33 Best American Restaurants near Sussex

“Old Stone is a charming restaurant with a warm and welcoming atmosphere, reminiscent of Cracker Barrel. The owners are friendly and attentive, often taking on multiple roles, including waiting tables. The menu offers a unique take on traditional dishes, such as French Toast and Home Fries, which are cooked to perfection. The coffee is decent and accessible, and the bakery cases are always being filled with delicious treats, including vanilla sprinkled donuts and blueberry turnovers. The restaurant's interior features historical accents and antiques, making it feel cozy and all-American. The tables are arranged to provide ample space, and the window seats offer a nice view. Parking is plentiful, with a strip mall lot that's easily accessible. Overall, Old Stone is a great spot for a delicious meal and a warm atmosphere, with friendly service and a homey vibe.“

“Elias Cole is a warm and cozy restaurant with great service and delicious food. Their homemade bread is incredible and adds a special touch to any meal. The menu is limited but offers enough options for most diners. The staff, including Princess Veronica and Roxanne, provide friendly and attentive service. The cherry pie is a must-try dessert, with generous portions. The atmosphere is familiar and inviting, making it a great place to stop by if you're in the area. Just remember to bring cash, as there is no ATM nearby.“

“The Farm at Glenwood Mountain offers a remarkable dining and event experience. Nestled in a beautiful setting, it provides a true "farm to table" experience with ingredients sourced directly from the farm or local providers. The venue is ideal for those seeking a rustic yet chic ambiance. Steve, the chef, collaborates with guests to create personalized menus, making the process enjoyable and engaging. The barn, adorned with elegant decor, provides a charming atmosphere for various events. Accommodations are both luxurious and intimate, perfect for staying with a wedding party. The Farm at Glenwood Mountain also hosts open farm markets on weekends, where visitors can purchase farm-raised meats, eggs, vegetables, honey, and more. Their farm dinners are highly recommended for a taste of the exceptional cuisine. In addition to the superb food and venue, the service and staff are exceptional, contributing to an unforgettable experience. The Farm is an excellent choice for hosting weddings, as the team works diligently to ensure a flawless and personalized event. The venue's beauty, combined with the exquisite food and service, makes The Farm at Glenwood Mountain an outstanding destination for any special occasion.“

“The Green Olive Wantage, located on State Route 23, is a gem in a remote area. The exquisitely prepared food, generous portions, and beautiful dining room make it a must-visit spot. Whether you're dining in the cozy restaurant or on the deck/patio, the experience is delightful. Try the bar burger, which is considered the best in the area, or savor the perfectly cooked fillet mignon. The friendly staff, like Patricia, make every visit enjoyable. Don't miss out on this highly recommended restaurant!“

“The Lamp Post Inn is a local favorite, serving delicious meals and amazing specials throughout the week. With friendly and efficient service, this restaurant has been a go-to spot for over 40 years. Their huge portions, including calamari, a shrimp basket, and a fried chicken sandwich, are sure to satisfy any appetite. While some dishes may not meet everyone's high standards, the overall dining experience is worth a visit.“

“The EARLY AMERICAN TAVERN is a hidden gem in the area, offering excellent American cuisine in a cozy and colorful atmosphere. The menu features a variety of delectable options, from appetizers and soups to main entrees like wings, fried pickles, steak, burgers, and surf and turf. The friendly staff and welcoming vibe make it a great spot for both friends and families to gather and enjoy a memorable dining experience.“

“TJ's Pizza has received positive reviews from recent customers. The restaurant is praised for its friendly service and use of real dough for their personal pan pizzas, setting it apart from other locations. The pepperoni pie is a popular choice, being described as delicious and leaving customers wanting more. Overall, TJ's Pizza has been consistent in providing a satisfying dining experience.“

