The Better Bagel

Bagels, Sandwich Shop

45 Merrick Rd, Amityville
(631) 608-4831


Take-Out/Delivery Options


Reviews for The Better Bagel

Absolutely love this place—no joke there is absolutely no better bagel (pun intended) than them. Sure, sometimes there’s a line but there’s a reason for that! I stop in often and they always have the bagel I’m looking for, and the staff is super friendly.

I was visiting from Florida and had to stop by a couple times. They're the best bagels and everyone was so nice. I love the breakfast sandwiches. We even took 20 bagels home in a suitcase to freeze so we can have their bagels at home. If they would ship then I'm be a lifelong customer.

Was running errands in the area and needed a quick bite so I decided to try The Better Bagel. It looked quite popular with lots of people waiting but the line moved fast. I got a fried egg and cheese on an everything flat. The bagel itself was delicious - it was crunchy on the outside with lots of delicious seeds. Very good. I wish the cheese melted Was melted with the eggs but it's not a deal breaker. The everything bagel with veggie cream she was also good. But what sealed full review

More Reviews(87)


Monday 6AM - 4PM
Tuesday 6AM - 4PM
Wednesday 6AM - 4PM
Thursday 6AM - 4PM
Friday 6AM - 4PM
Saturday 6AM - 4PM
Sunday 6AM - 2:30PM

Hours or services may differ due to COVID-19. Please contact the business directly to verify hours and availability.