps was the best decision I could had made to celebrate my 56th birthday. I decided to purchase the Nexf ix & Chill. First the presentation was SUPERB. The crabs, mussels and shrimp were FRESH and DELECTABLE. The vegetables were seasoned to perfection. least of them all the amount that you receive is enough to feed a full size family, and we only ordered for two. I will definitely be back. I recommend Seafood Pimps to anyone that enjoy fresh mouth watering seafood.“

“This one the BEST rice ball I have ever had!!“

“In the past year I used Custodi to cater two parties, a Hawaiian Luau and Texas BBQ. Both times the food was delicious! Chris is so easy to work with and very accommodating with what your needs are. His staff took care of everything the day of, very professional. Our parties were a huge success and everyone raved about the food! Thanks so much Chris!“

“Omg amazing breakfast! Aileen the best Waitress ever since I been coming. Thank you 🙏“

“My husband and I had our 40th birthday here this past weekend. We worked with Te'Niijah and she was great! At this venue, you must expect that you have to bring almost everything yourself except tables and chairs (and the provide black linen if that's the color you're going for which worked out for us). They also have 4 small black couches and 2 coffee tables you can use. They also provide a small stand alone bar. We added 3 regular tables around it to make a larger bar since we had 100 people. You should plan how much time you will need to set up vs clean up when figuring out your party time slots. We did a cocktail hour turned nightclub, hired bartenders and waitstaff (from John Claude Catering - who I would highly recommend!) and had no issues with set up time or clean up. JC staff took care of most of the clean up. I just had to get everything out by the time I promised I would be out by, which wasn't an issue. The space was exactly what we were looking for, exposed brick with that lounge vibe. We loved the long hallway before you entered - there is so much you can do with the space. The staff set up 2 tables in the hallway around 10pm (our party was over at midnight). One table was for cigars and the other was for McDonalds. It was a nice surprise that no one can see until they left the main party room. I tagged The Loft on IG so you should be able to see the rest of the set up from there. I would highly recommend having a party here! We loved it!“

“We ordered the general tso’s pizza yesterday for dinner and my family loved it. My son ate the last 2 slices for breakfast this morning. The guy who took my order over the phone was very patient and nice. I personally love their food as I’ve ordered many times from them when I was working in Wayne. We will definitely be ordering from now on because my family loved it. I can’t wait to try the Thai chili pizza with fried calamari. Great job Pizza One !!!!“

“Food was good, music was great. Staff very attentive.“

“We ordered the everyday Wednesday special on Friday. It was fantastic!! Thank you!!“

“Quinoa Salad with chicken so good. The place is clean, the service is friendly. I will be back to try more items off the menu“

“As the owner of Arlene Brief Entertainment, I have worked with many caterers, as you can well imagine...but I have never been so impressed as I was tonight working with Chef Kenny Collins and his staff. It was the best & most enjoyable meal I've ever had...Five Stars just isn't enough and I can't wait to work with them again! Bravo, Kenny....not only was the entire meal delicious...you make it into an art form! Jason Craig, my fabulous entertainer, who usually never eats while he's working, couldn't resist tonight..........and that's saying something!“

“UPDATE ! Patrick Lopez and the Wilshire are all in on dedication and professionalism to providing a couples wedding dreams come true. They not only rescued an art factory couple but literally 2 days before their events, thier caterer went mia too ! Patrick and the Wilshire were able to provide delicious foods, variety, flavor, beautifully plated, or buffet, all of it from rehearsal dinner to dessert. THANK YOU THANK YOU THANK YOU. We are blessed. All and everything ! The diverse and many large or comfortable size spaces can accommodate anyone . Pristine ! Patrick Lopez is the most genuine professional to work with.“

“We had the pleasure of working with Gabriel and his amazing team, and we couldn’t be more impressed. The food was absolutely delicious, every dish was flavorful, beautifully presented, and made with clear attention to quality and freshness.

What truly stood out was the attention to detail, from the elegant decorations to the seamless setup. Gabriel and his entire staff were professional, courteous, and went above and beyond to ensure everything was perfect. Their dedication and genuine care made our event unforgettable.

