12 Best Pizza Restaurants near Castile

1 Wolf Creek Deli

4.5 Superb 181 Reviews

104 North Main Street, Castile

• Delivery

“Wandered into Wolf Creek Deli after another rough afternoon fighting an opossum for half a gas station hot dog. Immediately knew this place would be a local gem. Their sandwiches and quesadillas are excellent, but the homemade soups are the main event. Absolutely DELICIOUS. Made from scratch. Warm, creamy, and comforting. Much better than the mysterious liquids I’ve been drinking out of a Campbell’s soup can behind the bowling alley. Then I discovered the homemade cookies. ENORMOUS. Bought one for later, ate it immediately. Went right back for another and told them it was for my children. I do not have children. Five stars. Left with crumbs in my fur and a renewed sense of purpose. Will absolutely return no matter how many times they tell me I can’t bring my own Tupperware and fill it directly from the soup pot. 🦝 5/5 would be their substitute assistant manager.”

2 Parkside Diner

4.7 Superb 223 Reviews

6240 NY-19A, Castile

• Delivery

“this place is good , real good , wife , and , I were cruzen around , went to the park then site seeing , we were hungry , stopped , wow , the food in good , server's are very nice , we try to get there as much as we can , we are 100ish miles away , but , this place is worth every bite , keep rolling .”

3 Mel's Eatery

4.6 Superb 81 Reviews

19 North State Street, Nunda · 7.33 miles

• Take-Out

“I am in Nunda just about every weekend and is a sad time when I can't get there once. Have had several different categories of food and all have been awesome. Owner is super friendly and knows alot of people by name. Is a good place to stop if your in the area.”

4 Charcoal Corral

4.7 Superb 386 Reviews

7037 Chapman Avenue, Perry · 1.72 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Spent the evening playing mini golf, checking out the classic cars at the car cruise, grabbing a bite to eat and ice cream all before catching a movie at the drive in. Food was good service was good! We didnt choose a very good movie but no fault of the Corral!”

5 Doughboys Pizzeria

4.4 Superb 84 Reviews

28 North State Street, Nunda · 7.3 miles

“We had ordered from here last night and it was our first time and we just had moved in the area and they were so welcoming and friendly!! Gave us some brownies with our pizza with a little bag that said welcome! The pizza was real good too!! 10/10 for sure!!!”

6 Daryl's Pizzeria

4.3 Superb 192 Reviews

163 South Main Street, Perry · 2.47 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“Eaten there a couple times. If distance (750 miles) weren't a roadblock, we would eat there often especially cod on Fridays.”

7 Country Kitchen Restaurant

4.3 Superb 134 Reviews

34 South Main Street, Perry · 2.73 miles

• Take-Out

“Every time I’ve been there it’s been great. Friendly and helpful staff.”

8 Pizanos Warsaw Pizzeria

4.3 Superb 100 Reviews

425 North Main Street, Warsaw · 8.83 miles

• Delivery

“I hosted a baby shower here and it was the perfect location! Affordable large room! The process to rent the space was so easy! I would recommend this to anyone! We brought our own food because of the theme which was so nice to be able to bring outside food and drinks in!”

9 Silver Springs Pizza Depot

4.3 Superb 93 Reviews

130 North Main Street, Silver Springs · 4.51 miles

“Great pizza, will order again.”

10 Stefano's Pizzeria (New York Style)

3.9 Good 138 Reviews

12 North Main Street, Warsaw · 8.11 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“100 percent satisfied. Thank you!”

11 High Banks Tavern

4.2 Good 282 Reviews

36 Main Street, Mount Morris · 7.02 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“We drove just under 2 hours to Stony Brook State Park, enjoyed the day and then decided to get some food at a local spot on the way home and picked High Banks Tavern. The food was really delicious. I would love to eat here again. Very intimate little place with one server taking care of about 10 tables plus the bar and they had non stop take out orders. Our server (younger gentleman) was calm, friendly, and hustlin! Our entire party of 4 couldn't say enough about the cheese curds, they were some of the best we've ever had, two of us agreed. My chicken sandwich was quite good as well, the rosemary fries get the MVP award tho. I am not much of a potato eater but I love rosemary, so I rolled the dice and I think they might be my new standard for a French fry. I loved them. Crispy, warm, and tasty. HBT is a great little place I'd love to be a local! We also really loved the new establishment next door, If you are local or in the area go check out Lewiston Waffles. We couldn't resist when we saw one walk by the window while waiting for our meal so we made sure to save room. Great experience!”

12 Leaning Tower

3.9 Good 230 Reviews

25 Main Street, Mount Morris · 7.05 miles

• Take-Out
• Delivery

“had the Philly cheese sub for lunch today and it was delicious. my order got here quick also.”