16 Best Caterers near Bayville

Mill Creek Catering & Events Caterers • $$$
275 A Bayville Ave, Bayville

“Made a reservation here for restaurant week. Apparently didn't need one. The place has its own parking lot with about a dozen spots. We entered the building which took us into the bar, which was bustling. The dining room was quaint, with some really nice booths and a fireplace that should have been lit. Our server was a good looking young man, pleasant, not overbearing with a sense of humor. We opted to include an additional appetizer of baked clams to our meal, along with the crab cake and winter salad, which I forgot to take photos of. My friend opted for the lamb chops while I had the branzino piccata. Yummy, although the menu never stated that the fish was served over a shrimp risotto. (I'm allergic to shrimp). Only 1 bone in the fish, so I was lucky. Our dessert consisted of tiramisu and rainbow cookie cheesecake. I was "fortunate" to get the last piece although not very cheesecake-y. All in all we had a nice dinner and will maybe return for another meal.“

4.7 Superb81 Reviews
Schultzy's Restaurant Seafood • $$
265 Bayville Ave, Bayville

Customers` Favorites

Fresh North Shore Littleneck Clams Casino
Fresh North Shore Fire Roasted Oysters
Pan Seared Halibut with Spinach
Sesame Crusted Ahi Tuna
Homemade Lobster Bisque
Seared Tuna Special
Seafood Fra Diavolo
Calamari Arrabiata
Smashed Red Potato
Mac and Cheese

“Open for lunch! Google maps said closed, (found out later, website had corrrct hours!) but we stopped by anyway thankfully. Beautiful lunch menu. Perfect French onion soup, sandwiches, etc. Excellent service because down to earth, real, friendly. Shall I continue? Totally recommend.“

4.7 Superb71 Reviews
Waterfront Wedding Venue Long Island - Soundview Caterers Caterers • $$$
45 Bayville Ave, Bayville

“We got married 11/4/23 at Soundview and had such an amazing experience with Soundview. When beginning the venue search we knew we wanted a waterfront venue with an outdoor space for the ceremony and a suitable indoor option in case the weather didn't cooperate. We fell in love with the stunning indoor and outdoor views and the fact that they host one event at a time was also a MAJOR plus for us. During the wedding planning process, Brittany was easy to get in touch with, super organized, and quick to answer any questions I had. Our wedding day was absolutely perfect. Our guests are still raving about the food and talking about how beautiful the venue was. Diego made sure everything ran smoothly, and Taryn our bridal attendant went above and beyond helping out our photographers, and made sure my husband and I had cocktails. The entire Soundview staff went above and beyond to make sure our wedding day was spectacular and we can't recommend them enough“

4.5 Superb34 Reviews
Wildacre Rotisserie Chicken Shop • $
147 E Putnam Ave, Cos Cob - 8.98 miles

Customers` Favorites

Roti Potatoes Tray Serves
White Cheddar Mac Cheese
Quarter Chicken Meal
Slow-Roasted Chicken
Rotisserie Chicken
Roasted Brussels
Crispy Brussels
Herbed Chicken
Cucumber Salad
Pacifica Salad

“This place is a gem in Cos Cob. Everything is delicious and it's very gluten-free and dairy-free friendly for my dietary needs. My go-to's are the quarter chicken meal with brussel sprouts, creamy tahini sauce, and the fries. Dare I say, best brussel sprouts I've ever had. The sauce is divine!Vegetarian options: There are some vegetarian options in the form of sides, salads and wraps.Dietary restrictions: Menu items are clearly labeled for gluten-free and vegan options.“

