10 Best Caribbean Restaurants in Baldwin

“My Family and I just finished having a late lunch here. The food was sooooo good and the service was great, we appreciate the staff accommodating our large party in such a short notice. The vibe was super chill and Pops was dope, came thru with a few samples 🙏🏾 Thanks again, we will be back next time we are in NYC.“

“TinNel’s Patties in Baldwin is an absolute must! Their patties are consistently fresh, flavorful, and perfectly spiced. The girls working there are always sweet and friendly. A must-try for anyone craving authentic and delicious Jamaican patties. Highly recommend!“

“Comfortable atmosphere, good drinks, good food“

“My fiance got us dinner today & I must say it taste very great. We have been looking for a good Jamaican restaurant for some time now. Every cook has slight dif flavor and you can always taste the dif in food. The food was healthy & the overall service provided was very respectful. We also felt full and great after our meal! Looking forward to coming again :)“

“Ok so I ordered shark and bake and 2 order of doubles. They were very unorganized and the men acted like they didn’t wanna work! But this young lady! She gave us communication, told us its gonna be a wait that she had to handmade everything! She literally handmade the bakes from scratch! Fried the shark! Handmade the doubles! I seen her cook my food as i sat watched and ate my doubles waiting for the sandwich! I appreciate that young lady. The food was so good! She’s the ONLY reason why i would ho back there!! If she’s not there whenever i go i turn right around!“

“Best tasting Caribbean Food !!!! ?“

“I’ve just had my third meal at Tony Mac’s in as many days, and again I was not disappointed!??? For lunch I had the curry goat which comes well-seasoned with rice and peas, steamed veggies and plantain. To drink I had a number 5 Sea Moss drink called “The Mac Body Heat” to wake up the body made of - Sea Moss, wheat germ, oats, peanuts, pumpkin seeds, roots and something called tigerbone! ???The waitress noted to me on the way out “Look after your wife tonight, the next day you might be getting a welcome visitor from the Creator!Great meal and the medium was mighty big for the money -$25 for the meal and drink! Highly recommended for great food, Garnett Silk music while you wait and the baby maker shake!!!!?????????Honey I’m home!????“

“We are multiple returning customers. The food is 10/10. We have tried the Jerk Chicken, rice and peas, cabbage, plantains, Rasta pasta, BBQ ribs, Jerk Pork, Red Bean Beef Soup, BBq Salmon. Ask for a side of Jerk sauce. Everything has a lot of flavor and very fresh. The customer service has been outstanding every time. We really appreciate the service. Even when it was busy, I noticed the chef stepped in and personally served us. We appreciated the good service and the restaurant was very clean. This place deserves a 5 star rating 100%%. You can clearly see the food is very fresh.“

“sweet sauce with jerk chicken good rice n beans good as well“

“Pizza, deli... ah what the heck.. let me try Jamaican.. I love spicy food.. walked into rock and come in. Seemed closed but staff was preping. Jerk chicken or curry roti?? Roti it is.. and I am glad I did.. warm ,tender, juicy and delicious. Don't forget a kola champange. I will be back..FYI didn't waste any food all I'm my tummy“