Pegasus Brooklyn

$$ • Breakfast, Coffee Shops, Pet Friendly

Menu Order Online

About Pegasus Brooklyn

Pegasus Brooklyn is a popular diner in Bay Ridge, known for its delicious food and attentive service. The menu offers a variety of dishes, with the pancakes being a standout. Vegetarian options are plentiful, and the restaurant is accommodating to vegetarian modifications. The brunch is especially busy, often with about an hour wait, and features favorites like the Kick A** Benedict, although some find the hollandaise sauce to be milder than expected. The hash browns are described as thin, crisp, and flavorful, but sometimes need salt and pepper. The French toast and Huevos Rancheros are highly recommended, with the Greek eggs Benedict, featuring spinach and feta, being a popular choice. The restaurant offers unlimited coffee refills, and the food is considered well-executed with creative twists on classics. Staff are friendly and attentive, creating a warm neighborhood vibe.

Recent reviews highlight that the waffle and chicken are fluffy and on point, with the Kick Axx egg Benedict with bacon being good though the ciabatta can sometimes be too wet to hold its texture. The omelette is light and fresh, allowing customers to adjust sodium levels, which is appreciated. The cold brew coffee has a good balance of acidity and taste, and the staff are friendly and attentive. Many recommend this place for brunch, noting good prices for the portions. One reviewer mentioned a 40-minute wait on a Saturday morning.

Overall, Pegasus Brooklyn remains a highly recommended spot for tasty food and good service, especially for brunch enthusiasts. The Greek Benny is praised for being quick, flavorful, and filling, and the coffee is highly appreciated. While the staff could be more welcoming, the overall experience is positive, with large portions and a clean environment.