13 Best Bakeries near Baiting Hollow

Sugar Sweet Treats Bakery • $$
4603 Middle Country Rd, Baiting Hollow

“Exceptional Bakery! Delicious cakes and cookies! Wonderful Service! Great People! They went out of their way for my brother’s birthday and made his day! He loves his cake and cookies!!! Thank you.“

4.5 Superb15 Reviews
Pride Enjoy Bakery • $
6302 Rte 25A Suite 2 Building C, Wading River - 5.77 miles

Customers` Favorites

Doughnut

“The best vegan/gluten-free desserts I've ever had! Thank you for existing!“

5 Superb46 Reviews
Mexican bakery pan pan bakery Bakery • $
145c Middle Country Rd, Ridge - 6.92 miles

Customers` Favorites

Carne Enchilada
Street Tacos
Chilaquiles
Croissant
Al Pastor
Lengua

“I got the rellenos de manzana, rellenos de guava, rellinos de guava, and vanilla cake (pardon my spelling). So tasty and moist. The taste of the pastry just makes you want to keep eating it! The man who works there/owns it answered all of my questions. He was super friendly and I’ll be back every time I go to the vet next door. I can’t wait to try the food next. The restaurant is clean and I’d eat inside if I had time.“

4.9 Superb22 Reviews
Sweet Dream Bakery Bakery • $$
1227 Wading River Manor Rd, Wading River - 6.24 miles

Customers` Favorites

Birthday Cake
Cupcake

“Beautiful cakes and they taste yummy!“

5 Superb12 Reviews
Celeste Bakery Bakery • $
857-863 Old Country Rd, Riverhead - 4.44 miles

Customers` Favorites

Birthday Cake

“When I tell you this is the BEST bakery around I mean it!! I always have them make my kids birthday cakes and they are a major hit! 10 out of 10 recommend!!“

4.2 Good39 Reviews
Cinnabon Bakery • $
1320 Tanger Mall Dr, Riverhead - 3.57 miles

Customers` Favorites

Cinnamon Roll
3.9 Good7 Reviews
Auntie Anne's Pretzel Store • $
200 Tanger Mall Dr, Riverhead - 3.95 miles
3 Average2 Reviews
Briermere Farms Bakery • $$
4414 Sound Ave, Riverhead - 4.28 miles

“These pies are the best! Especially the blueberry cream. I get requests from guests every year for it! Also their frozen fruit pies are delicious. They cook perfectly from frozen. I actually had one in my freezer for over a year and when I noticed it I figured I would bake it and see how it turned out. Not expecting it to still be good over a year later. WELL, it was just as delicious as if I got it and baked it from the farm that day!“

4.4 Superb180 Reviews
Sheila's Sweet Shoppe Bakery •
127 North St, Manorville - 8.04 miles

Customers` Favorites

Pie

“Took my vegan sister there and and found there were things for her and I with a gluten intolerance. Plus we picked up a banana bread for her husband who couldn't stop talking about it. Both my b-in-law and his son really enjoyed the candy apples!!! Great desserts...heading back there this weekend. YUM!“

5 Superb11 Reviews
Dari-Land Ice Cream Shop • $
51 Main Rd, Riverhead - 5.34 miles

Customers` Favorites

Chocolate Vanilla Ice Cream
Chocolate Fudge Brownie
Black Cherry Ice Cream
Banana Split

“I recommend Dari-land ice cream to everyone! The owner is such an amazing person who goes out of his way for customers! He went out of his way for me and I wish I could for him! Not only is his ice cream great but I want everyone to go to his store! Thank you Dari-land ice cream owner!“

4.4 Superb58 Reviews
Hampton Coffee Company Coffee Shops • $
272 Main Rd, Aquebogue - 5.67 miles

Customers` Favorites

Sour Cream Walnut Coffee Cake
Coffee and a Cranberry Muffin
A Cup of Coffee and a Scone
Coconut Almond Macaroon
Chocolate Chunk Cookie
Hazelnut Iced Coffee
Marshmallow Square
Chocolate Croissant
Pecan Raisin Scone
Mocha Freeze

“It was our first time going there .Water Mill location the Mexican chilaquiles are the BEST! I ask to meet the lady who cooked the chilaquiles to say Thank you for those delicious chilaquiles!! 😀😇 Her name is Yolanda . She is awesome and very sweet lady.“

4.4 Superb44 Reviews
Antigua Cafe Restaurant Bar Bakery • $$
309 E Main St, Riverhead - 5.55 miles

Customers` Favorites

Colombian Hot Dog
Colombian Burger
Sandwiches
Empanadas
Tostones
Nachos
Arepas
Tacos
Cuban

“I had a really good first meal at this cafe and as a foodie I can tell it’s really good. Then I read some comments below and noticed Some people just like to complain for the silliest things. People assume when you’re in a restaurant you just assume things everything is handed to you with just standing there. Obviously it’s a self serve cafe, it doesn’t hurt to ask how to do business w them. I like going in and eating in places like these as it’s so easy to go in and out without having to wait. They serve great food here, and I was served fine and good, people just complain too much for silly things“

3.7 Good55 Reviews
For Goodness Cakes Co. Food Trucks •
2287 Sound Ave, Calverton - 1.08 miles

“Love this truck! Everything I have tried so far is great from the chocolate chip cookies to macarons to the Cinnamon buns & everything in between! Definitely recommend!“

4.7 Superb12 Reviews