4.7 Superb86 Reviews
Metropolitan Caterers Caterers • $$$
3 Pratt Blvd, Glen Cove - 4.83 miles

“I recently hosted my Son 1st birthday party at Metropolitan Caterer’s , and I couldn't have been more pleased with the experience. The party hall itself was spacious and elegantly decorated, creating a festive and welcoming atmosphere for all our guests.The highlight of the evening was the impressive lighting and sound system that really set the mood for the celebration. The dance floor was perfect for our teenage guests to show off their moves, and the seating arrangements were comfortable and stylish.Throughout the planning process, the staff at Metropolitan Caterer’s were incredibly helpful and accommodating. They were responsive to all our inquiries and went above and beyond to ensure that every detail was taken care of. The catering service they provided was outstanding, with a diverse menu that satisfied all our guests' tastes.Our guests were also impressed with the party hall, with many commenting on the beautiful decor and the top-notch service they received. It was heartwarming to hear so many positive feedback from our friends and family.Overall, I highly recommend Metropolitan Caterer’s for anyone looking to host a memorable event. The experience was stress-free, enjoyable, and truly exceeded my expectations. Thank you, Metropolitan Caterer’s, for helping us create unforgettable memories for my Son special day!"“

4.9 Superb48 Reviews
Swan Club On The Harbor Caterers • $$$
90 Glenwood Rd, Roslyn - 7.35 miles

“My wedding there on July 20, 2019 was beyond the most amazing experience in my life time :) I received the best service from a great person named *Jordana* let me tell you she was there with me all the time I’m 6 months pregnant don’t know nothing about these weddings and she made me feel happy and ready to go, my guests were amazed with her service as well they said wow she is like family! &&& also big thanks to ivonne, bridal attended and amazing staff - thank you everyone for making my wedding dream come true !!! I recommend doing wedding any party there!!!“

4.7 Superb60 Reviews
Whitby Castle Caterers • $$$
330 Boston Post Rd, Rye - 8.01 miles

“Niki and Ralph made our wedding planning, and wedding day very special!! Niki and Ralph were so easy to work with and extremely professional. All of our guest were extremely impressed with the venue, the staff, and the food. We are eternally grateful for our experience with Niki, Ralph, and Whitby Castle. Jordan and I would 100% recommend Whitby Castle!!!“

4.8 Superb41 Reviews
Gyrolicious Mediterranean • $
24a Jericho Turnpike, Jericho - 9.23 miles

Customers` Favorites

Sampler of Souvlaki
Beef and Lamb Gyro
Falafel Sandwich
Chicken Souvlaki
Grilled Octopus
Avgolemono Soup
Galaktobouriko
Zucchini Chips
Fried Calamari
Lemon Potatoes

“For me, consistency is a major factor when it comes to choosing where to eat. Gyrolicious is consistently serving up some of the best Greek food I've had outside of Astoria, and the staff is always very welcoming. The portions are very generous, and never lack in flavor. You can tell they really take pride in serving their customers and the quality of the food they put out. Absolutely recommend!“

4.5 Superb66 Reviews
The Royalton Mansion Caterers • $$
33 Club Dr, Roslyn Heights - 9.97 miles

“From my bride: Book this venue NOW. The Royalton Mansion is a hidden gem that is absolutely beautiful, the food is amazing, and the staff is so kind. We were blown away by EVERYTHING. Mike and Arturo have been amazing since the first day we stepped in the front door to tour the Royalton. They truly make you feel like family. Communication has been very clear and they made us feel right at home. From that first conversation, everything was about us. We were able to make the Royalton our dream wedding and they never said no to any idea or ask.All of our guests have said this is the best wedding they have ever been to. We have received tons of compliments on how beautiful the venue is, the variation and amount of food at cocktail hour, and how every single dinner came out hot and in a timely fashion. All of the staff was professional and cared so much. Arturo was amazing and even gave the groom his own collar stays when we realized he forgot them. Michelle (the bridal attendant) was phenomenal. She kept all 13 bridesmaids organized and fulfilled every need / ask while taking phenomenal care of the bride. She was always around taking care of everyone and was on her feet from 7 am - 11:30 pm. We couldn’t be more thankful for this incredible team. Our wedding night was everything we have dreamed of and more thanks to The Royalton.“

4.8 Superb30 Reviews
Olivia Cooks For You | Meal Prep and Delivery Caterers •
294 3rd avenue ground floor, Brooklyn - 9.17 miles

