21 Best Pizza Restaurants in Paterson

“Greatest Pizza on Earth!!“

“la recomiendo 100% es un ambiente muy entrenado.“

“I've been eating their pizza for over 20 years and in my opinion it's the best I've ever had. Their antipasto salad is delicious and always fresh and their spaghetti with meatballs is delicious. The owners "Vito and Mario" are always courteous and kind and so are the employees. Best pizza in town!!!

Kid-friendliness: The owners and employees are always courteous and kind.

Wheelchair accessibility: There are no stairs so the place is wheelchair accessible. You can just go in.“

“Best food hands on, the staff is friendly, the restaurant is very clean“

“Stopped by quick, finished work was hungry. Not from Paterson but gotta say food was GOOD!, Cheesesteak wrap and plain pie perfect crust just would order slightly more well done, girl forgot to put the pizza order in to go, no worries she was cute, they was busy. Prices very reasonable and place Is clean and will definitely go back when I'm in area after work.“

“I'm still reeling from the incredible experience at Jersey Sub and Pizza Co! This hidden gem serves some of the best pizza and sandwiches I've ever had.
The pizza crust was perfectly cooked, with a delightful crunch and chewiness. The sauce was rich and tangy, made with high-quality tomatoes. The toppings were fresh and premium, elevating each bite to new heights.
But the real star was the Italian sub sandwich. The premium double-seeded semolina bread was crispy, with a subtle nutty flavor. The salami, ham, capicola and provolone were expertly sliced and piled high, each bite a perfect balance of flavors and textures.
The quality of ingredients shines through in every bite. The staff is friendly, attentive, and knowledgeable, passionate about their food. Jersey Sub and Pizza Co is a must-visit for great food, whether you're in the mood for pizza or a premium sandwich. Don't miss out!"“

“This was my home town Pizza place since I was very young, and as I worked for so many years in Downtown Paterson, from coffee, to Pizza, they are the best. Most humble Family Business I know. Elio and family, God bless you guys. Sending Love from Florida. Will visit every time I go to Jersey.“

“I've been eating Giovanny's pizza since I was -1 years old (my mom & gma are regulars) and their pizza is to live for!! There really isnt parking so this is the type of joint you run in, eat real quick - 15/20 - mins and bounce ASAP . The best pizza ever. Ever. Ever.“

“We would to tell all our Family and friends about Sam's Pizza in Paterson NJ it's is so Amazing Yummy ?? and the prices is very good we recommend any one who wants to order some amazing yummy ?? food this is the best place to order and very nice worker and fast delivery and nice and fresh and hot ready to enjoy some amazing yummy food ??♥️♥️♥️♥️From Tito and Day ♥️♥️♥️“

“I will vouch for the pizza and zeppoles. One of the best I have had. Their sauce has a lot of flavor and the cheese has a great hold and pull. Better than the “best” pizza in town according to the others. Everyone here has always been friendly to me. I think if you treat them with respect that is what you will get back.“

“Ate here today with two other friends. Food was great, very tasty, and the price we paid was surprisingly not expensive. I got the pork chops with rice and beans, another friend got two slides of pizza which she loved, and the other one got chicken w rice and beans and maduros. Will definitely return if I’m in the area again“

“The people there are nice and friendly. Food could be better but honestly nothing to complain about since it’s all made fresh there. Interior could be better but overall a quaint place to have a quick meal.

Parking: There are about 3 or4 spots available if you’re lucky to get close parking, other than that a bit tight since it’s next to a used car dealer/mechanic/car wash places nearby in the same block“

“Great taste, crispy and seasoned to perfection!“

“Best pizza in NJ period! If you find another pizza spot better than this one please let me because I've tried so many places but nothing compares to this pizza . Get xlarge pizza with extra cheese and thank me later. Side note eat there or in your car because it's a solid 10 fresh out the oven and a 8.5 if you wait more than 30 mins“

“One of the best pizza stores in Paterson, not only do they have great pizza but there subs are amazing as well! Everything is great here. Real Homemade Italian Food. 👨🏼‍🍳❤️“

“Fabulicious“

“Today I had a horrible customer experience with Subahan I understand he is young but a piece of advice no matter the personal situation you must always have respect for the customer, out of respect I will not speak on the experience in detail. But instead I will choose to highlight the positive way the experience ended.

The manager Ali was indeed very professional, assertive and swift at defusing the situation before it could escalate not only did he diffuse the matter he was even polite when I came back. (Sorry I will not share details as to why I came back that matter is professionally private out of respect for the staff and team that work here)

Thank you Ali for your Swift and assertive professionalism“

“Their pizza is to die for ! The owner is so kind, environment is clean, and they offer a variety of options. Definitely Will be a go to spot for me. 5 �’s“

“My experience at Joes Pizzaeria was pretty good. The owner was super friendly and since it was my first time coming in he was very accommodating. I wondered a Stromboli with pepperoni and all the prices here are very reasonable. The food is good my only complaint is the ambiance is not great.“

“Gorgeous restaurant. Always very busy so best to book... unlike us! But we got seated almost immediately. Indoor and outdoor seating available. Very friendly staff and lovely open viewing kitchens. Superb value for money. Right next to railway station and attached to two other restaurants that are also great.“