Bailey Seafood
$ • SeafoodAbout Bailey Seafood
Customers' Favorites
Lobster Tail & Shrimp Bowl
Shrimp & Rice Shrimp & Lobster
The Fish Fries Slaw and Tartar
Hushpuppies - Southern Style
Super Haddock Sandwich
Fish and Shrimp Combo
Macaroni and Cheese
Fried Fish Dinner
Chicken Fingers
Banana Pudding
Bailey Seafood Reviews
217 ratings
Share your opinion about Bailey Seafood
I used to order from here back in the 90s when it was under different management. Recently, I ordered from there while in town. It wasn't bad but it was nothing like it used to be. The menu is different, the seafood salad I used to order was better years ago and they don't have the same variety of fish they used to have now that they are under this management. It was okay..
I got the fish platter today and I must say it was outstanding. The fish was fresh. The collard greens were awesome. The mac and cheese wasn't bad and the rice was off the chain. My recommendations is going on a weekday. Don't go on a Friday the busiest day or go any other day and you'll be in and out in no time
Why I’ve been living in Buffalo since 1999 and no one told me about this place … THIS IS AMAZING FRESH FOOD. Fish , shrimp, fries , hush puppies 100/100 MAC N CHEESE OVER THE TOP. Coleslaw LORD knows this will be my NUMBER ONE BI-weekly MEAL… thank you guys everything was BEYOND DELICIOUS
Hours
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | 3 - 7PM |
| Wednesday | 3 - 7PM |
| Thursday | 3 - 7PM |
| Friday | 11:30AM - 8PM |
| Saturday | 3 - 7PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
Bailey Seafood is a neighborhood staple, known for its busy Fridays. While the slim parking may not be an issue for most, the service has been reported as inconsistent. Some customers have experienced mistakes with their orders, such as being served shrimp instead of fish and chips, and staff sometimes respond with rudeness or unprofessional behavior. One customer noted that despite the wait times due to the restaurant's popularity, the staff eventually found their order that had been ready the whole time, but the staff's decision to "mitigate the situation by lying" was frustrating.
Recent reviews highlight that the food is generally good, with the fried fish dinner being seasoned well and the fish fried perfectly. The seafood cocktail sauce was fantastic, and the fish sandwich was delicious with tasty bread. The seafood boil looks tempting, and customers have mentioned they would try it next time. However, some meals, like the greens, were not to everyone's taste, tasting unexpectedly sweet and not typical. The fries could also be better, as they were greasy and not very crunchy.
Overall, Bailey Seafood offers reliable seafood with tasty dishes, but the service quality and consistency could improve.