Highly recommend this catering service for anyone looking for top-tier food and outstanding customer service. ¡Gracias, Gabriel y equipo!“

“Highly recommend this place for so many reasons. The owner is an awesome guy, showed great hospitality, he was very on point, you can tell he takes pride in what he does and it shows. The room is nice, very DJ friendly too! And not to mention the food was great. If you’re looking for a venue to host your event, I highly suggest checking out Bella Casa!“

“I use San Carlo for our company holiday party for the past 6 years. We keep coming back because the service is that good. Food , venue, parking, and especially the friendly and attentive staff. I get so many great reviews on the food from my employees. Why would I go any where else. The staff change in the past few years but service is still great. I refer alot of my family and friends to this gem.“

“In short, there is no better than Royalty Catering Crew. The displays, the service, the incredible dedication by each member of the team…and OF COURSE, the taste and array of food that is prepared for set every day is UNMATCHED by anyone in the business. Every day, their game was upped and kept delivering at the highest level. I would only ever use this team for any film I produce. Look no further.“

“I've known Dino and his lovely wife Helen for more than 30+ years in the food industry. Excellence in every aspect of the restaurant business is par excellence and superb. Food is always top notch and employees are very friendly. This is the place. Thank you Dino and Helen for 30+ years of greatness.“

“Going to the Hot Tuna concert last night at the Wellmont with my son and stopped in for pizza before the show. The pizza was out of this world! Great crust, toppings were all quality and the staff was great. The owner Joe was friendly and place was going.“

“Love love love the food Luney makes! My kids love to eat her food a lot. It smells so good that sometimes I will try it too. Workdays become more manageable that I know whenever my kids want to eat, I have something delicious for them with just 30 seconds of microwave.“

“Gary and his team were wonderful, he catered our event for 400 lunches! They made it so easy for us! The lunches were fantastic, we heard nothing but praise, we would highly recommend!!!!“

“Thank you Stewart’s. Last minute saved my Super Bowl party. Called Saturday had it ready Sunday. Was delicious and a big hit Any occasion they’ll definitely take care of you Thanks again 5 stars“

“first time here very impressed the food was too perfection will be back with more people“

“The New England Clam Chowder with crab added to it was TO DIE FOR….. Got a container at The Herald Square Market to eat when i got home and I was in Heaven with every bite! Fresh and creamy, awesome taste and the crab meat added just intensified the experience! I’m visiting New York from TN and it was one of my best meals so far! HIGHLY RECOMMEND!“

“Ordered for Passover.. couldn't be happier... everything was delicious- a huge time saver- and the order was delivered to my home. I don't know why everyone doesn't do this.. when you add the cost of uncooked items.. your time and energy.. i think this works out to cost you less.. and the time you enjoy with your family.. is priceless!!! Definitely consider trying this for your next holiday or Shabbat meal!!! 5 Stars from me.“

“Hot Pot Caribbean restaurant is the place to go when your taste buds are calling for a good Jamaican dish. Highly recommend!“

“Hosted my best friends baby shower for her grand baby , and everything was absolutely perfect ! The food was AMAZING-the service was top notch ! It could not have gone better ! I highly recommend all to try truffles out for your next event !“

“Amazing amazing amazing the food was delicious the service was great and the Kremas reminded me of my family’s recipe! Definitely recommend them for the food is very traditional and you will love it!“

“Best restaurant. Staff is great, food is great and prices are good. I'm from Montreal, Canada and everytime I go to New Jersey its a must that I eat at Top Knotch restaurant.“

“Lisa in Catering is amazing! She truly makes sure all your needs are met and thinks of everything. We used them for my son’s birthday party and everyone raved about the taste, quality and presentation. Lisa is now helping me with my youngest son’s birthday! If you are looking for great food and customer service this is your place!“

“I will never use another caterer!! Thank you for making Andrew's graduation party a wonderful event and making it so enjoyable for everyone!! You absolutely gave us the "Personal Touch". Everyone raved about our Southern theme with the pulled pork as the favorite!! The delivery, setup, presentation and quality of food and service was superior! Thank you Lisa and John!“

“My girlfriends and I were there a few weeks ago for Sunday brunch. We were totally pleased with the service, the food, and the atmosphere. I'm big on customer service, and I must say that they far exceeded my expectations. The key lime pie was par excellent. Can't wait to go back again!“

