31 Best American Restaurants near Sussex

“Food is homemade and portions are large, derive is great , quaint ambiance 16-20 seats inside, coffee is excellent! Service is friendly, well worth going for breakfast in Sussex County NJ“

“today stopped in for a coffee for the ride back home to paterson nj. met roxanne and D. I REMEMBER THE PLACE WHEN I WAS A TEEN SOME TIME AGO THE PLACE IS UNIQUE AND HAS TO THIS DAY THE OLD SCHOOL ATMOSPHERE AND IMAGE TO ADMIRE, BROUGHT BACK GREAT MEMORIES TO ADMIRE SO IF YA WANT ABITE COMEING OR GOING YOU WONT BE DISSAPPOINTED GREAT TO SEE THAT IT LIVES ON AND WILL .“

“wow great food pizza is amazing!! Went to the bar afterwards and had a chocolate martini!! The bartender Alyssa was best engaging and a great smile! Will definitely be back !!!“

“Love this place. It’s definitely one of the better restaurants/bars in the area. Not like some other restaurants in the area, that charge you a percentage to use your CC. Not only that one particular owner takes tip money away from waitresses because you used your CC. Could you imagine the owner taking tip money away, because a customer used a credit card. Sad for those other restaurants. This place is honest and friendly.“

“Best place in town. I love the staff and the food selections are amazing. The banquet hall upstairs is awesome. Huge room. Lost of space and reasonably priced. You also get your own private bartender. These people always go above and beyond for their guests.“

“Normally order regular pizza which is great but yesterday I ordered the Tuscany Chicken Pizza. It was amazing and the best pizza I’ve ever had! Try it- you won’t be disappointed“

“Absolutely best food around and the service from the bartenders to servers and of course to Mr. Shane… my wife loves there little neck clams … today we had there special of braised short ribs and the killer meatloaf … if you haven’t been there definitely you are missing out … Great drinks as well and super great service…“

“Great lunch, great staff, clean and friendly atmosphere“

“Home cooking in a relax atmosphere. Food is excellent and the coffee mugs make you feel like you’re at Granny’s house. Perfection.“

“Nice bar restaurant at the end of a round. We were there on a Wednesday and it was empty. We order BBQ knowing that it was not going to be fresh as the grills were not going. That said the brisket and pulled port were still good. The sweet potato fries were good as well. Little crispy. We both should have order the bbq souce on the side. Too much on for our taste but we should have asked. Great bar with a large selection of whiskey and bourbon. Service was great too. I would go back. Like to see how it is when it’s fresh.“

“TLDR: Top tier brisket. Nearly as good as Texas brisket and certainly best I have had in New Jersey thus far. The hidden restaurant in the middle of a garden is so quaint and peaceful, I recommend going for lunch or a cozy dinner. View of the surrounding hills is also amazing.

Quality of Food: I had no complaints about the food. The garden salad was refreshing and did not lack in its flavor. The brisket was AMAZING. If you look at my other reviews, you will find I am originally from the south and have frequented a few BBQ places in New Jersey, all of which have fallen short of what I have come to find as quality BBQ. This. Did. Not. Disappoint. The brisket was slightly marbled and melted in your mouth. I can only imagine the quality of the Rib Steak if the brisket was top notch. The cornbread was the only thing I could say was standard taste and quality.

Quality of Service: It was neither over-the top nor mediocre service. Seemed like a decent amount of young adults were waiting on tables. We stopped in for a quick bite before heading to a festival, but we had no issues getting our order taken, food delivered and check processed quickly.

Environment & Ambiance: Can't be compared to the other locations at the resort. The garden by itself is adorable and makes you feel like you're in a storybook. Looking out towards the hills provides a feeling of awe. The outside ambiance and cute tables and chairs makes you feel like you're joining Alice at a tea party.

Pricing and Concerns: It's certainly not cheap if you are ordering their higher priced options. However, that being said, it is most definitely worth every penny. Not to mention you're at a resort, so what would you expect besides expensive dishes? For a party of two you can keep it under $$$. Add drinks or an extra person and you're going over. No other concerns to note.

Comment and Recommendation: Yes! I recommend! If I didn't already make it obvious - go for the brisket!“

“Spurs are THE best chicken tenders…..my go too every time…..one of our favorite spots for good food, friendly staff…..did I mention the spurs?? And the burgers are great too!“

“Great food, great people, love the new menu!“

“My wedding day was 10/05/2025 As a wedding photographer, I would say the view is perfect for the photo!!! We held our ceremony and cocktail hour in the large open mountain area surrounded by lush greenery—it was stunning. For the reception, the indoor barn provided a woody, cozy, and elegant atmosphere that felt both warm and refined. One of the biggest highlights was having the entire venue to ourselves for the whole day. Unlike other places, we didn’t have to share the space with other weddings, which made the experience feel very private and special. Everything was incredibly clean and well-maintained, especially the bathrooms (which were large and spotless!), and the private bridal suite was perfect for getting ready. The owner and staff are true professionals. The owner is an experienced chef, and you can really taste the difference with the farm-to-table menu. Everything was fresh, organic, and seasonal. Our guests haven't stopped raving about how terrific the food was! We also loved the tasting session before the wedding, which helped us feel confident in our choices. The managers guided us through every step, offering great suggestions and coordinating with our vendors (who they have great partnerships with—no pressure to buy!). They kept everything running smoothly and on schedule, answering every question we had along the way. We can’t wait to come back for one of their farm dining events in the future!“

“Extensive menu. Efficient and kind staff. I’ve had a few different entrees on the menu and they all were delicious. My favorite Diner in New Jersey.“

“Haven't been there in years. Went back to try something new. Happily surprised. Went on Friday. Brought the whole family back on Sunday. The service is excellent and very personable. Met the owner. Very nice couple. You don't feel rushed. The food is very good. Large portions so be hungry when you go. Great value. I also enjoyed the music. I just missed the piano player because I had to leave but I'll be back.“

“Awesome pancakes this morning! We have eaten there for breakfast several times. Food is always fresh & delicious!“

“⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ 5 Stars

I had an absolutely wonderful experience at Crystal Springs Resort, and a big part of that was thanks to Miss Barbie. She was an outstanding waitress with an amazing personality, a warm smile, and exceptional customer service skills. From the moment we were seated, she was attentive, professional, and made sure every detail was taken care of.

