50 Best Ice Cream Shops near Sea Isle City

“We went to visit this weekend and the ice cream was delicious👍“

“Let me first start with a compliment to Joe here ! I called in a day before to make sure that I could get a cake for my niece , and he confirmed the opening time was 11 am , I was early the next day for 10 minutes and surprisingly he opened the door at 1050 am and welcomed me in to sort me out ! He was way cool and patient about the questions I had and explained well , I got a few ice creams for my staff back in the office and he made all of them with a smile . When the cake was ready he was all smiles and ring me up , and of coz because of his exceptional service I got more ice cream ! DQ ! you have a winner here that represent your establishment well !“

“The name says it all…very good ice cream!! Had 2 scoops of cannoli in a waffle cone which was huge! Best waffle cone I’ve had to date!! Parking is difficult but we had a driver and she had Baby Rasharda to keep her company!! I would have drove but I was day drinking Garage Beer all day, then we went for a boat ride and Captain Billy had me shook!! This place does get packed but it is worth the wait! Only thing that could make this place better while you wait would be to have Bieber continuously singing Yummy!!!“

“Best ice cream store in town! Family owned and operated. They make their own waffle cones- so good. Love the vibe there❤️“

“Let me start by saying the owner Steph is truly all about making sure her customers are completely satisfied. I love that she changes her menu up with many different great tasting flavors. She has completely earned my Rita's business all the time. See you guys next year for some more great falvors. I must say the marshmallow and peanut butter ice and strawberry and peanut butter ice are my favorites.“

“Cash only. I really like their variety of ice cream flavors offered, especially the brookie dough. The line does get long and it does not move quickly. Service is slow, as they have limited employees working and limited space for those employees. Even with the wait, I still visit a couple of times each year. There is sufficient street parking - we usually drive there and have never had a problem finding parking within a two minute or less walk.

Parking: Plenty of parking available within a 2 minutes or less walk.

Kid-friendliness: Very kid-friendly

Wheelchair accessibility: The waiting line is wide enough for a wheelchair“

“best staff & ice cream! what’s not to love??“

“Always amazing service and food! We ordered the Cranberry Pear Streusel Pie for Thanksgiving and it was the best pie we’ve ever had! You could taste ever single flavor and it was so refreshing!“

“We absolutely love Tuckahoe Ice Creama!!! They have the most delicious ice cream at the best prices in our area! They sell homemade ice cream cake along with all kinds of specialty ice cream and ice cream desserts! We are so excited when they open for the season and so sad when they close for the winter! The ice cream cake is truly heavenly And the price is amazing for what you receive. They are the best in our area. ♥️🎉🧜🏻‍♀️🍦“

“Really good ice cream, large portions, seating available, bathrooms on site, off-street parking is free (but limited, of course). Not cheap, but what is? Workers are chill. A few blocks from the beach and boardwalk—no seagulls! The wait is worth it. Wish they opened a little earlier in the day, when it’s really hot. Also, a flavor board at the back of the line would be nice.“

“truly outstanding. as a lactose (very) intolerant person, i just cant resist☺️☺️☺️!! got my tonsils out and this healed it in a jiffy!! this place jumpin every night since it is the hottest ice cream place in avalon ( un ironicly 😙) toppings galore and extraordinarily amazing customer service. as a 64 year old local myself i watched this place grow in popularity from the ground up!! they make the line go speedy quick despite business. overall 9.37393974747383/10 and its pretty splendid. until next time!!!!🥲🥲🥲“

“I am a Kindergarten teacher in Millville and we decided to take the whole grade level to the beach for a field trip. I reached out to the Churn House asking if they could accommodate our K students and they did not hesitate at all. They opened their ice cream shop early just for our school to enjoy. They made the students huge homemade ice cream sandwiches that were absolutely delicious! Communication was beyond superb and we will be using them again!! Thank you so much for making our kiddos beach day special!!“

“I wish you had more than 5 stars. We can’t say enough good things about our experience. I called ahead and got an emphatic “yes” when I asked if they could accommodate my 6 year old granddaughter who has celiac disease. When we got there and to the counter the owners and counter help could not have been nicer, or more knowledgeable. They gave us our options, of which there were plenty. Showed us the ingredient label. Went in the back for a fresh tub and a clean scoop. We were a party of 8 , and besides celiacs we had one diabetic and one who gets anxiety when having to make a choice between so many flavors. They handled it all. And the ice cream was delicious.“

“I was intrigued by the guy dressed up as Mr. Softee waving at cars daily even in the winter! I was finally curious enough to stop in. They don't have many vegan / non-dairy options but do have dole whip in either strawberry or pineapple.“

“Fabulous waffles sundaes and great staff!“

“Pretty awesome spot. Would recommend!“

“Delicious ice cream and waffle cones, great customer service.“

“Delicious ice cream and waffle cones, great customer service.“

“I recently ordered their salt water taffy for the first time. A snow storm hit and I wasn't sure if my order would arrive on time. Nancy at Shrivers was THE BEST! The customer service was exceptional. She continually monitored the situation. Thankfully it did arrive on time!! Not only is the customer service exemplary, the salt water taffy is the best taffy I have ever eaten!! It's full of flavor and smooth on the palate. Top quality! I received so many compliments! You WILL NOT regret purchasing Shrivers Salt Water Taffy for any occasion. I will definitely be purchasing more!“

