36 Best Bakeries near East Haven

“Always beautifully decorated and delicious. We tried the cannoli cheesecake this year for my daughter’s birthday and it was awesome.“

“I love the how to shoppes they are so much fun!! Noone beats the taste and price. Always very fresh!! Cant wait to come back' which will probably be tomorrow! lol“

“a pues la verdad sus comidas son muy sabrosas y la atención es.muy buena son muy amables sigan así 👍👍“

“Angelica came through for me in a pinch. I only gave her a couple days notice for a cake I wanted to order for my sister’s 66th Birthday. Angelica, it was delicious and enjoyed by all!!! Angelica and her husband also delivered it to me in North Haven. The cake was an 8 inch 3 tier marble cake with chocolate mousse filling and chocolate buttercream frosting. I definitely recommend, Thanks again Angelica!!!“

“I highly recommend Jennifer's Ice Cream! Not only do they have a large selection of tasty ice creams, but they also have dairy-free Italian Ice for me! Look no further if you're after a yummy treat with a reasonable price tag!“

“The food was tasty and fairly priced. Lots of original recipes and overall lots of healthy options. I highly recommend getting takeout from here. You can dine in but most staff don’t speak English (Spanish only) which wasn’t my case. They had a soccer match playing on screen which was entertaining but a bit too loud“

“omg, I love your "pudding pies" I don't know how to spell the name you call them when I lived in Norwich we would always go for a ride to New Haven and get them !!! my brother still goes when he's in New Haven can't resist !!! Best Bakery“

“My family and I absolutely love this Crumbl location in North Haven! The staff is consistently friendly, helpful, and patient, which makes every visit a great experience. The cookies are always fresh and delicious. Highly recommend this spot!“

“First time trying the cupcakes. Tried the pistachio. It was to die for. Will be stopping in more often“

“There choc- trilogy dessert is the best.Plus any of there breads.Great customer service every time“

“If you are driving the Merritt Parkway, this restaurant is a three minute drive just west of the tunnel at New Haven. A Borek is a sort of pizza popular across the Middle East and Israel with a fabulous layered thin crust with cheese or potato. Wow. This is way better than a pizza. They have a simple little seating area and will bring you warm Borek, three sauces and really really good coffee in a box so you can take the rest with You. Fun fact. Google and the rest of the large language models can *never*spell Borek. I have to correct the spelling every time.“

“My husband surprised me with a Princess cake. I mentioned I’d love to try one after seeing it in a baking show. He searched online and Marjolaine’s was the only place he could find. He drove over an hour to pick it up and it was well worth the drive! We just picked up a Dacquoise. This one was a request from our daughter. We tried a smaller version that was in the case. It was absolutely delicious! So light and airy and the flavor was divine! We are driving this cake all the way to NC and are 100% certain that our daughter will be thrilled ! We are heading back in the beginning of April for a Marjolaine for our daughter in law. It is well worth the trip!!!“

“Sweet Seidner's is one of my best discoveries. I'd driven past this bakeshop every week, thinking they just sold pre-ordered items. One morning I decided to stop in, and I've been visiting them almost every week ever since. Cookies, brownies, hamantaschen, cakes, bars--all equally delicious and taste authentically homemade. They are kind people, happy to bake special requests and appreciative of their customers. 5++ stars!“

“Sweet Mary's had an amazing selection of cupcakes this morning despite being a holiday! Absolutely delicious and so beautiful! Special shout out to Mikaela for her help picking the perfect mix for my family! A+++++++“

“We hired JCakes to provide the cake for our wedding, which took place on June 20, 2026. Carly was the staff member who arranged a cake tasting for us and went over all the details for cake decorations. She really took the time to confirm what our vision was for decor overall and what we wanted for the wedding cake in particular. Shortly before the wedding, we updated the guest count and number of servings for the cake, which turned out to be much different than initially anticipated, and adjustments were made to our satisfaction. Our wedding reception venue ended up covering the cost of the cake as part of the banquet package (we were not aware of this detail when we booked them) and JCakes contacted us to refund our deposit. The cake was both beautiful and delectable, and we were very pleased with the service. Highly recommended.“

