50 Best Pizza Restaurants near Tenafly

“After finishing the kids' new school registration, we stopped by this pizza place for lunch. It was probably the first lunch I'd ever had in this neighborhood. We'd just finalized the house contract, so I'd taken a bus from a hotel in New York City to get here early in the morning.

Both my kids and I wanted a slice of Margherita pizza. But they only had two slices left! I was about to just order something else. But a kitchen staff member who was about to take a break came back in and made us a pizza. They willingly baked a whole new pizza just for one slice of Margherita. That pizza was so delicious, I still can't forget the taste of that Margherita. We were hungry and tired, but it tasted even better because of the staff's kindness in baking a fresh pizza just for us, for that one slice.

Since then, we've become regulars here and still order the Margherita pizza. And honestly, the pizza is truly delicious. It's not just because we feel grateful that we keep coming back.“

“Grab a bite and a glass of wine - relaxed atmosphere - great food - service is spot on. @lindaslist“

“Delicious pizza, loaded with fresh vegetables. Perfect thin crust. Each largw slice is a meal.“

“Margarita Pizza was delicious. Will definitely be back to try some more adventurous styles.“

“I saw this restaurant on uber eats about a year ago. I have ordered from this restaurant several times at work via uber eats or door dash. Additionally, I realized a few months later that your restaurant is less than 5 min from where I live. I continually order and I refer this place to many people. Anytime I call the order in and have to pick it up, the service is great.
Today I ate inside for the first time and as always the food was delicious. Our waiter, Don was fantastic!
I will continue to order from here and I will refer the restaurant to others!!“

“Loved this place! So good, very authentic“

“Thank you for doing the right thing!“

“The best pizza in Bergen County!“

“Super Nice Pizza NYC – Upper West Side Gem 🍕✨

Tucked away near Columbia University and Morningside Heights, Super Nice Pizza is a cozy sit-down spot that truly lives up to its name. The atmosphere is warm and inviting, with a great mix of locals and students — the kind of place where you can relax over a glass of wine and linger in good company.

Their drink selection was surprisingly impressive — from carefully curated wines to creative cocktails and even zero-proof options for those skipping alcohol.

The pizzas were the undeniable highlight: perfectly balanced crust, cheese, and toppings. Every bite was flavorful, light yet indulgent — definitely not your ordinary NYC pizza joint.

We also tried the salad, which was crisp and fresh, and the steak, cooked to a perfect medium, served with a generous side of fries and onion rings. And just when we thought we couldn’t eat any more, we ended the night with a huge slice of tiramisu — the perfect sweet finish.

Overall, Super Nice Pizza NYC combines quality food, cozy ambiance, and a welcoming vibe that makes it easy to say: we’re definitely coming back.“

“Really good food but please consider using real ham on the pizzas 🙏🏼 and not the mushy cubed stuff 😭 everything else is so good but this ham substitute stuff is always disappointing.“

“12/10!!! Great place! Awesome family owned restaurant and the pizza was amazing!! From Buffalo Ny!! We’ll be back !“

“good food, reasonable prices. What more could you ask for?“

“The pizza is first class! The crust is perfect! It snaps instead of biting into a pillow of heavy dough. the sauce is just right, not tart where you’ll have instant heartburn & not sweet where it tastes like some garbage out of a jar! All their food is equally delicious! The restaurant is spotless & has a rustic beautiful welcoming look. The staff & owners are respectful, friendly & attentive! I highly recommend this establishment!“

“Rosario and his staff are the best! Consistently great food and service!! Always smile , a joke and a great meal!! Maywood needed this place!!!“

“Perfect crust. Perfect pie. Sauce just right!“

“Margarita Pizza was delicious. Will definitely be back to try some more adventurous styles.“

“By far our favorite restaurant we visit in the city. Have been here over 500x and the tagliatelle with sheep’s cheese cabbage and shrimp will never get old ! Carmine runs a beautiful establishment on the UWS“

“The service was quick and friendly, and the pizza came out hot and fresh. The portion sizes are generous, and the price is very reasonable for the quality you get. Definitely one of the best pizza spots I’ve tried – I’ll be coming back again and again!“

“Always delicious pizza and the sauce is amazing. I usually order the personal round and personal square enough for my family. Love the Dad n Son great people and always have amazing conversations. I highly recommend this place. My cousins a professional Italian Chef making his own and he loves the pizza there.“

“Best pizza in NYC! And their fried calzones are a must 😊“

“Classic spot with hard working prideful staff and very good pizza—just remember to bring cash. Conveniently located right off the highway, with outdoor seating that’s perfect when the weather’s nice.
At first glance, the place might look a little run-down, but that’s part of its charm. Once you step inside, you can feel the history, and it carries a kind of legendary aura that takes you back in time to better days.“

“My husband and I was craving some good authentic pizza and let me just say this place DID NOT disappoint. The owner and everyone that worked there was super nice which made me love it even more. I wanted my husband who’s from Baltimore to try zeppole, he’s never heard of it and for me, growing up in Bk and Staten Island it was one of my childhood favs. They didn’t have any made when I asked about it which was fine but while I was in conversation with their delivery driver the owner came out with some. He actually went out of his way to make me some zeppole, and it was delicious and extremely nostalgic for me. He has no idea how that made my day and brought back so many memories to me. Their food is delicious, atmosphere warm and friendly. I recommend this place and we will be back.“

“This is the pizza I’ve been searching for my whole life.“

“The best pizza and friendliest staff!!!“

“The request was find the best pizza near our hotel. After comparing some reviews we headed to Urban Tomato. It’s in a neighborhood setting across from a church. The restaurant decor is simple but comfortable with a great hosts. We never felt cramped. The boys enjoyed a chicken pizza half garlic and half bbq drizzle and my wife and I enjoyed a fungi white pizza that was out of this world. I continue to say this, if g-d had given Jersey the water, their pizza would be king.“

