New American Restaurants near Bay Shore, NY

Lakehouse New American • $$$
135 Maple Ave, Bay Shore

Customers` Favorites

Crisp Long Island Duck Breast and Crisp Leg Confit
Herb-Marinated East Coast Striped Bass Filet
Grilled Marinated Skirt Steak & Herb Frites
Lake House Flourless Chocolate Cake
Oysters and Clams on the Half Shell
Fricassée of Peconic Bay Scallops
1 1 4 lb Lobster Roll with Fries
Lake House Butcher Blend Burger
Poached Colossal Shrimp Cocktail
The Lakehouse Vegetable Salad

“I recently had dinner at The Lake House and it was fantastic from start to finish. The atmosphere is warm, inviting, and perfectly matches its beautiful lakeside setting — it’s the kind of place where you immediately feel relaxed.

The food was outstanding — everything tasted fresh and was beautifully presented. You can really tell the chefs take pride in what they do. Our server was friendly, attentive, and made sure we had everything we needed without ever feeling rushed.

It’s rare to find a restaurant that combines great food, amazing service, and a view like that all in one place. Whether you’re going for a special occasion or just a nice night out, The Lake House is definitely worth the visit. I’ll absolutely be coming back!“

4.4 Superb289 Reviews
Whalers New American • $$$
124 Maple Ave, Bay Shore

Customers` Favorites

Korean Double Fried Chicken Wings
Sweet Chili Glazed Calamari
New England Clam Chowder
Whalers French Fries
Korean Lettuce Wraps
Pan Seared Scallops
Coconut Crusted Cod
Seafood Ceviche
Seafood Risotto
Lump Crab Cake

“Love John the bartender. Great food and atmosphere“

4.3 Superb309 Reviews
3

Zest

Zest American • $$
298 W Main St, Bay Shore

Customers` Favorites

Grilled Skirt Steak on Mashed Potatoes with Gorgonzola
PB and J Pulled Pork Sandwich
Loaded Grilled Cheese Pretzel
Buffalo and BBQ Smoked Wings
Pulled Pork Potato Skins
Cauliflower Crust Chips
Smoked BBQ Pulled Pork
Smoked Brisket Poutine
Thai PB & J Sandwich
Crispy Smoked Wings

“I just had another amazing lunch at Zest. The portions are VERY generous and the food is always amazing. The chef is a culinary artist.“

4.7 Superb158 Reviews
Goldy's Gems Bar • $$
5 Third Ave, Bay Shore

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Sandwich
Cupcake

“Been here a couple of times. Once on a date night Thursday with my wife, another time for birthday party on a Saturday night with DJ C Natryl. He created a sick vibe. Can't wait to come back to hear him play again!! Nice little room that really is a gem. :)“

4.7 Superb37 Reviews
Sweet Jane Cocktail Bar • $$
64 E Main St, Bay Shore

Customers` Favorites

Duck Merguez
Chefs Board
Date Cake
Rye Tai

“Thank you Gabby and Anthony for being the best service oriented hosts. Great drinks and comversation.“

4.5 Superb84 Reviews
Tula Kitchen Fine Dining • $$$
41 E Main St, Bay Shore

Customers` Favorites

Peanut Butter Chocolate Chip Sandwich
Mediterranean Platter
Vegan Tofu Crab Cakes
Rockin Vegan Cupcake
Mediterranean Spread
Sesame Crusted Tuna
Tuna and Asparagus
Roasted Asparagus
The Mediterranean
Tula Greek Bowl

“Delicious cocktails and food! We all had a difficult time deciding on a meal, everything sound so good! Friendly helpful staff, would totally recommend!“

4.4 Superb87 Reviews
Salt & Barrel Seafood • $$$
61 W Main St, Bay Shore

Customers` Favorites

Chocolate Chip Cookie Skillet with Vanilla Gelato
Raw Oysters on the Half Shell
Bigeye Tuna Tartare Avocado
New England Clam Chowder
Clams \u0026 Bone Marrow
Charred Baby Octopus
Crab Cake Benedict
Day Boat Scallops
Warm Lobster Roll
Tarragon Biscuits

