Custom Cakes near Rutherford, NJ

“Anyone going to any dairy Queen should try a Mr Misty. Once you try a Mr Misty you will never drink another slurpee or slushee again!!! The Mr Misty far exceeds all the other frozen drinks. It's not filled with air it's just pure delicious!!!“

“Placing a cake order with The Modern Cakery was the best decision I could have made. They listened to what I was looking for and not only offered wonderful ideas, they executed these flawlessly. The cake was not only beautiful, it was delicious!!! The birthday girl and guests were still talking about it days later! Thank you to The Modern Cakery! This customer will be a repeat one for sure!!“

“My partner wanted one gift for his birthday - Dominican Cake with Pineapple Jam...to say the cake was exceptional, is an understatement. DELICIOSO y RIQUÍSIMO! It tasted even better a second time when. We are excited to head back to the bakery for a treat and for the next celebration we have as a family. Thank you Karla and team for responding so quickly and making his birthday wish come true! -V&W“

“OMG! I am not exaggerating when I say the cake I received was not short of amazing. Chocolate Devil's Food with Raspberry buttercream. Tangy Raspberry preserves made from scratch by Jaclyn as well between the layers. Everyone who ate a piece of my birthday cake could not be more satisfied with the level of artistry in the decoration as well as the execution of the taste of the cake itself. I don't think I can go back to buying store bought cakes. They would just fail in comparison!“

“Amazing customer service, amazing cakes..so happy that we found you.“

“Esteban is THE BEST. The arepas are great, sure. But come and sit down and chat with the owner who will take the best care of you, make you feel like family, and make you laugh a little too. Great little spot in the LES for a late night bite. Don’t sleep on this place!

Vegetarian options: Vegana, Gato, Quiches, Turnovers“

“I ordered a birthday cake for my daughter's 3rd birthday party and the communication/final delivery of the cake was perfect! Not only was the cake adorable, it tasted delicious. I always appreciate when business's uses basic, clean (real food) ingredients. If you have an idea for a unique cake and want to support small business, I would highly recommend!“

“A great ice cream shop open late to satisfy your munchies and late night sweet tooth cravings. I could not be happier with what i got, i think it was the strawberry cheesecake of some sort. It was really nice though, and they definitely do not skimp on the toppings!!“

“A bakery that truly understands perfection! I cannot stop raving about the pastries and cakes from this place. The flavors are so rich and the textures so perfectly delectable. What sets this bakery apart is the evident love and passion that goes into every single creation. And when you enter, the aroma in the store is simply intoxicating. The staff is always welcoming and offers exceptional customer service. You can count on finding fresh and delightful treats every single time. Do yourself a favor and indulge in their amazing selection of pastries!“

“Rispoli Bakery is my absolute go-to for ALL occasions! Their desserts and pastries are always top-notch—beautifully crafted, incredibly delicious, and made with such artistry and care. The entire team is so professional, friendly, and an absolute pleasure to work with. When it came to catering my husband’s 40th birthday, there was no question—I knew Rispoli Bakery was the only choice! I was overwhelmed with so many event details and had no idea what kind of cake or dessert selection I wanted. Enter Rose—an absolute lifesaver! She guided me through the entire selection process, offering expert recommendations on flavors, quality, and variety. I sent over an inspiration photo for the cake, and when I saw the final result, I was speechless. Rispoli didn’t just match the photo—they far exceeded it! It was a true masterpiece, and I was so moved that I actually cried when I saw it (lol). The dessert spread was so impressive. Every single guest raved about how incredible everything tasted, constantly asking, “Where are these amazing desserts from?!” Thanks to Rose and the team’s thoughtful recommendations, every choice was a home run. I cannot say enough good things about Rose and the entire Rispoli Bakery family. Their talent, professionalism, and warm, welcoming nature make them a joy to work with. Thank you for making my husband’s birthday so special—you’ve gained a lifelong customer! ♡“

“Made the mistake of taking these in a take away box. They should really be eaten on the spot or after sitting in the fridge a bit to allow the cream to set otherwise it will come apart after cutting a few bites.