“Friendly's is an AMAZING restaurant with great food and service. The to-go cakes are stocked with a good variety, and the restaurant is always clean. They have plenty of parking and are very kid-friendly, always making kids happy with a smile on their faces. The simple food and delicious ice cream are enjoyed by all, especially with grandkids. Wheelchair accessibility is also accommodated easily. A top-notch, welcoming place that never disappoints.“

“Granny's Pancake House & Grill offers a warm and friendly environment, reminiscent of a favorite aunt's home. The bustling Sunday crowd enjoys quick service without feeling rushed. The Lumberjack special is a popular choice, featuring biscuits smothered in sausage gravy and a hearty omelette. Customers praise the affordable, home-style breakfast options like chicken and waffles. The staff's kindness and generous portions make this spot a local favorite, with many eager to return for more.“

“The Crystal Cafe is a family-friendly business that offers great food and excellent service. The menu features fresh and delicious options, including huge and fresh salads. The service is fast, and the atmosphere is cozy. It's a gem of Vernon, with affordable prices and a BYOB policy. Despite occasional cold breakfast dishes, the overall experience is wonderful.“

“Chef's Garden offers incredible food, from Clam apps to Ribeye Steak cooked to perfection. Chef Aishling ensures a perfect dining experience. Enjoy delicious pizza and drinks by the pool in a tropical setting, feeling like a mini-vacation. The friendly staff, including lifeguards, adds to the relaxing atmosphere. A great spot for a girls' getaway or hanging out with friends. Highly recommended for a fantastic time with great food and service.“

“My wife and I attended a wedding reception at the Black Bear Golf Club this past weekend. The evening was very enjoyable and Black Bear provided everything needed. The wedding ceremony was held outdoors in a comfortable setting. This was followed by a cocktail hour in a bright and airy room overlooking the golf course. There was a good variety of food stations and waitstaff serving hand held offerings. The food was very good. We then entered the main room for dinner. The room overlooked the golf course and a patio area with seating and a fire pit. The dinner include a delicious pasta dish, salad, a choice of filet mignon, baked chicken, shrimp scampi and a vegetarian option. Dessert was assorted pastries, cookies“

“Lafayette House is a fantastic venue for weddings and events like birthdays and Sweet 16’s. The staff is attentive, with a special shoutout to the maitre’d “Sara”. The rooms are beautiful, the food is exceptional, and the service is top-notch. Guests enjoyed dishes like blackened swordfish and chicken francese, paired with seasonal cocktails. A perfect evening with great food and entertainment awaits at Lafayette House.“

“Acquaviva Restaurant and Bar in Sussex County, NJ, offers a delightful dining experience with standout dishes. Meatballs, caprese salad, and various pasta options like Pappardelle and tortellini are popular choices. Meatballs and spicy shrimp are among the delicious starters. Entrees such as chicken parm, steak, and salmon Dijon receive high praise for their taste and quality. While there might be a slight delay in seating or bread service, the delicious food makes up for it.“

“The Butcher's Grill offers delicious food and coffee, with standout dishes including ribeye, grilled octopus, labneh, cheeseburger, lamb chops, chicken schnitzel, and potato rolls. The cozy restaurant, which seats around 20 people, boasts a lovely view of hayfields and mountains. During dinner, guests can enjoy a warm and eclectic atmosphere, with friendly and energetic service. For lunch, the soup of the day and juicy burgers come recommended. However, phone use on speaker in the dining room could be improved. Overall, The Butcher's Grill is a hidden gem, ideal for date nights or special occasions.“

“Homestead Rest is a local restaurant that offers a range of basic fare, including burgers, salads, and appetizers. The food is generally good, though not exceptional, making it a suitable spot for a casual meal and a few drinks. The restaurant has a quaint, Western-themed atmosphere, with live music adding to the ambiance. While the service can be a bit slow at times, the entrees are generally well-received, with the rodeo chicken being a particular highlight. Overall, Homestead Rest is a decent option for locals looking for a comfortable dining experience.“