“My Husband and I stumble across this place tonight and couldn’t be happier about it! From the moment we walked through the door on a busy Saturday night at 7:00pm we walk in simply based on a great name! The hostess Deanna was lovely and welcoming we were able to sit right away! The food was absolutely amazing and so were the drinks!! But the star of the show was the staff our waitress Emily was the best we have ever had! Just the right amount of attentive that we never looked for her and always felt taking care up. The busser also did an amazing job never a dirty plate on our table. We go out alot and I can’t remember the last time a restaurant covered it all flawlessly Service drinks and food. We have already texted friend excited to bring them here! Can’t wait to come back keep up the amazing work!“

4.3 Superb173 Reviews
Napper Tandy’s Irish Pub • $$
60 E Main St, Bay Shore

Customers` Favorites

Turkey Burger and Fries
Key West Fish Sandwich
Traditional Reuben
Warm Jumbo Pretzel
Chicken Sandwich
Taco Salad
Avocado
Chips

“Large bar, big place, lots of tv’s, great space upstairs for private events, cold 🍺 and great food = good times 💫“

4.2 Good85 Reviews
9

Mito

Mito Japanese • $$$
48 Deer Pk Ave, Babylon - 4.51 miles

Customers` Favorites

Brisket Hot Plate and Hot Mama Roll
Sea Bass Chef Special Roll
Mongolian Beef
Seafood Bisque
Fried Ice Cream
Fried Banana
Jumbo Shrimp
Rock Shrimp
Miso Soup
Sashimi

“Lovely atmosphere, delicious and generous portions, and quality service“

4 Good175 Reviews
Pace's Steak House Steak House
325 Smithtown Bypass, Hauppauge - 7.39 miles

Customers` Favorites

Filet Mignon and Lobster Tail
Pace's Seafood Platter
Salad with Blue Cheese
Peanut Butter Brownie
Lobster Tails Tempura
Pappardelle Bolognese
Jackson's Mac & Cheese
Double Cut Pork Chop
New York Shell Steak
Petite Filet Mignon

“….….Best place on earth………“

4.5 Superb191 Reviews
Restoration Kitchen & Cocktails American • $$
49 E Hoffman Ave, Lindenhurst - 7.11 miles

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Bacon Avocado Quesadilla
Buffalo Chicken Quesadilla
Stuffed Bleu Cheese Burger
Crispy Buffalo Cauliflower
Sautéed Brussel Sprouts
Chicken Avocado Sandwich
Skirt Steak Quesadilla
Pulled Pork Quesadilla
Spinach Artichoke Dip
Beer Cheese Pretzel

“Great mixologists! A real treat.“

4.6 Superb94 Reviews
Oakdale Brew House American • $$
927a Montauk Hwy, Oakdale - 6.67 miles

Customers` Favorites

Smokehouse Burgerand Onion Rings
Chicken Fingers and Fries
Burnt Brussel Sprout Pizza
Nashville Chicken Sliders
Butternut Squash Ravioli
Short Rib Grilled Cheese
Giant Bavarian Pretzel
Side of Truffle Fries
Pan Seared Salmon
The Brunch Burger

“I want to start by saying the buffalo chicken egg rolls are the best and I mean THE BEST Buffalo chicken egg rolls I have ever had. I got garlic parm wings as my main and they were also delicious. Came on a weekend and it was very busy with live music so make reservations!“

4.6 Superb87 Reviews
Argyle Grill & Tavern American • $$
90 Deer Pk Ave, Babylon - 4.48 miles

Customers` Favorites

Bread Pudding with Vanilla Bean Ice Cream
Argyle Marinated Grilled Skirt Steak
Spinach and Artichoke Dip
Marinated Steak Sandwich
Coconut Crusted Shrimp
Brie Stuffed Pretzel
Vanilla French Toast
Sliced Sirloin Steak
Babylon Clam Chowder
Argyle Prime Burger

“5/5 stars! We had an awesome experience at this place! Amazing food & cute yummy cocktails! This is my new go to spot!“

4.5 Superb149 Reviews
Aji 53 Services Japanese • $$
1 Miller Pl, Smithtown - 9.44 miles

Customers` Favorites

Dragon Roll \u0026 Boston Roll
Sushi & Sashimi Lunch Platter
Sushi and Sashimi Platter
Dragon Roll & Boston Roll
Yellowtail with Jalapeno
Rock Shrimp Tempura
Tuna Avocado Salad
Christmas Roll
California Roll
Seaweed Salad