Had the Tiramisu and the signature cake and the are very luxurious. Dont know what else to say other than it is airy and you can feel each layer as you bite down on it.“

“We selected The Hudson Cakery Cakery for our wedding and were thrilled with the taste, service, and gorgeous, classic look of our 3-tiered cake. They were friendly pros with a simple process to obtain samples. We highly recommend them for your wedding or event!“

“Had the rope vieja and maduros empanadas and they were excellent! Savory, sweet, salty delights. Can't wait to try the various appealing dinners and desserts.“

“Pyszne zdrowe deserki na każdą okazję 🌹🌹“

“Excellent place!!! Everything is top- notch!!! Highly recommended!“

“Absolutely amazing. Menu changes daily so you're never bored with their options. They have great desserts and their savory pastries are to die for.“

“Everything was absolutely perfect, from the service to the deliciousness of the food (Chilean sea bass was outstanding, the lamb chops special was superb and the grilled octupus was perfectly tender). The only mention I have and it's seriously not a big deal was the dining room that we were seated in was a bit too dark I actually had to turn my flashlight on my phone to see. On a scale of 1-10 I give it an 11 !!“

“I love By the Way Bakery since I discovered it couple of years ago. Friendly staff, many choices and the guarantee that I will not get sick when I buy anything from here. I am obsessed with the coconut cake and the carrot cake.

Dietary restrictions: All gluten free, dairy free and vegan.“

“My sister was having a beach chic baby shower because her and her husband do not want to know the gender. She wanted cupcakes that looked like succulents that also taste delicious. I immediately thought of Huascar and asked if he could do it. I traveled to Florida with them and they were a hit. I can’t describe how beautiful they look and I can tell you the taste of theses cupcakes were out of this world. Everyone was contacting my sister afterwards to see where she’d got them. 😋😋😋“

“Smokey Fitzgerald loves the treats. ��Smokey Approves!!“

“As charming as the bakery is, it pales in comparison to Miss Eleanor, the owner. Over the past several years I developed a sensitivity to wheat, so I wanted a gluten-free snack. She had a wide selection of sweets (cupcakes, cookies, brownies) but I saw the picture of biscuits and quickly decided to enjoy them with my coffee.

I took Ms Eleanor up on her offer to warm them up and chatted while waiting for my order to be complete. We had a lovely conversation about so many things - food, travel, career changes.

The biscuits were delicious and very reasonably priced so I’ll have to make my way back soon.

Dietary restrictions: gluten-free. dairy-free. egg-free. keto/sugar-free.“

“I had went to three different bakery trying to get a specific design a cake and was turned away . Finally I was recommended by a friend to to see Emily at Bella Vida pastry . Im glad I did ,I have to say my goddaughter sweet 16 turned out so beautiful it was more then we expected we sent her a picture and she matched it to the tee, and it tasted amazing. And let me not forget to mention their very reasonable in their prices They will definitely get my business again.“

“As a fat man and a traveler, I've had pastries from all over the world. And these are as good as Ive had anywhere. And the eggs were cooked perfectly on my sandwich. And no one ever cooks eggs perfectly. 5 Stars!“

“Petal Dust Cakery is first rate from making my vision come to life through cake design to the easy ordering process and friendly assistance. Look at all these cakes below!! Each one was SPECTACULAR! All within the past month too. Amazing work and sooo delicious💖💖💖“

“I purchased 3 dozen each of the Nutella stuffed and the brown sugar chocolate chip cookies for a bridal shower and they were GONE in no time at all. Everyone LOVED them. They were individually wrapped and people were taking several “to go” as they couldn’t get enough. The ordering process was extremely easy, Jay was super responsive, and pickup was seamless! I will definitely be coming back here for ANY bakery items I need in the future - you just got to try it for yourself!!!“

“Wow this lady can bake! I have know her for a few years now but didn't really know about her baking till recently. I thought I would be nice and supportive and buy a cake. BAM! Best cake I ever eat! Now I am trying to think up excuses to buy another.“

“Makes such amazing cakes! So happy with her creation for my daughter’s baby shower.“

“My sister and I got 2 bingsoos (black sesame and rice cake), a sweet potato latte, and a pistachio dacquoise. They were all very delicious and unique.
The sweet potato latte has a strong sweet potato taste, which satisfies the soul and the dacquoise was very soft and chewy. The bingsoos was also very unique. It kind of had a dry(?) flake to it, but I liked the texture of it. I do wish there was more red bean in it, but it still hit the spot.
Would love to come back and try more of their pastries.“