“The 🍅 sause is the 🔑 key Eggplant Mozz. Chicken Mozz Both the 💣“

“This place gives off that run-down beat up pizza joint vibe, but it’s actually pretty solid. The pizza’s definitely way too greasy, but it's good. Prices for slices are overpriced but prices for pies are very fair. Being open late is a huge plus in this area. Far from the best pizza around, but it’s one of those spots you end up going back to anyway. sometimes the staff is in a great mood and helpful and sometimes they look cooked. You know what ur getting into when you walk in.“

“The food is delicious the staff is amazing“

“Good Pizza Great service Good Beer“

“I actually dined at Kyria two nights in a row (Thursday and Friday evenings). The food is outstanding/fabulous; the decor is lovely - chic and elegant without being too dressy. The servers both evenings were very attentive and helpful. The noise level on Friday (as expected) was louder than I'd have preferred... as it was a bit difficult to hear the person across the table for two at which we dined. (Thursday evening was a pleasure in terms of accoustics.). Kyria is a restaurant that is not to be missed.... and is certainly one to visit frequently.“

“Delicious food“

“Our server, Natalie was so nice and cheerful served us with a smile and the food was delicious. We have a margarita pizza to start and it was the best go on a pizza decide the best place I’ve ever had.! Portobello meals were delicious as well. I recommend this place to everybody! What?“

“Qui ho mangiato la pizza con le melanzana più buona della mia vita!!“

“It’s great place with very delicious pasta and artesanal pizza! 🍝🍕“

“I have always prided myself as a loyal patron to local business. This also includes my favorite pizzeria. But today, I just needed to try something new. And I'll tell you what!!! Amazing Pizza!!!! I got 2 slices of sausage and peppers, can't remember last time I enjoyed sitting this long for food. --MJ“

“I am from West New York my whole life and I can honestly say this pizzeria has exceeded my expectations. The food is always fresh and flavorful leaving you longing for more. From the pizza to the entrees and everything in between, the flavor is hard to compete with. I always feel welcome and appreciated when I walk in or order for delivery. I highly recommend West New York Pizza to anyone looking for quality!“

“Huge slices! so good! delicious!! We ❤️🍕🫶🏼👍🏼“

“***** The best Caesar salad.“

“My son has food allergies and as soon as we started inquiring about ingredients, the associate called for their designated allergy handler. Before we even got into his specific allergies, she wiped down the prep area, changed her gloves and showed us their allergy binder. She prepped everything right in front of us and chose ingredients from under the counter as to avoid cross contamination. Bravo, Jiya! When casually talking with the owner, he mentioned having friends with food allergies so he definitely understood the severity of being diligent with prep. We were so impressed by the process, we ate here twice on our trip. And yes - the pizza was quite delicious!“

“So…this is an Upper West Side 5 star. The plain slice (the tone setter) is a brooklyn 3 star. The specialty slices were good. They focus on thin crust…which I like. The atmosphere is a 5 star, you can comfortably order some slices and have a seat…not intimidating or tight. I live on the UWS so I will be returning to try more of the specialty slices, the Sicilian looked good but it came out after I ate.“

“Came all the way from Brooklyn to go to the Bronx Zoo and found this amazing restaurant to go to afterwards. The ambiance is chic, rustic and cozy. The food is absolutely delicious. The fried calamari was perfectly fried, the lobster ravioli was soooo yummy, and I enjoyed the pepperoni hot honey pizza as well. Everyone in my party enjoyed their food. My passion fruit margarita was really good too, as were the espresso martini, cheesecake and pistachio ice cream. I highly recommend this hidden gem and will definitely return next time I’m in the area.“

“Drove an hour and a half to take my Mom to lunch, and we loved the food here! The service was outstanding too! Highly recommend this place!“

“One of the best pizzas I’ve ever had! Never tried the tomato pie until here and fell in love with it.“

“Want the best pizza in all of New York City. Sorry to break it to you but it won’t be downtown. This place is a gem in Inwood and hopefully will be here for generations to come! Def must check it out if you’re ever In the city.“

“First time going in tonight I was feigning for pizza all day needed a good place this place was only 3 minutes away from me first time ever ordering and I love the pizza loved the pizza guy which I’m sure is the owner the young beautiful lady at the counter is also great! I appreciate the amazing services the best part walking inside that place made me feel like I was back in the 80s & 90s will definitely go again

Donnie from Summit Ave“

“The pizza here is unbelievable. I've had the pizza from this place 2x now and the second time proves the first time wasn't a fluke. The Grandmas pie is absolutely worth the money. Crispy, thin and tons of flavor. Usually Grandmas is so dry and tasteless. This is fantastic. The hot vodka pepperoni pizza was also perfect. Super friendly when I got the pie. If you like crisp and thin pizza this is the place to go. Haven't eaten there yet but looks like it's been nicely renovated. Can't wait to try some of there other items besides the pizza, but it's tough once you have the pizza to want anything else.“

“the food is phenomenal and the decor transports you out of the Bronx“

“I'm still dreaming about my experience at The Mountain House! Their tasting menu is delicious, with many options for each course that will satisfy any appetite. The chicken was cooked to perfection and the venison was the best tasting venison to exist. The fig panna cotta and pistachio cake were so rich and delicious, my taste buds will still bursting well after dinner was over. The views of the redwoods were a beautiful touch to the ambiance that made dinner even more magical.“

“Amazing food and excellent service! Everything is always delicious!! Pizzetiello is now one of our family dinner go-to spots when dining out.“

“Great people make great pizza!“