“EXCELLENT FOOD & SERVICE!“

4.7 Superb53 Reviews
Husk and Vine Kitchen and Cocktails American • $$$
655 Middle Country Rd, St James - 10.49 miles

Customers` Favorites

Tempura Bang Bang Shrimp Street Noodle Bowl
Pan Seared Niman Ranch Filet Mignon Tidbits
Mediterranian Olive Hummus Appitizer
Asian Style Kobe Beef Meatballs
Bang Bang Shrimp and Noodle
Asian Style Kobe Meatballs
Vegetable Flatbread
Charcuterie Board
The Wagyu Burger
Brussels Sprouts

“Husk and Vine has been our go-to date night spot for years, so when it came time to plan my mother’s 70th birthday celebration, we knew exactly who to call—Chef Fran.
We wanted a Polynesian-themed menu, and if anyone could bring that vision to life, it was the Husk and Vine team. Chef Fran and his culinary staff are known for their creativity and fusion, and they absolutely delivered.

Chef took the time to listen to our ideas and dietary needs, crafting a menu that tied everything together beautifully. Our guests are still raving about how delicious everything was!

If you haven’t visited Husk and Vine yet, make sure you do. It’s truly a must-visit experience.“

4.5 Superb119 Reviews
Coco Bistro Kitchen & Lounge Cuban • $$$
944 W Jericho Turnpike, Smithtown - 8.48 miles

Customers` Favorites

Pork Shank with Arroz Con Gandules
Little Havana House Salad
Tapas Cuban Sandwich
Cuban Surf and Turf
Homemade Lava Cake
Skirt Steak Mofongo
Tres Leches Cake
Coconut Mussels
Petite Churrasco
Coconut Shrimp

“Great atmosphere, music, and amazing staff!! Food is really delicious! Would definitely come here again and again. 😊💕“

4.5 Superb116 Reviews
The Snapper Inn Seafood • $$$
500 Shore Dr, Oakdale - 5.04 miles

Customers` Favorites

Fried Calamari & Hot Cherry Peppers
Herb Seared Fresh Atlantic Salmon
Raw Oysters on the Half Shell
Shrimp and Scallop Scampi
Red Snapper over Risotto
Pan Seared Sea Scallops
Potato Encrusted Cod
Stuffed Lobster Tail
Chicken Francese
Shrimp Francaise

“The food is delicious in large portions, waitress is attentive and knowledgeable, very nice atmosphere.“

4.4 Superb175 Reviews
Jackson Hall American Bar & Grille American • $$
335 E Main St, East Islip - 3.66 miles

Customers` Favorites

Lobster Roll with Sweet Potatoe Fries
Chicken Panini Fries Coleslaw
Connecticut Lobster Roll
Long Island Lobster Roll
Bang Bang Shrimp Tacos
Chocolate Mousse Cake
Marinated Skirt Steak
Lobster Bisque Soup
Bavarian Pretzel
Mashed Potatoes

““The food is absolutely outstanding, the service is incredible, and Chef Mike is one of a kind. Do yourself a favor — if you’re in the area, stop in. You won’t be disappointed!!“

4.3 Superb276 Reviews
Island Mermaid American • $$
780 Bay Walk, Ocean Beach - 7.02 miles

Customers` Favorites

Steamed Prince Edward Island Mussels
Grilled Fried Flounder Sandwich
Charcuterie Board for Two
Teriyaki Atlantic Salmon
Scallops Potatoes Corn
Gourmet Burger
Lobster Rolls
Fish Taco
Quesadilla
Burgers

“We had a very nice meal here back in October. Our server, Shannon, was outstanding and took excellent care of us. The location is fantastic, sitting right on the water and made for a very pleasant meal. We had the calamari appetizer (very good), the Sauteed Flounder, which was okay and not worth $40, and the Gourmet Burger. I thoroughly enjoyed the burger. Since we came over on our boat, we weren't drinking, but the bar area looked pretty cool. We will come back again.“