“I need to say that Renee and Carrie are amazing! Very amazing service, being able to be answered in French at the boutique was amazing! I drove twice in 2 days to grab cupcakes and cookies… I cannot say what’s my favourite out of the cupcake, the brownies, the cookies etc because everything was decadent and not too sweet. You taste the quality of the ingredients and the love they put while cooking them. The fact that Carrie was answering me while the business is close is a sign that she’s passionate and that she care about her client. They’re on the expensive side compared to other bakery, but once you compare you understand why… You taste the butter in everything! If you like some fluffy, moist, creamy cupcake this is your place… While planning my wedding, I’ve compared a few bakery and non are as good as this one… Thank you for the amazing experience and taste!“

“I had an amazing experience this past weekend. I went to a cake baking class with a few women in my ministry. Ashley, the owner, was professional, patient and very knowledgeable. I would most certainly recommend her business to everyone!“

“Randy did an amazing job with our son's custom camper-themed cake. Our kid was beyond thrilled. Thank you for being so accommodating and wonderful! You really made his birthday special.“

“She made my dream wedding cake! I was adamant about finding a bakery/baker that’s able to create a heart-shaped cake for my small wedding celebration. Before I speak with Cristal, I had reached out to other well known bakeries in the area, all of which said that they won’t be able to make the cake I’m asking for. But the moment I spoke to Cristal, I knew she will be the one making my cake. She was enthusiastic about making the cake, made it sound very doable, and finished the job in less than a week! She is very talented and takes pride in her work! Don’t hesitate to order a custom cake from her and be confident that your vision will come to life.“

“The Best!! Love Averything!! Very loyal to their customers👍“

“Pure perfection!!! Thank you for helping make our 100 year celebration such a success ⛳️“

“I purchased a custom cupcake cake for my mom's 65th birthday party and I couldn't be happier with the cake and the whole process of working with David's Custom Cake. They went over every detail with me thoroughly, making sure the inspiration pictures I gave them were tailored to exactly what I wanted. They made payment and pick up very easy and were extremely friendly, caring, and professional. And the bonus- it was DELICIOUS! I recommend getting your cake here for any occasion! Thank you David's Custom Cakes!“

“If there is ever a time you need a cake for a special occasion. Please look no further. I can say nothing short of an absolute incredible experience from Beth. Her expertise is second to none and the cake itself was nothing short of exquisite. She will truly take whatever you envisioned and take it to the next level“

“Love the friendliness inside!!“

“The owner Erika was a pleasure to work with. Super helpful with choosing the right size cake. Designed the cake better than the picture I sent. The cross and rosary were so realistic it’s hard to believe it’s sugar. Not only was it a gorgeous cake but so fresh and delicious!“

“Riquisimo sazon. La mejor fritura dominicana chimis! picapollo! pechurinas! club Sandwich 🥪“

“Best bakery ever. Best Cuban sandwich in town, and everything else. The pasteleros, the café con leche , the ham croquettes every top quality.“

“Good page with interesting stuffs kindly follow like share and comment on it for more contents“

“Markela was such a pleasure to work with. My custom cookies were fabulous looking and tasting. She went above and beyond to make sure the presentation was beautiful and that my cookies were delivered/ shipped. I highly recommend Dulce cakes snd desserts !“

“Steph’s Baking Boutique was recommended from a local page. I am from out of the area, but needed to order a cake for my sister-in-law’s baby shower. This was a perfect recommendation! Steph did a fantastic job, the cake was delicious and we ordered cupcakes in another flavor to accompany the cake. I had sent her some ideas and photos and she went above and beyond. For the toppers of the cupcakes I thought she would just do an icing decoration, but she added sugar cookies and they came out so cute and complimented our theme perfectly! Thank you again!“

“Siiii!!! Me encanta lo que hacen!! Sigan asi!! Saludos desde ARGENTINA!! 😃😃“

“muy rico pan recién orniado“

“Son super ricos los pasteles“

“This place is a favorite of the locals. Wide selection, all freshly backed, wonderfully friendly staff and the cherry on top is the actually fair prices in a time when almost nothing feels like that. They offer freshly made breads (including challah and Italian style breads) cakes, cookies and so on. This is a walk in bakery not a place to sit.“