50 Best Delis near Rutherford

“Materas’s really came through when i needed catering in a hurry due to an unexpected family emergency. I dropped in with zero notice and they were able to help me with feeding dozens of people within 30 minutes. The food was awesome as always. Kudos to Matera’s. Truly wonderful people.“

“Sandwich was so overstuffed it was almost impossible to eat without making a mess. fresh bread, tons of meat, and somehow everything still tasted balanced. little shop gets crowded around lunch and there’s usually people waiting near the counter. not really a place you hang out for long, more like grab your food and figure it out as you go.“

“Mutz is a soft, mild cheese. You'd be forgiven for thinking that it would struggle to stand up to roast beef, roast turkey, hot peppers, sweet peppers, and the soft loaf encasing them all in a piled-high deli sandwich.

This mutz shines through. The stories about this place? The Biancamano lore? All true. This old-school deli shows why they're an institution.“

“Great place Wonderful food Good service“

“The waiters in white coats are busy behind the counter, the menu has not changed for decades, and even the lighting seems to have remained in the last century - this is the old New York I want.“

“High quality food and top notch service. The online market and delivery offered this year have been fantastic and very convenient. Highly recommend.“

“Staff is outstanding. i've been coming here for years. They're frozen dumplings are delicious. They're tofu is outrageous. Tofu pudding with syrup to die for. I live in suffering county long island. 39 miles. Worth the trip. I stop here every time after I stop at EW trading around the corner. Jenny and Joe. Awsome.“

“The sandwich’s are priceless. The wait is worth it sometimes lol.“

“Great food. Nice clean space and all the guys there are super friendly“

“I love this place for so many reasons. They deliver. They assist and carry you purchase to your car. The food is verr good ! Get the White pizza with Broccoli and Meat Lasagna with Eggplant Parm.“

“The best deli hands down! I’m a vegetarian and I LOVE how they have plenty of vegan and vegetarian options. Their veggie burgers are AMAZING and let me tell you about their Falafel burger!!!! DELICIOUS!!!!! The store owner and cook are so welcoming and nice! If anyone is around the neighborhood please pay a visit!“

“The taste profile is spot on. One of the better Italian Deli in the vicinity. High food quality. The place is clean and the staff and owner are very down to earth and humble.“

“Stopped before Jets game for sub…. Great people! Super friendly and the subs were awesome! So much MEAT!!!“

“This one the BEST rice ball I have ever had!!“

“Plain bagel with veggie cream cheese 👌 just amazing. Perfect about of cream cheese in my opinion, and triple wrapped so it stayed warm and soft to eat when I got back to my destination.
Staff were so kind. It was quick to get in and out also.“

“Always a great experience at the deli. The owner is very personable and accommodating.“

“I got smoothies here almost daily while I was staying nearby, and they were great.

I wanted to try and keep a good diet of fruits and vegetables whilst I was in NY for work, and this was a reliable spot to get green/fruit smoothies and standalone fruits.“

“This deli is a great addition to the landscape of our small town! It's cozy, clean, and inviting, and of course has great food made to order. Short story... one evening I was running late to work on second shift. Michelle had already closed, but was still inside cleaning. She let me in, and made me the two sandwiches I requested without hesitation. I will never forget that. Thanks Michelle! Keep up the great work!“

“Amazing food, very clean environment. Great staff. Beyond reasonable prices!!!! Strongly recommend.“

“I recently stopped by this deli, and it turned out to be an excellent choice. The moment I walked in, I was welcomed with warm smiles and quick, attentive service. The place is clean, well-organized, and has that classic deli charm that makes you feel right at home.

The food was the real highlight—fresh ingredients, generous portions, and flavors that stand out. Whether you’re craving a hearty sandwich, fresh salad, or something warm and comforting, everything is prepared with care. You can tell they take pride in what they do.

Prices are reasonable, and the quality makes it even more worth it. If you’re in the area and want something delicious, satisfying, and made with attention to detail, this deli is definitely worth the stop. Highly recommended!“

“have been going for 40 years always a pleasure wonderful staff consistent quality Deli“

“Sunny & Annie’s Deli in New York was a place where you could truly feel the authentic vibe of everyday local life blending with a wave of creative energy. I highly, highly recommend their signature menu, the Pho Sandwich—it is absolute perfection!“

“good food and lot's of variety to choose from“

“Great owner, friendly staff, and an awesome deli counter. Fresh Mozzarella is store made and is some of the best I’ve ever had. The owner has special ordered coffee upon request for me. Ridgefield Park Liquor & Deli is a great community store!“

“My Family and I were visiting up from PA for the weekend and decided to come here for breakfast. Not only was the food amazing but service was as well. Place was well kept and coffee was good. The staff were friendly and welcoming, what more could you want?!?“

“One of the best, hands down.“

“Went here with a couple of my friends the other day and ordered the knockout steak and fries and i’m not gonna lie they say colonial grill is the best, in my opinion this spot is where it’s at. Steak cooked just right everything just amazing keep up the good work terrace ave deli🙏🏾..“

“Delicious Breakfast Poutine!!!“

“Federal Gourmet is a convenient neighborhood deli offering a wide range of sandwiches, snacks, and quick bites. The food is fresh, portions are generous, and everything is made efficiently. It’s a reliable spot when you need something fast, simple, and satisfying on the go.“

“I was renovating my house over the summer and my kitchen was out of commission for four months. We ate lunch here practically the entire time. I NEVER had a bad dish! The staff is friendly, the place is clean and the food is AMAZING! ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️“

“Now this is a good bodega. Ordered a sandwich and was such a fair price. And not only fair price, but the sandwich was amazing! And included a bag of chips! There’s a lot of bodegas in NYC, let me tell you, and not every one of them is offering this kind of quality at such a good price. And the guys were super nice as well. Keep up the good work.“