“Acquaviva Restaurant and Bar in Sussex County, NJ offers a delightful dining experience. Their Burrata with Prosciutto and Balsamic drizzle is excellent, as well as the Salmon Dijon and Steak Pizzaiola. The meatballs, stuffed chicken, and tortellini are also highly recommended. Despite a slight delay in seating, the warm bread and delicious dishes make it a must-try restaurant.“

“American Deli & Grill is a wonderful place with super friendly staff and delicious food. They offer a HUGE turkey sandwich with mayo, onion, and tomato for under $12 as a lunch special. The staff is very helpful, although one worker with short hair can be rude. Parking can be a bit tricky, but the overall experience feels like visiting a hometown deli.“

“Westtown Fare Restaurant & Bar offers excellent food and drinks in a cute, hidden gem setting. Known for their beef Wellington, brussel sprout appetizer, and chocolate platter, the French onion soup and poached pear dessert are also a hit. The family-owned restaurant impresses with delicious dishes like Elk Chops and rib eye steak, making it worth the trip. Service is top-notch.“

“Applebee's Grill + Bar offers good food, with some dishes like Mac and cheese and chicken being highlights. Despite occasional issues like overly soupy Mac and cheese, the meals are generally satisfying. The restaurant's late hours make it a convenient choice for travelers, even though the service can sometimes be bland. However, there are exceptions, with standout servers like Jon B in Newton NJ providing fantastic and prompt service with a great attitude. The coffee quality can be hit or miss, but overall, Applebee's offers a decent dining experience with room for improvement in customer service.“

“Restaurant Latour offers an exceptional dining experience with impeccable service and delicious food. The staff, including the sommelier, waiters, and coat check attendant, go above and beyond to make guests feel welcome. The menu caters to dietary restrictions, with substitutions made to accommodate allergies and preferences. Dishes like the oxtail and chocolate mousse are highly recommended, along with the signature scallop udon. The presentation of the food is excellent, and the ambiance of the restaurant adds to the overall dining experience. Guests can enjoy a special touch with unique dishes like the two-tone kaluga caviar and the delectable coffee. The wine pairing is stellar, and the bread basket, especially the black garlic, is a standout. Overall, Restaurant Latour is a must-visit spot for a special and exciting meal.“

“Gemma's Country Kitchen is a family-friendly restaurant in Sussex County known for its delicious breakfast options. Their western omelette is a standout, as are their homefries, which are considered the best in the county. The menu also offers tasty breakfast sandwiches and delectable pancakes, French toast, and coleslaw. The staff is friendly and the atmosphere is homey, making it a great spot for a relaxing meal.“

“Crystal Tavern is a restaurant located near Crystal Springs Resort, known for its delicious food and picturesque views. The shrimp cocktail and chicken dish are standouts, as well as their unique pear cocktail. The restaurant also offers a breakfast buffet with a wide variety of options, though it can be on the pricier side. Service is generally good, but there can be delays in getting the waitstaff's attention due to the restaurant's popularity. The hostess and staff do not consistently acknowledge special occasions. There was an incident involving a bartender who almost served an alcoholic drink to a pregnant woman, which was followed by poor handling of the situation. Despite these issues, many customers express interest in returning to try more of the menu options.“

“Hampton Diner is a top-notch restaurant that exceeds expectations. It offers excellent service, great food, and a full-service bar with delicious drinks, including the recommended blue martini. The menu features standout items like burgers, gyros, sweet potato fries, pork chops with gravy, vegetables, and mashed potatoes. The diner also serves impressive specials, including a tasty Spanish paella. With outstanding food quality, a welcoming atmosphere, and a sense of community, Hampton Diner is a favorite among locals and visitors alike. The diner also offers online ordering with seamless pickup, making it a convenient option for families, who appreciate its kid-friendly environment.“