What impressed me most was how attentive she was not only to me, but also to my family and the children in our group. She made everyone feel comfortable, welcomed, and well cared for throughout our visit. Her patience, kindness, and genuine concern for our needs did not go unnoticed.

Miss Barbie had everything on point—from checking on our table regularly to making sure our food, drinks, and overall dining experience were enjoyable and stress-free. Her positive attitude and friendly demeanor truly stood out and made our visit even more special.

Crystal Springs Resort is fortunate to have someone like Miss Barbie on their team. She definitely deserves a 5-star rating and has become my favorite waitress. I look forward to returning and hope to be served by her again. Thank you, Miss Barbie, for making our visit so memorable!

Highly recommended!“

“This was our first dining experience at Westtown Fare Restaurant. To say we were very impressed is an understatement. Charming atmosphere, friendly and attentive service, combined with an outstanding meal all contributed to a pleasant and satisfying dinner. We will be returning. A+++“

“Had dinner there last night. Service was great with special notice to out server Denise. Tipped her accordingly. Other staff removed used dishes in a timely manner. Meals arrived hot and portion size was perfect. This was our 4 visit to them and always had great dinning,“

“Last night we did the 7-course chef’s tasting menu with wine pairing at Restaurant Latour at Crystal Springs Resort. In my opinion, this is easily one of the best restaurants in Sussex County.

The wine pairings were very well done and thoughtfully matched to each course. You could tell a lot of effort went into balancing the flavors and overall experience. Some dishes were outstanding and really memorable, while others were good but did not have the same wow factor.

You can definitely see that the restaurant is striving for a Michelin-level dining experience. The presentation, creativity, and overall atmosphere are there, although there are still some areas that could be elevated further.

The setting was beautiful, especially watching the sunset during dinner. Pricing was about what you would expect for this type of experience.

The biggest thing holding the evening back was service staffing. The staff was polite and professional, but the dining room felt understaffed at times, which created gaps in service that took away from the overall flow of the evening.

Overall, we had a very enjoyable experience and would absolutely recommend it to anyone looking for a high-end dining experience in Sussex County.“

“The staff is very attentive, and kind. We always get Marco as our server and he’s great! Tonight was no different. Also, Melissa was the manager tonight and she was constantly around and available if we needed something when Marco was helping other tables. The team at this location works really well together so we’ll definitely be coming back.“

“it's just a fun place. waitress are friendly. love the bands. especially jack Romano.“

“This place is so charming and the food is incredible!!! We sat outside and enjoyed pancakes with berries and the special sweet potato bowl with spinach, mushrooms and pulled pork. They also have espresso drinks and my cappuccino was served with a sprinkle of cinnamon, a lovely touch. This is a wonderful spot for breakfast or lunch“

“Crystal Tavern Restaurant offers a wonderful, elegant atmosphere to enjoy dinner with family or a loved one. The quality of the food was outstanding, and our server, Rachel, was courteous, friendly, and provided excellent service throughout our visit. Highly recommended!“

“Beautiful venue with a view, great staff and service, tasty food. Had a great time at a line dancing event there with Debbie and Beyond the Line, hope to be back soon!“

“It was an incredibly hot sunny day, my partner and I were looking for a dining experience when we came across Biergarten. I am absolutely blown away and all expectations were incredibly exceeded. They have a plethora of options including the bison burger, pulled pork, kids menu and much more. We decided to go with the tacos and tried each of every kind. Our absolute favorite was the Mahi Mahi tacos. Perfect blend of Mahi, Pineapple Salsa, and other ingredients. All balanced perfectly. The chicken taco was also incredibly delicious. Incredibly simple and traditional, however tasted extremely phenomenal. The pork taco and steak tacos were also very tasty. However the Chicken and Mahi are my personal recommendation. Our waitress (apologies for forgetting your name) a young woman, tan complexion. Was incredibly friendly, attentive and interactive and made our dining experience even more of a pleasure. Incredibly delicious, and cozy. I would recommend and return to this establishment 1000%!“

“Fabulous pizza. Will definitely return.“

“I love eating here...people are friendly, and inviting...“

“I came to the restaurant a little after they opened and I was extremely delighted to see the mother and son Duo back at work honestly from all the times I've been there they seem to be the most respectful and hard-working people out of anybody else I've seen there I didn't show the reaction when I was in there because I was doing with something else but deep down I was extremely delighted to see them besides that the food was great and the place was very clean and tidy once again I was extremely delighted to see the mom and son duo especially the Son since from what experienced a few times he was given a hard time for nothing just because I'm a few comments even though he works the hardest and he does the most work out of most of the people he works with including his mother but the food was cooked correctly frys tasted amazing and the places was excellently clean“

“The chef is amazing and the staff is so friendly. We enjoy eating here often!! Love all the drink specials and desserts!!“