Sailor & Siren
Seafood, Hot Dogs, Pet FriendlyAbout Sailor & Siren
Customers' Favorites
Fresh Lobster Rolls
Sailor & Siren Reviews
72 ratings
Share your opinion about Sailor & Siren
Insanely great tasting food, and very friendly service!!
Best lobster roll in the city! Highest quality of the lobster and the bread! Wish they had more seating inside.
They put a lot of lobster in the roll, so it definitely feels like you’re getting your money’s worth. The roll was also delicious and better than the lobster rolls I had in Maine 🙈
Hours
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | Closed |
| Thursday | Closed |
| Friday | 12 - 8PM |
| Saturday | 12 - 8PM |
| Sunday | 12 - 8PM |
Sailor & Siren in Greenpoint is celebrated for serving some of the best lobster rolls outside of Maine. Customers praise the generous amount of lobster in each roll, feeling it offers great value. The lobster is fresh, sweet, and plentiful, with many describing the meat as tender and perfectly cooked. Unlike traditional Maine lobster rolls that are often tossed in mayonnaise, Sailor & Siren’s rolls highlight the lobster's natural flavor, allowing it to shine on its own. The bread is crispy and buttery on the outside and soft inside, adding to the overall enjoyment. Some reviews mention adding lemon or seasoning to enhance the flavor, but many find the lobster delicious enough without extra ingredients. The restaurant also offers a lobster dip that many find tasty.
The space is small but charming, decorated with a pastel color aesthetic, and creates a fun, upbeat vibe with lively music. The staff are friendly, helpful, and accommodating, often going above and beyond—such as providing a birthday treat like a whoopie pie and wishing happy birthday. Despite being a casual spot, Sailor & Siren impresses with quick service and great prices, making it a favorite for lobster lovers. Visitors often express a strong desire to return and recommend it highly to friends. The restaurant is open on weekends and is known for its simple, direct menu, focusing on quality lobster and a lively atmosphere. Overall, Sailor & Siren offers a memorable lobster roll experience that combines freshness, flavor, and excellent service.