“Best deli in the Kips Bay neighborhood. The sandwiches/wraps are objectively good, the smoothies can be a hit or miss depending on who's working that day, great service overall. The previous resident cat that was a long haired tortie (I think) was so friendly and adorable.“

“We visited this spot specifically for the pastrami, and it did not disappoint. It has a milder flavor compared to Katz's, which I actually prefer since it allowed me to finish the whole sandwich in one go. Katz's meat is so intensely flavorful that I usually need to take a break and cleanse my palate before I can finish later. This place is a fantastic alternative if you're in Jersey. The prices are reasonable, and the 8 oz option is perfect for satisfying your craving without breaking the bank. The Knish and macaroni salad were delicious as well. They give you delicious pickles. We’ll definitely be returning often. Update January 2026. Stopped by for some pastrami sandwiches. They are still delicious and worth every penny. Hot dog special this week, $2.00. They were flavorful with an awesome snap.“

“I ordered a Chicken Cheesesteak, with their signature Chipotle Sauce, and it was phenomenal!!... Roll was so soft & fresh... Their store is so clean & neat, and I received great customer service!!... Their kiosks helped me to have a quick & easy transaction & the owner Mr. Rudy was extremely helpful, and nice!!... I recommend Poppies Deli to all who desire good quality food & a fast & efficient service!!...“

“This place is clean and well organized. I went for a quick lunch break and staffs were well respectful and made amazing sandwich. I highly recommend this place if you are in area. I am definitely going back for endless selections of food.“

“The Real Deal In Italian Deli.“

“Delicious food prepared with such love and care. You will enjoy every morsel😁“

“Everything delicious: Best Italian sub sandwich; eggplant parmigiana. Going years. No exaggeration“

“The best sandwiches in the area“

“Best deli sandwich of all time. Make sure J is on the grill he’s top 2 and not number 2. Prices are extreme reasonable especially for the area. Make sure to give it a visit. Bonus everything is halal and organic and locally sourced!!!“

“The reviews are all true . This is real deal Italian neighborhood food ! Homemade soups, cold sandwiches that don’t cut corners, hot subs done properly, liquor available, and genuinely good service from a family-run spot planted in one of New Jersey’s strongest Italian communities.

The power move is the steam table in the back. That’s where the nonna cooks whatever she felt like winning with that day.

Daily specials, rotating, well seasoned, zero shortcuts. I’ve tried several. They don’t miss EVER 🔥🔥

Daily specials change constantly and are posted on their website. Skip the trendy places pretending to do this. This one actually does“

“Just had their cheese ravioli and manicotti. Wow! The manicotti was so delicious and creamy. Absolute heaven! And the ravioli were the best I’ve ever tasted. Deluxe! I’ll definitely be traveling the 1 hour+ up to Nutley to pick up more.“

“Best meatball parm in NYC“

“As a mom you worry about what your kids eat when they are on the go. My daughter has ulcerative colitis and can only eat certain foods. Wonder has been a great place for me and my daughter to go come where we dont have to worry about limited food options for her gluten free diet or things that are anti inflammatory. The staff is also very welcoming and helpful 😀.“

“You know a place is special when it starts feeling less like a deli and more like a second home.

Only real ones know about this spot right now, but honestly… it deserves all the love.

Grandma and grandpa own the deli and the warmth of the place reflects them completely. The moment you walk in, you’re greeted by the scent of fresh flowers from the huge flower selection at the entrance, warm smiles, and the kind of generosity that’s becoming rare these days. They genuinely care about people. You can feel it in the way they remember faces, serve food, and create an atmosphere where everyone feels welcome.

The open kitchen concept is such a rare find now too. Everything is always incredibly clean, comforting, and full of life. It feels human in there.

And the food… genuinely some of the best Korean comfort food I’ve had. I’ve tried pretty much everything on the menu at this point and it’s all fire 😭 The bibimbap is top tier, the tteokbokki is addictive, and both the cabbage kimchi and radish kimchi are SO good. One thing I especially love is that her kimchi is vegan, with no fermented shrimp like traditional recipes. It tastes clean, homemade, and deeply comforting.

There’s generous seating so I bring my friends here often, but it’s also perfect for grabbing lunch on the go. They also have some of the best brews in town and so many underrated Korean snacks and little finds that make the whole place feel even more special.

One of those places you almost don’t want to post because once everyone knows… it changes.

But please support small businesses like this 🤍

And trust me, I’m really not the type to write reviews unless it’s truly worth it.
You’re welcome : )“

“Excellent Food and service. Top Notch!!!!!“

“The #1 and the Chicken, Eggplant, or Meatball Parmigiana Sandwiches are literally perfect on every level. Expertly sliced, sized and also very fairly priced. The Daily Homemade soups are great as are the Daily Specials. If I lived closer I'd eat lunch here daily. Cash $$ only.“

“Amazing place. Our favorite in NYC. Great food. Wonderful people.“

“This place has been around for as long as I can remember. I vaguely remember them being in a different location though.....on the corner adjacent to them.....where CVS is now (they expanded that space. The place is small with no tables. There's just a couple of stools by the window. We always order delivery though. Family run by husband, wife and son. They are all very nice and delivery is always within 30 minutes. I've tried a bunch of things from there. Egg sandwiches, cold cut sandwiches, BLTs, burgers, pasta salad, fries etc. I haven't disliked anything. Their fries are a must get! Not sure why they're so good, but they are. As for the pricing, everything is under $10 which is great! Definitely check them out!“

“Friendly atmosphere. Great menu, delicious food.! I would come back anytime. Highly recommend stopping by, making friends with the owner and feeling at home while there. Great place to visit while in between work meetings, a lunch break or just need food and place that will hug your spirit: :)“