4.2 Good47 Reviews
Prato 850 Gastropubs • $$
Mayfair Shopping Center, 204 Jericho Turnpike, Commack - 8.3 miles

Customers` Favorites

Eggplant Meatballs with Burrata
The Drunken Burrata Pizza
Short Rib Mac and Cheese
Classic Margherita Pizza
Wood Fired Bone-In Wings
Brick Oven Cheese Pizza
Giant Bavarian Pretzel
Skirt Steak Frites
Short Rib Burger
Chicken Wings

“Great consistent food. Priced very fairly. Great atmosphere. Enjoy seeing Todd O and Richie. It's like the 90s and Sprats. We are just missing Danny S.“

4.3 Superb96 Reviews
Flanagan's Pub Irish Pub • $$
451 Hawkins Ave, Lake Ronkonkoma - 10.01 miles

Customers` Favorites

Chicken Parmesan Flat Bread
Oysters on the Half Shell
Burrata Chicken Sandwich
Traditional Fish & Chips
Corned Beef and Cabbage
Bourbon Tempura Shrimp
Mozzarella Sticks
French Onion Soup
Flanagan's Nachos
Shepherd's Pie

“We have our family dinner there The food is good. Miranda our waitress always does a great job. Thank you !!!“

4.2 Good66 Reviews
22

CJ's

CJ's Bar & Grill • $$
479 Bay Ave, Ocean Beach - 7.02 miles

Customers` Favorites

Rocket Fuel

“Came here for Sunday of the holiday weekend. Great atmosphere and awesome service. There were two bartenders, both super friendly. The guy bartender was dressed in an awesome 4th costume, and made us the BEST rocket fuels. I would come again just for him. He made our experience amazing and was not only friendly but very accommodating. Come here!!!“

4.5 Superb6 Reviews
23

Gyro

Gyro Greek • $$
Dix Hills Rd, Huntington Station - 10.01 miles

“This family owned restaurant is worth the time and effort. Nothing fancy except good Greek food. We both eat in and take out The staff is so accommodating and friendly. Many times the owners wife and children are eating there. The grandfather works at the grill when not spending time with his grandkids Again, nothing fancy except for the food, the atmosphere and the people. Please go and enjoy home-cooking while eating out“

3.2 Average1 Reviews
The Villager Bar • $$
262 Deer Pk Ave, Babylon - 4.39 miles

Customers` Favorites

The Villager Burger and Sweet Potato Tots
Fire Island Slaw Burger
Park Ave Steak Sandwich
Bang Bang Shrimp
Bavarian Pretzel
Breakfast Burger
Chicken Wings
Gouda Fries
Tater Tots
Flatbread

“Great place to go very safe and friendly“

4.1 Good49 Reviews
Lion's Den Bar & Grill • $$
191 Higbie Ln, West Islip - 3.44 miles

“Had the best lunch today. Food was amazing but the server was even more amazing. Donna rocked it!!! I will be going back soon!“

3.9 Good10 Reviews
Chiddy's Cheesesteaks of West Islip Fast Food • $
510 Union Blvd, West Islip - 2.91 miles

Customers` Favorites

Build Your Own Cheesesteak
Beef and Cheddar Empanada
Chiddy's Mac N' Cheese
Homemade Empanadas
Sweet Potato Fries
Philly Cheese Steak
Mozzarella Sticks
Cheesesteak Fries
Fresh Cut Fries
Onion Rings

“Absolutely love their cheese steaks! Service was fast and with a smile....cheese throughout sandwich as it should be...ribeye steak grilled perfectly. Well done!“

4 Good48 Reviews
Bagel Express Breakfast • $
264 W Main St, Smithtown - 9.35 miles

Customers` Favorites

Eggs and Cheese

“I ordered online to pick up and my service dropped so I called back. The same gentleman answered and was very nice and patient, took my order and I forgot to ask for salt, pepper and ketchup on my egg sandwich and he kindly asked if I wanted to add it so kudos for the attention to detail. I arrived and parking is sufficient and it’s right off the main road so it’s easy to access. The Chinese lady greeted me at the counter and was genuinely nice and warm toned and asked if I was there for pick up. My breakfast was ready and she rung me up for $6 and offered me a free coffee which I declined. They sue take debit with a $5 minimum and they use a modern payment device so no pin is needed if you don’t mind that and paying is instant so no waiting on that end either, I was in and out in less then 3 min. The place had a decent amount of seating and was very clean and the customers seemed to be enjoying themselves. This place is a winner and sets the bar high for the other establishments in the area. I ordered an everything bagel with 2 fried eggs, sausage and pepper jack cheese (my only critique would be that they did put a very thin slice of cheese I would have liked to taste more of it) and it was delicious. Thanks again Bagel Express I will be back!!**** I wanted to mention I did NOT get napkins so not a big deal most places throw a few in the bag so I have been spoiled, just a note to management ****“

