11 Best Pizza Restaurants near Castile

“I arrived less than 5 minutes before closing and the staff member who took my order was very polite in asking if take out was okay, since they were closing soon. I ordered a turkey bacon cheddar melt on marbled rye and it was excellent. The homemade chips were amazing. The price was quite reasonable, too.“

“I was in today to have lunch with my young grandsons, Michelle are waitress was wonderful! Food was great! Prices very reasonable!! Highly recommend!!“

“I am in Nunda just about every weekend and is a sad time when I can't get there once. Have had several different categories of food and all have been awesome. Owner is super friendly and knows alot of people by name. Is a good place to stop if your in the area.“

“Great pizza, will order again.“

“Eaten there a couple times. If distance (750 miles) weren't a roadblock, we would eat there often especially cod on Fridays.“

“100 percent satisfied. Thank you!“

“Every time I’ve been there it’s been great. Friendly and helpful staff.“

“We had ordered from here last night and it was our first time and we just had moved in the area and they were so welcoming and friendly!! Gave us some brownies with our pizza with a little bag that said welcome! The pizza was real good too!! 10/10 for sure!!!“

“This is an amazing little all-in-one restaurant that features North American, Southern as well as pizza and an ice cream shop all in one. They have daily and weekly specials. The food is fresh and they deliver as fast as they can given the volume of people they get. Well worth the money. Adding pictures of the menu as of September 2025 for those that have been questioning price differences check out my pictures!!“

“had the Philly cheese sub for lunch today and it was delicious. my order got here quick also.“

“We drove just under 2 hours to Stony Brook State Park, enjoyed the day and then decided to get some food at a local spot on the way home and picked High Banks Tavern. The food was really delicious. I would love to eat here again. Very intimate little place with one server taking care of about 10 tables plus the bar and they had non stop take out orders. Our server (younger gentleman) was calm, friendly, and hustlin! Our entire party of 4 couldn't say enough about the cheese curds, they were some of the best we've ever had, two of us agreed. My chicken sandwich was quite good as well, the rosemary fries get the MVP award tho. I am not much of a potato eater but I love rosemary, so I rolled the dice and I think they might be my new standard for a French fry. I loved them. Crispy, warm, and tasty. HBT is a great little place I'd love to be a local! We also really loved the new establishment next door, If you are local or in the area go check out Lewiston Waffles. We couldn't resist when we saw one walk by the window while waiting for our meal so we made sure to save room. Great experience!“