“Service is always outstanding and the bananas are the best!!“

“Awesome ice cream 🍦 Will be going back.👍👍👍“

“We had the most amazing experience here tonight. The quick story is the soft serve dipped in chocolate was delicious. The longer version is our daughter has Celiac’s Disease and when we asked if they could do hers gluten free, Annalise was amazing and took it very seriously. She was actually training a new employee and used the opportunity to go through the process step by step with him. She honestly reminded me of the people they discover on the show Undercover Boss. It was obvious not only how much she cared about ensuring our daughter had a safe experience, but also to properly train her employee, and overall just the pride she had in her work. She was amazing and we will definitely return.“

“The atmosphere is welcoming and laid back. Great place to bring the kids for a sweet treat. Prices are as expected and the food is delicious. Has always been a great local staple during the spring and summer months for a quick bite or cold treat! We visit the Ranch at least 5x a season.“

“The coolest guy I’ve ever met Jun“

“The new Owners Rob & Kim who took over Salty Paws in Stone Harbor are simply the BEST ! They are extremely friendly, have a sincere love for all animals and are the kindest people you will ever meet ! My PepperGirl enjoys roaming around the store, getting extra love and attention. Our favorite pet treats are the Peanut Butter cannoli’s and of course their doggie ice cream ! If you haven’t visited Salty Paws in Stone Harbor, you must ! You will NOT be disappointed… They also hold Special Events for our 4 legged friends ! You guys rock ! You are definitely PepperGirl Approved !“

“Have been coming here for years. First with our kids and now with our grandkids. Owner is one of the nicest people I have ever met! Great service and great products. Five stars for sure!!!“

“Fabulous waffles sundaes and great staff!“

“We started patronizing in 2022. Always consistent and friendly staff. Went today! Great service! 🏁👍“

“It’s Kohrs, what’s not to ❤️“

“Always fast and friendly service and the ice cream is delicious“

“delicious vegan treat! well done on the strawberry whip...“

“Great ice cream and reasonable prices 🥰“

“Pretty tasty. The staff is very polite. I think some of the prices were a bit too high. We had gotten 5 small (and they are pretty small) ice cream cups for like $20. The mediums seems a much more reasonable price. Was like twice the size (maybe more) of the small for not much more. But nice for a family treat on the way home from the shore.“

“It’s Kohrs, what’s not to ❤️“

“I just finished my Winter stay in one of the suites available from Jilly's. I was very pleased with the accommodations and it was a good value for me. I will definitely return there in the future.👍“

“I LOVE Rita's, and this Rita's is no exception! The variety of flavors is outstanding, the consistency of the actual water ice is excellent. Their custard is also outstanding, and a mix of the two makes any day a great day for me😀. Staff are well trained, and service is fast. Visit Rita's - you won't be disappointed!“

“Been there every day this week. The Vegan Coconut Almond Fudge Chip is by far best vegan ice cream I have had!!“

“Phenomenal dole whip, it may not be for everyone but I highly recommend the 5 mile cake.“

“Awesome ice cream 🍦 Will be going back.👍👍👍“

“Love the ice cream cakes! It's all the kids want for their birthdays now!“

“I was Happy to try the Flamethrower Burger w/Fries,along with a Medium drink/Flurry(Awesome service worthy of 10,000/10,000 of awesomeness)“

“Excellent service, customized authentic boba“

“Love the ice cream! Don’t like the choice of vocabulary in the menu.“

“Best pizza I've tried on the boardwalk. They're always crispy and fresh and flavorful, and you get a really decent size slice for the price you pay, especially vs certain competitors.

I can also vouch for their ice cream right next door, they sell Richman's which is a good brand and have a ton of different fun combos you can get.

If you go to the OC boardwalk and go anywhere else for pizza, try here, you'll be converted real fast!“

“The coolest guy I’ve ever met Jun“

“Blend was our server for our ice cream cones. He was very nice and friendly and gave us the perfect amount of ice cream. He made our ice cream experiences fun! ?

Kid-friendliness: A highlight for the kids on the boardwalk!“

“I had a fudge sundae over vanilla M&M ice cream. Really good ice cream. Highly recommended.“

“Very much enjoyed my delicious order of Singapore noodles and pork fried rice. The owner is very sweet and friendly also. Will be back to dine-in soon!!“

“Custard was pretty good. We wanted to go to a la mode but the line was wrapped around the building at 9:30 so we figured we’d try something new.

We got gelaties and custard.

-4 flavors of water ice & 2 flavors for custard…chocolate and vanilla.

It’s CASH ONLY.

Water ice is chunky and not like a Rita’s but still good! It works for a quick treat.“

“So EVERYONE knows about George’s Macaroons, breakfasts and Ice cream.
But I just had THE MOST DELICIOUS HOMEMADE FUDGE delivered, and it was beyond wonderful!!!!
I received a gift card for my birthday and I ordered the fudge I knew would be delicious from when I used to order it when I was right there in O.C., New Jersey, but it was even better than I remember!!! SOOOOO FRESH!!! Unfortunately, I’m not able to go to travel to Ocean City, New Jersey right now ! AND George’s Candies delivered the fudge immediately. AND I found out they will DELIVER ALL YEAR LONG & I am out of State!!! Do not miss out on this decadent homemade fudge that is BEYOND LUSCIOUS!!!!! Yummmmmmm!!!!“