3.6 Good11 Reviews
Alletto's Restaurant Seafood • $$
218 E Montauk Hwy, Lindenhurst - 6.62 miles

Customers` Favorites

Filet Mignon and Lobster Tails
Free Hot Bread Dine in: Yes
Bread and Salad to Share
Linguine with Clam Sauce
Lobster Special for 2
Eggplant Parmigiana
Artichoke Sciliano
Shrimp Parmigiana
31b& Maine Lobster
Seafood Marinara

“Delish lobster!!! Also recommend the aging steak!!! Truly enjoyed our meal!!! Highly recommend giving this hidden gem a try! Prices are still good while everyone else's are ridiculously overpriced! ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️“

3.9 Good32 Reviews
Siu's Kitchen Chinese • $
3283 Sunrise Hwy North Service Rd, Islip Terrace - 4.1 miles

Customers` Favorites

Mix Wonton Egg Drop Soup
Sweet and Sour Chicken
Sweet and Sour Shrimp
Roast Pork Egg Roll 1
Chicken Wonton Soup
Plain Lobster Sauce
Chicken Rice Soup
Shrimp Toast

“Sui's is a solid choice for standard chinese- american food. As a spare ribs, broccoli and fried rice guy, I can say that Sui's does the 'regular' dishes aa well as pretty much anyone else - glad that they are my neighborhood chinese place.“

3.8 Good21 Reviews
Tres Palms New American • $$
16 East Ct, Babylon - 4.74 miles

Customers` Favorites

Painted Hills Marinated Skirt Steak
Pan Seared Lamb Chops
Lobster Nachos
Grilled Salmon
Cheeseburger
Sea Scallops
Bunger Burger
Lobster Roll
Tuna Tar Tar
Baked Clams

“Tres Palm is Tres Bon!! Random pick while looking at the map. Great location in the sun, on the water. Had the lobster roll and that Hawaiian burger. OMG!!“

3.5 Good203 Reviews
Chop Shop Bar and Grill Steak House • $$$
47 E Main St, Smithtown - 9.42 miles

Customers` Favorites

Slow Braised Lamb Shank
Crispy Fried Calamari
Sesame Seared Tuna
French Onion Soup
Gorgonzola Steak
Clams Oreganata
Stuffed Shrimp
Bone in Ribeye
Lobster Tail
Caesar Salad

“The chop shop is fancy and nice service.“

4 Good109 Reviews
Deli Big Boss Deli • $
Little E Neck Rd, West Babylon - 5.8 miles

Customers` Favorites

Carne Asada Con Tajadas
Quesadilla de Carne
Pollo Con Tajadas
Tacos Tostados

“There are breakfast sandwiches and then there are BREAKFAST SANDWICHES. I am so happy that I stopped by to try the breakfast here. The eggs weren't drooping with oil, bacon and sausage were cooked perfectly. The ladies were extremely friendly and welcoming. Ordered 4 sandwiches and everyone really enjoyed them. Prices are extremely reasonable and will be coming here more often.

Came recommended from Rob at Superstar and glad I listened.“

3.6 Good18 Reviews
33

BayVue

BayVue Lounges • $$$
854 S Wellwood Ave, Lindenhurst - 6.98 miles

Customers` Favorites

Shrimp Scampi over Linguini
Great Lobster Macaroni
Shrimp Fra Diavolo
California Roll
Cajun Salmon
Rocket Fuel
Lobster Roll
Poke Bowl
Wings
Sushi

“Absolutely wonderful! Came in for dinner last night (5/31) and had a great table right by the water. Even though it was very busy, our waitress Jenn was very attentive to the table and gave great recommendations on the menu. The crab bisque soup was excellent and the fish tacos were incredibly fresh tasting. For a first time visit, I was super impressed! I will definitely be back! Perhaps for lunch next time!!“

3.9 Good68 Reviews