“We hired Casa Cubana to cater my Goddaughters Sweet 16th last month. No hassle putting together a great menu for a very large family / friends' event. With constant changes on my end, the staff was always a phone call away, very courteous offering excellent advice to ensure the perfect feast. Oh and the food was amazing.“

“Indulge Eats is a delicious eatery. You will not be disappointed with their selection of salads. All the fruits and vegetables are of the highest quality.“

“We feel so lucky that we found Tere and Jam Cakery. It took us many tries to find a NY bakery that (1) could make a vegan wedding cake (2) wasn’t way too sickly sweet and (3) was within our budget. I’m an amateur vegan baker, so after 2 no-go cake tastings, I was prepared to give up and make our wedding cake myself – thankfully we found Jam Cakery shortly after and I’m so relieved we did.

Not only is Tere very kind and warm, but she makes really, really good cake. We loved meeting her for our cake tasting, she was so flexible working with us to get the flavors we wanted (we landed on lemon basil cake with fresh strawberries and cream cheese buttercream), and understood our desire to not have the cake be overly sweet. She didn’t balk when we asked for 4 tiers (some bakers we talked to said vegan cake wasn’t structurally sound for that), and she hand delivered our cake on the big day.

Our guests loved our cake, and many of them were shocked that it was vegan.

Unlike so many wedding vendors out there, Jam Cakery doesn’t upcharge for weddings. I look forward to getting future celebration cakes from Tere.

Photos courtesy of Heather Pauline.“

“There is a reason Chef Mark and Remarkable Cuisine are the only people I will work with when hosting an event and I CANNOT say enough good things about the entire team, notably Tara who allows you to be the crazy host and is patient and kind and ultimately just wants to make sure you get what you want and are happy with the result. First and foremost, the food is delicious. Second, Tara and Mark really make planning an event a fun and stress free experience. They listen to your vision and come back with menus and presentation suggestions that are perfect. I’ve done everything from big parties to intimate dinners with them and each time has been a delicious culinary experience that my guests rave about. And they are extremely accommodating! Most recent event I wanted a menu that worked for adults and kids - playful but still adult appropriate. They nailed it. We had a perfectly curated menu that everyone loved and the details were impeccable. For our burger bar for example, I asked if we could add some fun toppings to the mix. Chef Mark and Tara came back with a multitude of items for the display and they were a HIT with the guests. Execution was perfect, food was fired throughout the night so nothing felt old or like it had been sitting out all day. The servers were extremely kind and helpful - made you feel welcomed and at home and that is really important to me when hosting in my home. Remarkable is high end, professional, delicious - not your cookie cutter catering. Further, the experience is consistent EVERY TIME (I’ve done multiple events now so I can say this) and really only has gotten better. I like to host and the one thing you just can’t screw up is the food and the service. It’ll ruin a party. So if you want to guarantee that your guests will be talking about the food the next day, and commenting on how extraordinary the service is, call Remarkable asap.“

“Amazing food, an enthusiastic and gracious host. Great live music greets you at the door. Wonderful experience!“

“Quality is better then food sold at most restaurants“

“Best godfather sandwich EVER!!! My Friday treat after a long work week!!! Alex, please get another one ready this Friday (5/22) Ken’s picking it up. You make them THE BEST!!! Thank you!!!“

“It was a pleasure providing the DJ Entertainment and working with Ira of Foremost Caterers at Wave Hill in Riverdale. Every detail was taken care with the utmost professionalism and white glove care. Plus, the food was absolutely stunning to both the eyes & taste buds!“

“I had dinner here and it's the best ITALIAN FOOD I've had in a long time,SERVICE was great as well.“

“The Best 🌟🌟🌟🌟 reminds me of my Nona and PopPop’s house every Sunday.“

“Chicken was delicious and facility clean“

“I had to order last minute for my daughter's St. Marys high school teachers appreciation week. The owner was amazing. Not only did he take my huge order last minute...he delivered it in time for lunch for the teachers and staff!!! They loved it. Fresh and delicious....the turkey and provolone ...and Spicy Italian were a crowd pleaser!!! Will definitely order again...and highly recommend ? ? ?“