“Skylands Craft Beer & Wine Garden offers an enjoyable dining and drinking experience in Sussex County, New Jersey. The restaurant features a wide selection of craft beers, with $7 beer flights, as well as a variety of wines. The food menu caters to diverse tastes, with options like hot Italian panini and pepperoni pizza receiving positive reviews. The outdoor seating, fire pits, and live music on Sundays create a lively and scenic atmosphere. The staff is known for their friendly service, and the establishment is motorcycle-friendly with designated parking spots. While the parking lot can be challenging, the overall experience at Skylands Craft Beer & Wine Garden is praised by visitors.“

“Millside Cafe is a delightful restaurant with fresh and flavorful food. The menu offers delicious options such as a breakfast bowl and homemade soups, as well as tasty pancakes that are sure to please. The cafe stands out for its fresh ingredients and attentive staff, creating a cozy atmosphere and a satisfying dining experience. While it can get busy, making it sometimes challenging to get the staff's attention, the friendly service and fresh meals make it a worthwhile find. Millside Cafe is a charming addition to the area, and a recommended destination for a pleasant meal.“

“Cafe Serendipity in Newton is a great breakfast spot with amazing food like the "fat pat" and fluffy pancakes. The environment is quiet and comfortable, with excellent service. You can enjoy homemade food, make your own coffee, and stay as long as you like. It's a sweet place for friends to meet, with vegetarian options and kid-friendly menu available. Parking is convenient right out front, so why not check it out yourself?“

“Village Diner is a 50s retro spot with incredible breakfast options like Breakfast Pot pie, custom Omelette, and French toast. The Patty melt and chili are must-tries too. The prices are slightly high, but the food is good. The friendly staff, especially Sabrina, adds to the fantastic experience. Don't bother with the other diners in town - Village Diner is the place to be.“

“Brick & Brew is a restaurant known for its delightful food, as expressed by multiple reviews. The atmosphere is described as pleasant and chill, with a nice interior. The staff is attentive and friendly, providing good service. The menu includes a Cowboy Ribeye, pizza, and burgers, all highly recommended. A frequent customer has never had a bad meal here, and the bartender, Megan, is praised for her excellent service. Overall, Brick & Brew is a great spot for a satisfying meal.“

“Annabel's Pizza & Italian Restaurant is a small yet impressive eatery that serves authentic Italian-American flavors. The food is consistently hot and well-prepared, with generous portions that are sure to satisfy. The pasta dishes, such as Linguine in Red Clam sauce and Gnocchi Bolognese, are particularly delicious and made with love. The restaurant also offers crispy fried calamari and warm, comforting soups. Their NY-style pizza is a highlight, and the staff is accommodating and welcoming. Overall, Annabel's is a great option for those seeking authentic Italian cuisine and generous portions.“

“Wayback Burgers serves great burgers and exceptional fries. While milkshakes can be hit-or-miss, the restaurant offers many choices, including vegetarian options, and caters to kids and those with dietary restrictions. The staff is neutral, but the parking lot is spacious and wheelchair accessible, making it a convenient stop for a quick bite.“

“The George Inn is a charming and inviting restaurant that offers a delightful dining experience. With a large menu featuring vegetarian options like the delicious Eggplant, the eatery caters to a variety of tastes. The attentive staff, including the wonderful waitress Erin, provide personalized service and excellent recommendations. The restaurant boasts a comfortable, clean, and quiet atmosphere, making it a favorite among locals and visitors alike. Whether you're celebrating a special occasion or simply enjoying a casual meal, The George Inn is sure to impress with its exceptional food and warm hospitality.“

“Biergarten is a popular spot for mountain bikers to grab lunch and a beer. The bison burgers are a tasty option, but be prepared for a wait, as food can take a while to arrive, even during slow periods. The beer selection is available in a downloadable menu, but be patient, as the file size can be large. A small draft beer comes with a higher price tag of $10. Overall, a pleasant spot to relax and enjoy a meal, as long as you don't mind the wait.“