“Olivia's food is amazing - delicious, healthy, fresh, and a HUGE helper for busy people. She is the consummate pro, and wonderfully attuned to the needs of her clients. Her meals are truly fabulous self-care and also make wonderful gifts. Cannot recommend her highly enough!“

4.7 Superb28 Reviews
Garden Catering - Stamford Chicken • $
235 Main St, Stamford - 9.89 miles

Customers` Favorites

The Og Chicken Sandwich
Bacon Egg & Cheese
BBQ Chicken Wrap
Big Boy Special
Corn Fritters
Nugget Wrap
The Special
Bacon Egg
Cones
Fries

“Been going here for years and always get the nuggets with the cones and the fries. Unfortunately, the portions get smaller as the years go by. The chicken is always consistent and the egg sandwiches are amongst the best in the town I think. The milkshakes are yummy as well and they have different unique wraps. Overall I recommend for a quick bite to eat while in the area.“

4.3 Superb58 Reviews
Laura's BBQ Waterfront Restaurant and Bar Barbecue • $$
76 Shore Rd, Glen Cove - 5.65 miles

Customers` Favorites

Ribs and Pulled Pork Platter
Half Rack and Brisket
Brisket Platter
Buffalo Wings
Mac N

“This place is fantastic!! The wings are perfectly cooked. The ribs are AMAZING! The brisket is cooked to perfection. This place is an absolute hidden gem, if you love BBQ and you live on Long Island you are missing out if you haven’t been here yet. Highly recommend!!“

4.2 Good39 Reviews
Garden Catering - Old Greenwich Chicken • $
185 1/2 Sound Beach Ave, Old Greenwich - 8.42 miles

Customers` Favorites

The Og Chicken Sandwich
Nugget Wrap
Cones
Fries

“Came in here and said to the guy behind the counter that I heard they had the best chicken nuggets ever. He answered with an emphatic yes and couldn't believe I was unaware of this undeniable fact. Wish I caught his name because he was extremely nice and couldn't have been more friendly and helpful for my first time here.And yes they do actually have the best chicken nuggets. I also had the cones (fried mashed potatoes) and onion rings, both of which were delicious.Delicious food and great friendly service. I'll have to check out the other location too that he told me about which is closer to home.“

4.2 Good39 Reviews
Longo's Park Deli Caterers • $$
203 S Regent St, Port Chester - 8.53 miles

“Best deli food ever with amazing customer service, they're fast & super friendly, they remember me even when I don't go in for a couple of months. They also have the best Chipotle mayo I've ever had!! No other deli compares“

4.3 Superb20 Reviews
Kitchen Kabaret Sandwich Shop • $
409 Glen Cove Rd, Roslyn Heights - 9.23 miles

Customers` Favorites

Strawberry Cheesecake Y Fruit Tarts
Pepperoni Pizza with Pepper Flakes
Delicious Homemade Cupcakes
Steak Teriyaki on Lettuce
Strawberry Chocolates
Garlic Knot Sandwich
Roast Beef Sandwich
Chicken Pot Pies
Chicken Sandwich
Seafood Salad

“I'm giving it 4 stars, because I went in looking for lunch, not an additional 10 pounds! Hahaha the food was so good!!! And desert......stop it! I should bill you for the sugar coma I was left in, the cookies, canoli, puddings also so very good. This place is amazing, a whole lot of everything no matter what your taste buds are craving!“

3.9 Good71 Reviews
Barbara's Bagels Caterers • $
113 Mineola Ave, Roslyn Heights - 9.65 miles

Customers` Favorites

Bagel with Lox Spread
Flat Special Bagel
Bagels
Salad

“Corner spot, parking in the back but also parking on the street available. Small spot but the service and delivery of food is really quick. Fresh bagels, delicious bagels. I love bagel and I’d consider myself a bagel tester lol. Ice coffee was fresh and great as well.“

4 Good32 Reviews
Loading...
map Map