5 Best American Restaurants near Sussex

The Farm at Glenwood Mountain American • $$
1801 County Rd 565, Sussex

“The farm was the first venue we visited, and it was also the last. We fell in love that day and never looked back. Food is really important to us, and the farm was perfect. It was as close at it gets to a true "farm to table" experience, right on the property. All of their ingredients are either sourced from the farm itself, or other local ingredients. Steve, the chef, works with you directly to figure out the menu, and that process was really fun! The barn itself is the perfect setting for the "rustic chic" vibe that we were going for. It's gorgeous on its own and didn't require much for decoration, although working with Candice on the decor was easy and fun. We also stayed on the property that weekend (with our wedding party) and the accommodations were both luxurious and cozy/intimate. Working with Steve & Candice was a true pleasure, and we can't wait to go back for a farm dinner (they do those too!) soon. They also have an open farm market on weekends from 11-4 --- we highly recommend stopping by for farm raised meats, eggs, vegetables, honey, and so much more. <3“

4.8 Superb26 Reviews
Elias Cole American • $
1176 NJ-23, Sussex

Customers` Favorites

Grilled Chicken Sandwich
Philly Cheese Steak
Cheeseburger Deluxe
Sweet Potato Fries
Meatloaf Platter
Meatloaf Dinner
Lemon Meringue
Homemade Bread
Fish N' Chips
Fried Chicken

“We've been here twice so far and will continue to return. Their homemade bread is incredible so we'd recommend ordering anything that includes that! The most basic of sandwiches, ham and cheese, becomes delectable when served on their bread. The menu is pretty limited but provides enough options for most. The ham and cheese sandwich was obviously of great quality but we would strongly recommend something other than fish and chips. ?They also make homemade pies and he loved the cherry and it was a very healthy serving. (Maybe they gave an oversized portion because he hardly ate his lunch?)It could be confusing the difference between the deluxe burger on the menu and on the chalkboard special, besides a few dollars; but service is friendly and attentive so just ask.Finally, bring cash--or you have to leave your boyfriend behind and head south four miles to hit an ATM. ?“

4.5 Superb51 Reviews
The Lamp Post Inn Italian • $$
1601 County Rd 565, Sussex

Customers` Favorites

French Onion Soup Au Gratin
Pizza Burger and Fries
Peanut Butter Pie
Penne Alla Vodka
Chicken Wings
Buffalo Wings

“Lamp Post Inn is FANTASTIC! We recently had a reception here for our son's baptism. Sal (the owner) was a pleasure to work with. He was very responsive, helpful, and very patient with all my questions and inquiries. The room we had was perfect for our guest list of about 45 adults and 15 kids (10+ were under the age of 9!) Everyone RAVED about the food which was your normal buffet food. However, this was the best buffet food I have ever had! The chicken francize was my personal favorite. Our minimalist decorations were perfect for the intimate space and getting to be in the space early was perfect! Our servers went above and beyond for all our guests. I will definitely be coming back for my next gathering!“

4.3 Superb75 Reviews
The Green Olive Wantage Greek • $$
1 Libertyville Rd, Sussex

Customers` Favorites

Baby Rack of Lamb
Mushroom & Swiss
Chocolate Mousse
Garlic Shrimp
Greek Panini
French Fries
Greek Salad
Onion Soup

“We were pleasantly surprised our waitress Patricia was phenomenal the drinks were extremely reasonable and we had two Greek salads one with chicken and one with grilled shrimp they were amazing. This place is a very high recommendation. Get there “

4.3 Superb50 Reviews
9 Main St, Sussex

Customers` Favorites

Spice Is Nice Burger w Onion Rings
California Cobb Salad
Prime Rib Sandwich
French Onion Soup
Fried Pickles
Fish and Chips
Pretzel Bites
Irish Burger
Bacon Bombs
Pulled Pork

“What a lovely tavern treasure! Such a cozy and colorful atmosphere and great pub food served by wonderfully friendly staff. Great spot for friends or family get together:)Kid-friendliness: Family at the next table with little ones were having a blast!“

4 Good90 Reviews
map Map