The Better Bagel

$ • Bagels, Sandwich Shops

45 Merrick Rd, Amityville
(631) 608-4831


Take-Out/Delivery Options


Reviews for The Better Bagel

I’ve been coming pretty regularly recently, probably 2-3 times a week if not more. The food quality is very good. My problem is their ability to accurately follow mobile orders. There hasn’t been a single order in the last 10 orders that hasn’t had something majorly wrong despite various attempts at making accurate instructions. How hard is it to understand that selecting “bacon, egg, and cheese“, checking off “extra meat”, and writing in the note box; make full review

The food is excellent. However, I've had to ask the employees to change/put on gloves plenty of times prior to handling food. The employees handle money and food with the same gloves, or don't put gloves on altogether. Although I did bring this to the owner's attention - he brushed it off as these employees are "new". I've seen these individuals work here for months.

Horrible service today when I tried to get two bagels durning a non busy time. First the woman grabbed the wrong bags then she doesn't toast it. Angrily talkin to herself the whole time. Borja Nd raised eating bagels every Sunday on Long Island and this was by far the WORST service I have ever had. Had to go somewhere else. ‍

More Reviews(106)


Monday 6AM - 4PM
Tuesday 6AM - 4PM
Wednesday 6AM - 4PM
Thursday 6AM - 4PM
Friday 6AM - 4PM
Saturday 6AM - 4PM
Sunday 6AM - 2:30PM

Hours or services may differ due to COVID-19. Please contact the business directly to verify hours and availability.