“I would like to share my recent experience at Saray Bakery. A couple of days ago I placed my order over the phone and went to pick up on Thursday. There was a mistake with my order and it wasn’t ready. The employees seemed very apoplectic and told me to please give them 15 minutes and they will fix it. Even tho I was really in a rush i decided to wait. The ladies at the counter were so hospitable that you couldn’t be mad at them. The offered me a free coffee and 2 cookies. One lady came over to apologize again and explained the situation while the other lady worked on my order. They make my order quickly and put in another free pastry to go. That was so nice! At the end it’s not the mistake that matters it’s how they handled it and how they made me feel! Thank you lovely ladies at Saray Bakery I will be back :)“

“I love their large variety of cakes, each one is so beautiful and delicious you want to buy them all!! The cookies are awesome. Pumpkin Cheesecake was decadent! 👍🏻“

“Great place. Donuts are always good and fresh.“

“Milani's did cookie boxes for my daughter's communion. Such beautiful presentations.“

“We ordered two cakes from Sweets on Main to celebrate our daughter’s birthday. Not only was the owner so nice, pick up was a breeze and the cakes were delicious. No pic of the GF chocolate cake but there was not a piece leftover. The strawberry mascarpone was light and refreshing - perfect for our one year old who we don’t want having a lot of sugar. Will definitely be using Sweets on Main again!“

“Cute little coffeeshop with very good coffee“

“Great wait staff Food was delish“

“I moved 4 years ago, but I know it’s still THE BEST! I started coming her at 16 every Friday to get bread. I’m 51. Meet the family and find out how good they are! You won’t be disappointed.

Dietary restrictions: Always“

“I enjoy the authentic Guatemalan coffee, the bread, they go great with my coffee. Enjoy Authentic Guatemalan tamales, reminds me of when my grandmother made them, the chuchitos, they are like mini corn tamales and great with coffee too. Definitely recommend if you are looking for authentic Guatemalan food. They also sell beautiful souvenirs.“

“Jaw dropping selection of fresh dried medicinals. There is nothing like this near me in PA. Family owned. 💜“

“So I went over a friends house for dinner and he had a Lupi's Bread on the table, Looked great. Tasted better. He told me about this little bakery in New Haven at 169 Washington Ave Lupi's Marchigiano Bakery. I went the next day for another Bread where I met Larry Lupi a true gentleman. His grandfather started the Bakery in 1900 when he came over from Italy, and now is being run by Larry and his brother Peter. So If you want to taste a little piece of heaven, stop by Lupi's and for a few bucks you can.
Thanks Larry and Pete,
Vinny“

“We had our wedding tasting here. So delicious!!“

“Incredible coffee and pastries!“

“Ricotta's catering service is wonderful! We are from out of state and were organizing a Shiva lunch for family living near New Haven. Given that we only had a day to plan, time was very tight and we didn't know where to turn. Luckily, Ricotta's was recommended. Sarah was great - she was flexible, willing to deliver, arranged the food beautifully, and everything was delicious. Guests, in particular, loved the sushi, the pita sandwiches and the pastries. When visiting, we can't wait to eat at the restaurant and to hopefully use the catering service for a happier event. We highly recommend them!“

“Getting to the location is a bit tricky because the bridges are very low and the GPS won't give you the correct route. Try to follow this same route for both entering and leaving. The streets are narrow, so you need to swing wide; check the photo to understand the route.“

“Great wait staff Food was delish“

“I got a cake from here 2 years and it was exactly what I wanted (the heart cake). My husband loved the taste and kept mentioning it when it got closer to his birthday this year so I, of course, had to get another one. It was AMAZING! Everyone loved it and a few said it was the best cake they’d ever had. Yellow cake with cheesecake filling and buttercream- highly recommend. Steve was also great with communicating and working through my indecisiveness about the design.“

“(Translated by Google) The cakes are good, everything that Lupita Baker sells is tasty, jealousy, I recommend many thanks to all, good day(Original)Están buenos los pasteles todo lo que vende lupita Baker esta sabroso de betdad celos recomiendo munchas grasias atodos buen dia“

“My Lord! What a place. I’ve tried many of the major contenders in the bakery world, including Lucibello’s and Libby’s, and Cheri’s blows them out of the water.

The taste and texture are absolutely phenomenal, and the prices are more than fair. The quality is outstanding, and honestly, I’d happily pay twice as much (but don’t tell them that!).

If you’re looking for an incredible bakery, Cheri’s is it!“

“We stopped in for some stuffed breads and tried some italian pastry.They where all excellant and be back for sure.“

“Our absolute favorite place! Never had a bad meal. Service is excellent!!“